Re:Microsoft Coffee
by gkop on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:59PM
(#26673272)
No, we have tone and punctuation to disambiguate the two interpretations here. Parent commenter interpreted correctly. If the grandparent’s intention was otherwise, they should have used a comma.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
It's a good example of how ambiguity can arise when humans use (or don't use) punctuation and other features of a language that's been evolving for centuries, to communicate across an instantaneous worldwide medium with little effort
Well said.
They didn't interpret it correctly, and there's no rule stating a comma is necessary that's universal in every style-guide.
They interpreted incorrectly per English grammar. We don’t know whether they interpreted correctly or incorrectly per the utterer’s intention, as the utterer has not clarified their intention.
This isn’t a question of style, but one of grammar.
Re:Microsoft Coffee
by Dylan16807 on Friday April 02, 2021 @06:20PM
(#26676567)
It's not that simple. Commas are lawless.