The EDA tools are often given for almost free to startups, as the vendors recognise startups can't start without them, and if they are too expensive to a fledgling company they are shooting themselves in the foot. Startups get the tools, but not the support. I'm in HW chip design and use EDA tools daily, and while they are not always great, I would not be as concerned about them for a startup as I would getting enough money to create the first prototype, fab costs, lab equipment costs, man years of engineering, and of course the IP.
Re:Semiconductor Startups – Are they back?
by ancharm on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:26AM
(#26712144)
Though they are essentially given for free, stitching everything together is still a lot of work. Getting the tools as an individual is not really possible (with the exception of Mentor sometimes..) the open source software ecosystem needed around every tool is non-existent, which means that each company ends up recreating their own scripts and flows each time you want to design a new IP.
The tools are still kind of rubbish in the sense that for many startups in software their edge could literally just be having an extremely good internal development flow whereas EDA stuff seems to be written solely to get from A to B.
I haven't seen the deep end of the software as you get closer to the fab, but I'm guessing it's worse.
Re:Semiconductor Startups – Are they back?
by tails4e on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @05:00AM
(#26709657)
A HW startup will not be suddenly successful because of their EDA flow. They could however fail badly if they have their EDA incorrectly setup, as if your chip STA flow was incorrect and you have hold time issues on silicon, you just blew 6 months+ and a few million. It would be critical to have an STA expert for that reason, as well as a solid sign-off process before tape out.
Re:Semiconductor Startups – Are they back?
by monocasa on Monday April 05, 2021 @08:47AM
(#26698244)
You need the support though to know why the crappy tools are breaking your design and be able to hack around it.
Re:Semiconductor Startups – Are they back?
by tails4e on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @04:55AM
(#26709631)
Yes and no, if a startup has experienced designers, they can work around issues. I've often done this and I have access to AEs, as to get an issue resolved externally takes more time than a bit of debug on why the tool is not doing what you want. Rarely is the issue an actual tool bug, but often a tool quirk with some esoteric solution. The issue with most of these EDA tools is their million configuration variables, and that they rarely do something useful out of the box. And experienced designer knows the edges on this and will work fine without support.
Re:Semiconductor Startups – Are they back?
by DivisionSol on Monday April 05, 2021 @04:06AM
(#26696431)
I don my tinfoil hat with you. EDA tools are intentionally opaque to maximize IP capture. I have no skin in the game, nor do I have hardware/circuit development experience... But every time I want to dabble as a Hobby-ist it's clear: "You're not allowed to experiment."
Starting that train now is quite difficult. Lots of inertia to overcome with pre-existing closed source tools being chosen by default at colleges and companies.
God bless Claire Wolf
While EDAs truly are ridiculous expensive garbage, their cost is a pocket change in the age of billion dollar startups without a selling product.
It's just you actually have to make some working product in semiconductors, it's a substantial technical undertaking, and thus a big turn off for the aforementioned billion dollar internet startups.
Re:Semiconductor Startups – Are they back?
by monocasa on Monday April 05, 2021 @08:42AM
(#26698213)
The six figure per seat cost of cadence is a lot to the point of being unobtainable for even early stage of what would become unicorns.
It's not like giant checks are generally being written to these startups that have no users and no engineering done yet.
Re:Semiconductor Startups – Are they back?
by varispeed on Monday April 05, 2021 @12:23PM
(#26700994)
Isn't that, at least for digital application, many chips can be replaced with FPGA, CPLD or just a good old CPU?
Only recently you can see some companies reproducing audio IC from the 80s, but not much of original work. It seems like there is a huge niche in that space, but probably companies think it is too small to be profitable.
The same companies that make the EDA tools also make IP blocks that semiconductor companies purchase, so it's in their best interest to prevent an open source hardware scene from thriving. I get that making masks for a chip is expensive for a startup. But if the design, verification, and layout steps were cheaper and more streamlined, I would bet money that the fab costs would work their way down in clever and creative ways.