News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by Lev1a on Monday March 29, 2021 @12:58PM (#26624766)
When the first thing I see after opening a website is some sort of "Give us your email just for some useless newsletter honest" popup I just close the site as fast as I can.

How ITF can such a disgustingly annoying UX element still be so prevalent on certain genres of websites?

Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by MaxBarraclough on Monday March 29, 2021 @01:24PM (#26625196)
I suppose there's no reputational cost if it has become the norm.

The same thing has happened with We care about your privacy dark-patterns. Otherwise reputable sites like Tom's Hardware pay little reputation cost for trying to trick the user into granting full cookie permissions.

Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by site-packages1 on Monday March 29, 2021 @02:12PM (#26625928)
I have thought about this a bit. My take is that almost all of these blog posts are from one-off contributors and not one you'll see over and over. I kind of see it as them taking their shot as making you a recurring visitor or recurring reader of their content. I've personally never heard of Statista and don't think I ever will again, if past experience is an indicator. I don't fault them for that, although it is slightly annoying.

Though if it were me, I'd personally wait until someone was partway through the article at least before presenting a newsletter sign up. There's no way I'd sign up for a newsletter before I saw the site's content.

Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by kevincox on Monday March 29, 2021 @03:46PM (#26627243)
I do exactly the same. If I see a popup covering a significant portion of the popup I just close the tab. It is rare that I am interested enough to actually click though, when the title is "Facebook tracks you" it definitely isn't worth it to me.

But I guess it is clear that we are the oddballs. If everyone was like is these behaviours would disappear.

Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by mobileexpert on Monday March 29, 2021 @12:30PM (#26624290)
This is a bizarrely misleading take from iOS 14 privacy labels. Use for ads optimization/measurement/targeting does not mean sharing with third parties for FB/IG or anyone who runs their own ads stack.
Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by CharlesW on Monday March 29, 2021 @02:05PM (#26625818)
Privacy labels also tell you if your data is being shared with third parties.
Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by Urgo on Monday March 29, 2021 @02:50PM (#26626499)
The data is sourced from pCloud[1]. Highly recommend checking their site out if you want to know more then the linked story's summary. They show what each of the referenced categories are and also compare it to a whole slew of other apps.

[1] https://blog.pcloud.com/invasive-apps/

Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by elvis70 on Monday March 29, 2021 @12:39PM (#26624445)
And statista.com contribute to it as they share cookies with Facebook after their cookie manager. Unless you click on the small text "Confirm my choices" instead of the big blue button.
Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by yalogin on Monday March 29, 2021 @01:44PM (#26625484)
Its not clear what this is. May be I am overthinking this but it could be one of two --

1. Is Instagram collecting a lot of data and sharing 79% of that with third parties on their end?

2. Is Instagram collecting 79% of the user data available to third party apps on iOS?

If it's 1, as I suspect it is, then is it through their ads sdk? If so, how does an external entity get this estimate of 79%?

So many other questions come up too. Why is it listed separately from FB app? Do they have a separate ad sdk for Instagram and FB? I thought the number just means that Instagram is more valuable to services and so buy more there.

[dead]
Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by rhacker on Monday March 29, 2021 @12:42PM (#26624498)
As of right now yes, the US government is making records public such as who you marry, where you live, in some cases your salary. It's pretty bad we don't condemn that first.

All of this info is generally public because of our legal system requiring we be able to find people we need to sue. It's all old and needs to be rebuilt from the ground up. Then again, when the millennials do that (you know when they are 60 years old), they will inevitably build in a way to be sue proof.

Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by varispeed on Monday March 29, 2021 @01:00PM (#26624802)
Many governments do censuses from time to time where they ask invasive private questions and people can't even object to that. So this is kind of a step forward to make it real-time rather having a snapshot of population. Plus not many people will actually file one, even if there is a fine for not doing so, simply because they don't exist in the system, but they may exist on Facebook.
Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by reaperducer on Monday March 29, 2021 @03:29PM (#26627042)
US government is making records public such as who you marry, where you live, in some cases your salary. It's pretty bad we don't condemn that first.

Why? That's public information that's been collected for hundreds of years. It's used for all kinds of legitimate basic things such as genealogy and public health.

Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by rhacker on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:25PM (#26672890)
The change is that in the last 10 years all of that information has gone online. The creeps love all of that information. It has also lead to people trying to escape things be haunted by it. I know a guy that moved from CA to ID to escape someone trying to murder him. He said he's seen the guy's car drive by his new place...

A drunk driver hit my car a few months ago. He got out of his car and denied the whole thing. Tons of witnesses backing me up. He was fucking scary. I'm just some dude that pulled waaaay off the road to avoid getting hit and now I have to be scared of him coming after me because my insurance is going after him.

I'm sorry you still live in the bubble but revenge murders happen all the time. And 1/3 of all murders are totally unsolved.

There are other records that are abused too. Manta - my favorite company to hate. This place had the habit years ago to purposefully mess up your "public" business listing. Wrong address, misspelled addresses, wrong phone number. It was on purpose because I was able to look at (at the time) all of the unverified businesses and compare it to Google's data. Every single Manta listing that wasn't claimed had a small mistake. Their goal was to take public info and mess it up a bit so that business owners would be frustrated enough to claim it and fix it. I really think we made a huge mistake making public records easily re-publishable online. I just think that each record needs to have a transaction associated with it.

Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by kube-system on Monday March 29, 2021 @02:27PM (#26626162)
The US has laws regarding the collection, use, and sharing of that data.

Commercial data brokers have almost zero restrictions. Anyone can buy basically whatever data they want if they have money: real-time location data, transaction data, browsing history, etc.

You're missing the forest for the trees.

Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by consumer451 on Monday March 29, 2021 @12:35PM (#26624380)
You should check out threat modeling.
Re:Personal Data: Instagram Is a Real Tattletale by mdpopescu on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @09:45AM (#26634536)
I have.

The number of people killed by the US government in the last 50 years dwarfs that of people killed by Facebook by many orders of magnitude.