News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by dang on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:18PM (#26693689)
Please don't take HN threads into religious flamewar.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by Ozzie_osman on Sunday April 04, 2021 @12:17PM (#26690696)
Not that I agree with Salafists at all, but it's odd that many people's reaction to this is to mention them.

To a large degree, local so-called Salafists (at least the politicized ones) have been largely silenced, imprisoned, and otherwise "dealt with" since 2013.

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by inglor_cz on Sunday April 04, 2021 @02:15PM (#26691615)
I know what happens to prominent Salafists under Sisi, but that is no guarantee of future development.

Most of them have survived with their heads temporarily down, but not off. A massive reservoir of angry manpower waiting for the moment that the regime starts going wobbly.

If the history of totalitarian movements in Europe can be used as an analogy, the question of "who is going to rule Egypt in twenty years" is far from settled.

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by Mediterraneo10 on Sunday April 04, 2021 @01:53PM (#26691453)
I spent two months hitchhiking around Egypt in 2008, after coming down from Europe and passing through the countries along the way. I found Egypt to be by far the most Salafist-leaning of the countries I passed through, far stricter in its understanding of Islam than Turkey or the Levant. When mentioning the Ancient Egyptian past to the average Egyptian (i.e. not some Cairo elites), the response was usually that even talking about all that was haram.

So, when a person's firsthand experience of Egypt was like that, naturally one of the first things that will come to mind is “Hmm, I wonder how the local Egyptian people felt about this procession.” I do find it hard to believe that the population has become less strict in its interpretation since 2013, even if their room for applying their beliefs politically has narrowed.

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by Ozzie_osman on Sunday April 04, 2021 @02:14PM (#26691600)
Sorry you had that experience. I grew up in Egypt and don't think it's representative. Some regions might be like that, or you may have gotten unlucky.

A non-trivial part of the Egyptian population is employed in tourism. It's not all about Ancient Egypt, but that's the main attraction, so many people not only are OK discussing it, they're making a living out of it. Ancient Egyptian history is taught in public school curriculum, etc. Even the national soccer team's nickname is the "Pharaohs".

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by Mediterraneo10 on Sunday April 04, 2021 @02:40PM (#26691784)
I feel my experience was representative, because Egypt clearly consists mainly of a somewhat freethinking elite around the capital and a conservative proletariat within the capital's poorer districts and everywhere else in the country. The elite might have the power to decide the public school curriculum, for example, and if you spent all your time within the elite it might seem like a whole world in itself. Nevertheless the religious masses still vastly outnumber them.

I was told by Cairo elites that a major change in Egypt since the 1990s or so was the increasing pressure the masses were putting on the elites. For example, if you ran a business and you did not have the prayer bump on your forehead, your customers might question your religiosity and take their business elsewhere. And the stricter veiling of urban Egyptian women compared to accounts from the mid-20th-century was obvious. Again, I don’t know what might have changed in that regard since the revolution.

That people are employed in tourism to the Ancient Egyptian past does not necessarily mean acceptance of the Ancient Egyptian past. There are a number of Muslim countries that derive income from tourism that is at odds with a strict understanding of Islam, but devout Muslims are willing to look the other way (and perhaps tell themselves that this is just a temporary thing until the great sharia future ushers in an equitable economy for everyone).

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by simlevesque on Sunday April 04, 2021 @05:51PM (#26693149)
> I feel my experience was representative

Everyone does.

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by dotancohen on Sunday April 04, 2021 @03:08PM (#26691981)
Do contemporary Egyptians consider the current Egyptian state to be a successor state to the ancient Egyptians? Do they consider their culture to be a development of the ancient culture?

Serious question from someone who has been to Egypt but not fully digested the culture or the people. Thanks.

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by Ozzie_osman on Sunday April 04, 2021 @03:41PM (#26692226)
Not really. Keep in mind after the Ancient Egyptians, Egypt was ruled by many empires (Roman, Greek, Islamic, British). Egypt basically only got its independence after thousands of years of foreign rule in the last century.

So it's viewed as part of the country's heritage but not necessarily culture or state.

