News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fukushima: It's much worse than you think by PaulHoule on Thursday June 16, 2011 @01:01PM (#2662117)
There's a lot of nonsense in that article. First of all, they keep repeating the words Plutonium and Uranium (particularly "enriched Uranium") and try to suggest that these are the major threats from the accident.

They're not.

Uranium isotopes have a half-life of billions of years, so whatever radioactivity they emit is spread out over a very long time. Overall, uranium is toxic in the same way that lead is toxic, and the chemical toxicity is probably worse than the radiotoxicity. Even in a completely melted reactor core, uranium dioxide is relativly stable and won't be quickly transported into the environment.

The isotopes of concern are primarily of Iodine and Cesium. Radioiodine from the accident has almost completely decayed, although Cesium isotopes may still be hazardous in heavily contaminated areas for years.

Currently there seem to be "hotspots" at considerable distances from the plant where doses on the ground are in a range that's at the edge of what nuclear power workers are permitted to get (but rarely do.) There's no proof that radiation at that level is harmful, but no proof that it's completely safe to have that exposure for your lifetime either.

Now, it's also BS to say that the threat from spent nuclear fuel that's been sitting around for 10 years is as high as the threat from an active core or one that's been sitting around for three months -- it just isn't; radioactivity decays and heat generation goes down, so it's really unfair to count the number of "cores" worth of danger here.

That said, I wouldn't blame people for mistrusting Japanese government, industry and even society. Japan has been the world's leader in nuclear accidents for the past 20 years, and it's often said that they're not completely honest about industrial accidents in general (such as in the auto industry.)

Nuclear safety requires a person who's disciplined and (for the most part) follows orders but who also has a strong individual sense of right and wrong and won't follow a bad order. America's nuclear navy works hard to cultivate this ethos, but I'm not sure if it's easy to cultivate this in Japan.

Re:Fukushima: It's much worse than you think by marshray on Thursday June 16, 2011 @03:06PM (#2662735)
Overall, uranium is toxic in the same way that lead is toxic, and the chemical toxicity is probably worse than the radiotoxicity.

You know darn well we're not talking about "overall uranium".

We're talking about very hot uranium and plutonium directly from the cores of active nuclear reactors and the entire spectrum of elements and isotopes that get produced when you take that core, rods, and support structure and melt it out through the bottom of a containment vessel onto a concrete foundation that wasn't designed as a core catcher. Mix in seawater, steam, hydrogen explosions and gord knows what else and you have a reaction that is insufficiently modeled.

What we do know is that a large area of land is not being occupied in Japan due to contamination. The Japanese have very expensive land, know a thing or two about radioactive contamination, and are not exactly known for exaggerating the impact of industrial accidents.

Re:Fukushima: It's much worse than you think by Confusion on Thursday June 16, 2011 @04:15PM (#2663037)
The uranium in that reactor isn't different from overall uranium, except that it's concentrated and its composition differs from what naturally occurs. However, that's over there. Uranium would be dangerous to US citizens if the uranium was in the US. It isn't. And so far, not even the worst doomsayers that actually know their stuff have worried about uranium or plutonium. That's just not the stuff you care about after a nuclear meltdown. You care about the other isotopes that were produced and that are much more easily carried outside and are easily used to compose other molecules that can spread further.

Secondly, what on earth is 'hot uranium'? If you are speaking about the temperature: it certainly isn't hot anymore by the time it reaches the US. If you are speaking about it's radioactivity, you're wrong: individual uranium atoms from that reactor, once escaped, do not behave differently than naturally occurring uranium atoms.

As for your other fears: it's perfectly well known what radioactive isotopes controlled and uncontrolled fission processes can produce. That's why they've been monitoring for things like cesium, iodine and basically every radioactive isotopes that exists: the number is rather limited). No significant levels of the stuff have been seen in the US.

Re:Fukushima: It's much worse than you think by marshray on Thursday June 16, 2011 @06:38PM (#2663573)
The uranium in that reactor isn't different from overall uranium, except that it's concentrated and its composition differs from what naturally occurs.

That can be a pretty serious categorical difference, particularly in the concentration.

However, that's over there. Uranium would be dangerous to US citizens if the uranium was in the US. It isn't.

Duh.

Did you even read what I wrote or are you pasting this from some talking points you got somewhere?

And so far, not even the worst doomsayers that actually know their stuff have worried about uranium or plutonium.

