okay, I'll bite. What is the solution then? We got rid of Fairness Doctrine without putting any other check in place and Fox News successfully argued that no-one in their right mind should take Tucker Carlsen seriously, even though he has the biggest talk show on American TV today. I am guessing they are gonna argue the same in their voter machine cases too.
There should be some way to regulate the news media, no?
To what end? The Fairness Doctrine was little more than a method by which powerful people within the government could service their own vendettas against conservative radio hosts, executed through FCC licensure agreements.
Everything is IP-networked now, and there's no FCC licensure for publishing on the internet so a bloody-minded focus on returning to the glory days of the Fairness Doctrine is really just fighting the last war. Oh and it's effectively government-compelled speech, AKA a blatant and egregious violation of the First Amendment without even the paper thin justification of public-owned airwaves.
And that's not about "fighting the last war"; it's about correcting for the network effects of the Internet that create natural monopolies with too much influence on public discussion.
And that is protecting the free speech rights of users, in an age when the public space is controlled by private corporations, so there's a compelling government interest involved.
Absolutely. I'm not saying that's the best possible solution, but it has the advantage of historical precedent for a similar problem: a few companies have too much influence on public discussion.
And it addresses the flaw in Section 230: companies that act like publishers but claim the protections of platforms.
So is that the best reply you can come up with, or do you have any other reasonable objections besides those I've already addressed?
Your proposal as to how it could work amounts to while the First Amendment does say “Congress shall make no law etc.”, it doesn’t say anything at all about Congress not weasel around it, engage in political blackmail, and make bad law anyway”, just so you can get away with calling it “not technically compelled speech”.
Your motivation appears to be to increase the number of forums in the broadest sense of the term in which people can talk freely as like if they were on government property instead of private property, at the expense of private property rights, that other thing that is integral to a free society and liberty. The mechanism by which you propose to do so would however provide a strong incentive for existing server owners to get out of the forum business thus actually reducing the total number of servers and services connected to the internet on which you can post.
There isn’t anything I can say to your position that you haven’t said yourself if this is seriously your position. I mean it’s immoral, antithetical to both free speech as a cultural phenomenon as well as our laws, antithetical to private property rights, and probably also unconstitutional, and at the very least a massive abuse of legislative authority. I guess if you can convince Congress to pass your proposal, the New York Times and Fox News should also be quaking in their boots at the prospect of turning off their comments sections (do they even still have comments sections?).
My recommendation instead is to make peace with the idea that there’s a website, podcast, subreddit, Facebook group, IRC, Slack and/or Discord channel for every opinion, every gradation of an opinion, and every type of audience. The web is a big place. Not quite as big as the Universe but from our puny positions with our lack of perspective it might as well be as big.
Likewise, any law could be called "blackmail", because they all threaten negative consequences if someone doesn't do what the government says, but that doesn't matter to anyone at all.
Those aren't serious objections to any regulation.
And it's ironic to call this "antithetical to free speech as a cultural phenomenon" when this would be a defense of free speech for 99% of the population.
The rights of a few billionaires who own web companies shouldn't trump the rights of the public.
Finally, where do you get the idea that companies simply couldn't exist if they didn't remove user content that doesn't violate a few regulations the law would allow (like spam, threats, obscenity, and copyright, which would all be clearly Constitutional content-based exceptions)? That reddit, for example, would have to shut down if they hadn't banned The_Donald or ChapoTrapHouse? That would be a fair objection, if you can support it.
So if I want to run a website with comments I need a lawyer to review each comment? Like how am I, a layman, supposed to determine whether a comment violates copyright or is actually fair use? Or whether it's a "true threat" as opposed to bluster ("Next person who comments about X is getting slapped")? What happens if I wrongly remove a comment?
Probably there would be exceptions for personal non-commercial sites and even small businesses. There's plenty of room for compromise between the status quo and draconian rules that shut down every website.
This is something that matters to anyone that owns or aspires to own property and assets: houses, vehicles, servers and other fixed assets, as well as the money in your bank and brokerage accounts. Our economy doesn’t exist without private property rights.
> Likewise, any law could be called "blackmail", because they all threaten negative consequences if someone doesn't do what the government says, but that doesn't matter to anyone at all.
The reason and intent behind a law matters in a democratic society if you prefer laws to be just rather than tyrannical in nature. Section 230 despite the political football it has become was actually a fairly reasonable piece of law. The courts may have come around to similar law through procedure, but by passing it as a statute from the legislature, it quickly resolved what the risks were to running a server other people could use as long as you made a good faith effort to moderate publicly accessible data which enabled the sort of risk-taking that made an interactive web possible. You would take this otherwise fine piece of legislature and smack private entities upside the head with it, and if you can’t see the problem with it, I can’t help you see it.
> And it's ironic to call this "antithetical to free speech as a cultural phenomenon" when this would be a defense of free speech for 99% of the population.
99% is actually a reduction. What part of “Congress shall make no law etc.” is unclear? Generally when two parties have conflicting free speech interests, the property owner wins. That means the owner of the server prevails. You, as a private individual, can purchase your own server, and if you let me post to it, you can kick me off of it and I would have zero remedy.
> The rights of a few billionaires who own web companies shouldn't trump the rights of the public.
As I’ve just outlined, this is not zero sum. There are countless channels in which you can exercise your first amendment rights, but you are not entitled to do so on someone else’s property more than they allow.