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by dotancohen on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:13PM (#26693658)
Another question, then, if I haven't overstayed my welcome.

Did Egyptians consider themselves a distinct nation under thousands of years of foreign rule, or did they consider themselves Romans at some point, then Greeks, then Islamic, etc (obviously not British)? Or did they always consider themselves an independent nation?

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by fakedang on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:36PM (#26693788)
Egypt is like India in that any invaders who settled down there assimilated into the local culture pretty soon enough. The Greeks assimilated into the Egyptian kingdom during the reign of Ptolemy. Roman governors did the same, adopting Egyptian customs and of course intermarriage (cue Mark Antony). The Umayyads did not assimilate as much, often forcing the locals to adopt their stricter religious stances (like modern day Islamists). And like that, they suffered from lack of popularity and eventually revolts in Egypt (along with Iraq, Iran and anywhere not in Arabia), which led to the Abbasid Caliphate. The Abbasids ruled from Baghdad, but Cairo was given significant importance like an Eastern capital of sorts. When the Abbasids soon began declining due to internal weakness, Egypt gained more importance gradually at the expense of Baghdad. Saladin, a Kurd, ended up ruling from Cairo himself. When Baghdad fell because of the Mongols, Cairo effectively became the preeminent Muslim authority up until the conquest of Constantinople. Ottoman pashas often assimilated into the local culture. In fact, the first ruler of Egypt who fought for its independence from the Ottoman Empire was an Ottoman Pasha himself.

Edit:- also helped massively that Egypt controlled the Suez, and the proximity of Cairo and Alexandria (which Baghdad lacked) meant that the spice trade would inevitably make the Egyptians more prosperous. And of course prosperity leads to autonomy.

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by dotancohen on Monday April 05, 2021 @09:38AM (#26698768)
Thank you so much. Many of these cultures I know of only in passing, and you've connected many dots for me. For the rest, I'm off to Wikipedia.

Thank you!

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by selimthegrim on Sunday April 04, 2021 @08:14PM (#26694036)
A pasha of Albanian origin
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by dotancohen on Sunday April 04, 2021 @04:53PM (#26692737)
I see, thank you.
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by doktorhladnjak on Sunday April 04, 2021 @06:24PM (#26693362)
It's complicated. Copts (about 20% of the population) in Egypt are the most direct descendants of the ancient Egyptians. Greeks, Arabs, Ottomans, British, French invaded and took control at various points in between. Arabs brought Islam and Arabic language to Egypt with most Copts being Christian and no longer speaking Coptic (a language descended from ancient Egyptian) today, there's additional tension and politics.
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by akhenptah on Sunday April 04, 2021 @08:14PM (#26694043)
Not exactly.

“Copt” means Egyptian and was used by the Turkish decedents ruling class to refer to Egyptians regardless of religion.

So all Egyptians are Copts. Some Copts are Christian

The church, sometimes referred to as the Coptic church literally meant “the Egyptian church” and played a key role and maybe to this day, for example with a bishop sent to Ethiopia.

As for “who think of themselves as a descendant of those mummies?” Pretty much all Egyptians do, the national soccer team is often referred to in Africa as “the pharaohs”. Of course some Arabs Turks Greeks Armenians British and French stayed over the 1000s of years but given the population was already well established over confined space(3% of Egypt is populated, mainly around the Nile and coast) the influx couldn’t overtake the indigenous population.

This is not just some fantasy / wishful thinking either. If you observe farming habits, certain traditions, specific tools, fishing, sailing etc, you can see a very long and continuous way of being. It is called “maat”

Some studies concluded 98% genetic makeup overlap between the ancient and modern Egyptians. There is such a thing as “Egyptian ethnic group”. Travel through the streets and you will see the resemblance. TV shows? Not so much.

With that said, the Egyptian constitution of 1920s declared “the Egyptian is anyone who wishes to declare themselves Egyptian”.

