Not all of them though. They thought tip-only wages, child labor and openly paying different rates based on people's ethnicity were all reasonable practices. Ford would have people inspect his workers home and would dump them if they were being too "foreign", I mean we are talking Lochner era here.
It's a mixed bag. Culture is some amorphous blob, stretching one way and ceding ground the other. You could get a decent paying union job in 1920 without a highschool education but you could be fired for infidelity with your wife, miscegenation, being gay, etc. And just forget about gender equality.
It'd be nice if we could "buffet" practices from the past and skip over the ones we find distasteful.
That's the case that people (rightly or wrongly) are referring to when they say that companies have an "obligation to maximise profits".
The war described in the article is waged on both sides. The workers themselves are acting as mercenaries - understandable given the conditions. And clearly a business can't extract maximum value from a worker that has absolutely no loyalty.
On a whole though I find the article weak. It's just a hope for an ideal situation with no idea of how to get there. "Can't we all just get along?" - it's clear that no, that state of affairs does not simply spring itself into being.
While today we can debate the growing chasm between worker productivity and wages, it iss important to remember that for over 60 years after this article was written:
- Management practices continued to become more rigorously productivity oriented
- Wages rose in tandem and in proportion to productivity
For all of the faults debated over taylorism and the defects that have developed in our system a century later, on the merits of those points I would say this article has aged well.
BTW, I don't think Friedman was arguing that corporations should engage in criminal negligence - just that they should not be working explicitly for the good of the society. What was paramount was shareholder value. Probably it is understood that maximizing shareholder value is to be done within legal limits.
I agree that maximizing shareholder value is expected to be done within legal limits, but also basic ethical limits. I’m not an expert in Union Carbide’s history, but I was under the impression that the company was hollowed out after selling off assets to pay the Bhopal settlement, and Dow eventually acquired it along with its liabilities for a fraction of what its market cap would have been without the disaster. Criminal negligence can erase a huge amount of shareholder value.
In a different or malfunctioning legal system you could imagine the Indian courts not holding the shareholders responsible for their negligence, the way the US justice department failed to hold the financial industry responsible in 2008 for instance. Smarter people than I have pegged the rise of populist politics in the US as a delayed response to this political and legal failure to wipe out shareholders of corporations that took risks which harmed the economy.