Which is not to say it's not a problem, only that you find some reason to dismiss the views you don't agree with.

That's just not the stuff you care about after a nuclear meltdown. You care about the other isotopes that were produced and that are much more easily carried outside and are easily used to compose other molecules that can spread further.

That must be why they're setting limits on the acceptable level of uranium in the rice then. To draw attention away from the things that are really dangerous. http://www.businessweek.com/news/2011-03-28/fukushima-may-ab... Riiight.

Secondly, what on earth is 'hot uranium'?

What I said was "very hot uranium and plutonium directly from the cores of active nuclear reactors and the entire spectrum of elements and isotopes that get produced when ...".

If you are speaking about the temperature: it certainly isn't hot anymore by the time it reaches the US. If you are speaking about it's radioactivity,

In this case, the term 'hot' captures temperature (in Celsius), reactivity (neutrons), and the health effects of radioactivity (Becquerels). It works on many levels.

you're wrong: individual uranium atoms from that reactor, once escaped, do not behave differently than naturally occurring uranium atoms.

You really seem to want me to be talking about specifically uranium atoms in fallout on the continental US. The vast majority of that article is about Japan with only a few sentences claiming some nonspecific particles could be detected in the US.

Is it that you know only this one counter argument, the one that natural and low-enriched uranium samples aren't wildly different in decay rates?

As for your other fears:

I'm not afraid, you're just making that up.

it's perfectly well known what radioactive isotopes controlled and uncontrolled fission processes can produce.

I don't think our knowledge of these meltdowns is anywhere close to "perfect", but note that I said "the entire spectrum of elements and isotopes...".

They don't know what temperatures were reached what state of matter the cores were in and for what time periods. The IAEA says there could have been recriticality, but they don't know for sure one way or the other.

That's why they've been monitoring for things like cesium, iodine and basically every radioactive isotopes that exists: the number is rather limited).

Do you think I've never heard of the periodic table or something?

Re:Fukushima: It's much worse than you think by shareme on Thursday June 16, 2011 @03:23PM (#2662813)
put another way most USA houses have a percentage of soil containing uranium..yet only less than 0.1% require any meaningful radon gas decontamination work..

the fuel rods when not used only give off so many isotopes per hour. the problem here is the rods in melted state are not cooled off to non active yet, hence the use of water and other materials to bring their activity down.

Re:Fukushima: It's much worse than you think by shareme on Thursday June 16, 2011 @03:19PM (#2662792)
no you are not! the isotopes from uranium and plutonium fuel rod use and miss use only!
Re:Fukushima: It's much worse than you think by dhyasama on Thursday June 16, 2011 @02:19PM (#2662512)
That last bit reminds me of a Malcolm Gladwell story. I think it was Korea Air that had a terrible safety record and a consultant was brought in to figure it out. Turns out Korean culture strongly discourages questioning your superiors, even in the face of obvious error. Pilots were making mistakes and co-pilots wouldn't correct them.
Re:Fukushima: It's much worse than you think by nasmorn on Friday June 17, 2011 @06:47AM (#2665045)
I once read a story about a Korean aircraft hitting a mountain where the blackbox recorded the last minutes. They copilot and engineer (used to have those too) would only speak up a few seconds before impact. Before that they would only make vague mentions of being off course. It seemed and still seems unbelievable that someone chooses death over telling a superior that he is wrong.
Re:Fukushima: It's much worse than you think by gojomo on Thursday June 16, 2011 @03:12PM (#2662764)
Radioiodine from the accident has almost completely decayed

Given that the accident isn't over – fission is continuing without the normal containment – isn't more radioiodine being created, and at risk of further wide release, every day?

Re:Fukushima: It's much worse than you think by PaulHoule on Thursday June 16, 2011 @04:09PM (#2663010)
There is no more criticality and no more fission than natural spontaneous decay.

Other kinds of radioactive decay continue to release heat in the fuel, which could drive material transfer, but the production of radioiodine is long over.

Re:Fukushima: It's much worse than you think by orblivion on Thursday June 16, 2011 @05:43PM (#2663402)
So why are these things still hot?
Re:Fukushima: It's much worse than you think by saulrh on Thursday June 16, 2011 @11:04PM (#2664174)
Normal radioactive decay. Check out RTGs, which generate electricity without any criticality whatsoever: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_gen...