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by dotancohen on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:15PM (#26693675)
Thank you, I did not know that the Copts are descended from ancient Egyptians. Does any of the ancient culture survive with them? You mention that the language is almost gone, but how about foods or clothing? Methods of construction, or methods of keeping cool in summer, or crafts?
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by JetAlone on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:35PM (#26693779)
Coptic is still used as a liturgical language, but yes there are very few speakers of it.
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by selimthegrim on Sunday April 04, 2021 @08:12PM (#26694025)
There were Arabs living in eastern Egypt for centuries before the Islamic conquest
[dead]
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by Ozzie_osman on Sunday April 04, 2021 @01:04PM (#26691075)
People have been imprisoned, tortured physically and mentally, and killed for being part of (or just being accused of being a part of) certain religious/political groups.

I find it hard to say "good" about that, even if I disagree with the group they are a part of.

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by TheMblabla on Sunday April 04, 2021 @01:38PM (#26691361)
Is this a cosplay account? the real Henry kissinger probably would be in favor of political prisoners.
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by yk on Sunday April 04, 2021 @03:04PM (#26691946)
Considering there was a US backed coup, I have a hunch considering Kissingers realpolitik in this case.
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by Solocomplex on Sunday April 04, 2021 @02:09PM (#26691572)
No respect for those of us who still worship Ra.
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by nafizh on Sunday April 04, 2021 @12:21PM (#26690725)
Don't want to give a political opinion as people are entitled to their own. But as a religious fact, it is prohibited in Islam to show veneration of any kind to pagan traditions or celebrations because of its strict commitment to monotheism. So, bringing in salafists into this to show this is an extreme position is factually incorrect.
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by Ozzie_osman on Sunday April 04, 2021 @12:37PM (#26690871)
I am a Muslim and have at no point considered celebrating non-Muslim ancestors as being wrong or prohibited. None of Muslim friends think that either. I am aware that some Muslims might, but it is not by any means a religious fact.
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by egeozcan on Sunday April 04, 2021 @01:00PM (#26691042)
I'm not a Muslim but I've read the Quran. I can confirm that there it says not to worship any entity other than Allah and it says nothing about "celebrating" them being prohibited.

It does say a lot of bad things (to put it extremely mildly) about people worshiping other deities, especially idols, though.

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by nethunters on Sunday April 04, 2021 @03:16PM (#26692050)
Understanding the Quran literally is not the only way Islamic law is derived.

According to the four Schools of Jurisprudence in the Sunnis and the Ja'fari Schools of Jurisprudence in the Shias Islamic law is derived from the following sources: - Quran and Quranic exegesis - Ahaadith (prophetic traditions) - Ijmaa' (consensus) - Qiyaas (analogy - limited use cases and remit)

This is a ruling that is held by each of the Schools of Jurisprudence in the Sunnis and the Ja'fari School of Jurisprudence of the Shias.

As a side note the modern day Salafis/Wahabis/Ahlul Hadith literally interpret the Quran and Ahaadith (Prophetic Traditions) which is how they reach rulings that differ from the accepted Schools of Jurisprudence that have had millions of scholars over centuries work together.

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by whoisburbansky on Sunday April 04, 2021 @01:18PM (#26691198)
The Old Testament Bible says similar things about worshipping other deities, idols, etc. The literal first commandment explicitly prohibits it.
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by ClumsyPilot on Sunday April 04, 2021 @01:58PM (#26691494)
The old testament has some pretty crazy, hairy and barbaric stuff in it.

Literal taking of religious texts is generally incompatible with moderm civilised society

Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by whoisburbansky on Sunday April 04, 2021 @02:24PM (#26691683)
I agree wholeheartedly, which is why felt like I had to point this out to someone seemingly taking another religious text quite literally.
Re:Egypt holds grand procession of ancient mummies in Cairo by nethunters on Sunday April 04, 2021 @02:54PM (#26691878)
What you consider is not religious fact.

This is a religious law that is agreed upon by each of the Schools of Jurisprudence in the Sunnis and the Shias.

Edit - This is not meant to be demeaning. What I meant is that religious law in Islam is not based on what is considered to be acceptable or not by a few people. Also what a person and their friends consider a ruling to be is not representative for all Muslims.