> Finally, where do you get the idea that companies simply couldn't exist
Don’t put words in my mouth.
This sounds like another repetition of the same bad legal take on the "rhetorical hyperbole" standard based, probably, on the McDougal case or one similar [1]. That argument is made with respect to particular statements, not that nobody would ever believe anything they say. But don't take my word for it, read how the court in that very case talks about the standard:
"In particular, accusations of “extortion,” “blackmail,” and related crimes, such as the statements Mr. Carlson made here, are often construed as merely rhetorical hyperbole when they are not accompanied by additional specifics of the actions purportedly constituting the crime."
You will note that it's limited to particular statements in a particular context, not everything the person ever said for any reason, nor to anything ever said on the show. This same standard was used in, e.g. the case vs. Larry Flynt[2]. The media loves to misrepresent this argument as applying very broadly to everything a person says whenever it comes up in contexts with a political opponent, but the claims made are far narrower and rely largely on people not bothering to read legal rulings or knowing what on earth "rhetorical hyperbole" is to begin with. If you take this as some defense of Tucker, it's not, the other side does exactly the same thing whenever rhetorical hyperbole comes up.
So basically every time you see the meme "can you believe that X argued in court that nobody would ever believe them" you can be sure that you are seeing this tired misrepresentation of the rhetorical hyperbole standard.
Which seems apropos in an article about the media losing trust, as I know from actually reading a lot of court rulings just how uniformly terrible legal reporting is to the point where I actively mistrust all headlines by all outlets and refuse to consider anything but actual court papers off of Pacer.
Outlets love to put out headlines with unreasonable billion dollar defamation claims (even if actual awards are a tiny fraction thereof and they have no realistic hope of getting anything but a headline because their prayer for relief doesn't have a prayer), or to headline meaningless procedural motions as somehow dispositive (The Supreme Court denied a hail Mary petition for a writ of certiorari to decide whether suit could even be brought in the first place? Quelle surprise! The case must be almost over!), or to talk about "harsh questions" during oral arguments (the side that gets questioned more wins slightly more often, they may be trying to shore up the arguments for their ruling). There are far, far more tropes than this, but seriously, if you care at all about accuracy, take a course or two on legal procedure so that you understand the different courts and levels of appeal and actually read legal rulings.
Granted, that takes at least some small amount of legal education, but honestly, the public has neglected legal literacy for far too long.
[1] https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/new-yor...
https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/20519858/3-22-21-...
She argued that her beliefs were based on disclosed facts (sworn depositions by others), which is a credible defense against defamation.
Inasmuch as you're claiming that she doesn't argue truth as a defense, that's appears to be true based on skimming this brief, but it's also quite common simply because that puts the burden of proof on you and it's much, much easier to argue most other defenses.
So even when a person truly believes that they're right, they often won't argue this point in court, especially not on a contentious political topic. So failing to argue that point isn't quite the indicator one might normally assume it should be, even if it does tend to appear in slam dunk cases.
N.B. I don't think her allegations here are actually true.
That aside, it's not because there is a higher diversity of sources at more diverse scales tosay that the answer is not to look at what worked in the past. Or to simply throw one's hands in the air.
It is not because small ISPs, tech companies, etc. exist that the large conglomerates that impact our daily lives should be left untouched and unregulated. Same goes with news, or masquerades of news.
A good start for instance would to untie news media from the profit motive. NPR exists, the French Radio Publique exists, etc. and they output great content, independently more often than not. It shows that public investment into newsmaking is worthwhile and has often a better quality to it. News reporting should be seen as of public interest, and treated as such rather than as a commodity. Breaking news conglomerates should also be explored.
I can setup a website or twitter handle and get my ideas published out there, but they drown in a sea of similar opinions. I can't compete with the kind of ideological carpet bombing than Fox News, CNN or MSNBC can produce. Money and Capital can buy a much larger bullhorn, so that is what people listen to.
Instead of censorship, Capital simply hoarded all the bandwidth, starving alternative voices of attention.
How now are us newly ennobled modern highly educated professionals supposed to hear voices which no longer exist?
The hysterical bit is social media swiped the control away from advertisers. We've replaced your dreaded hereditary nobility with the mythical meritocracy.
That's... literally not a "fact". It's a situational thing. I mean, just to be glib: almost everything that "worked" in the 1980's works now. Most things haven't changed!
As far as media balance: yes, clearly balance is a good thing. I think forcing Fox to hand over an hour of coverage every evening between Hannity and Tucker to someone like Chris Hayes can only be a net benefit. MSNBC can slot Ingraham in after Maddow. Both their audiences will win, because the networks will have to find a way to keep eyeballs without outrage.
Fox only works as "Fox" because of the echo chamber effect. And that can absolutely be regulated.
This is true, which means it's important to look at the context.
The fairness doctrine was from a time when there was limited airtime. Things were broadcast and anything so broadcast filled space that couldn't be used by something else. Filling the airwaves with a singular opinion literally prevented any others from being carried. The fairness doctrine was meant to counteract this.
Today that technical problem does not exist. Everything is on demand. The economic cost in terms of storage and bandwidth is so low that the likes of YouTube and Facebook can carry everything published by everyone. Problem solved, right? Just carry everything; completely fair.
Except that they reintroduced the scarcity artificially through market consolidation. There are effectively three major cable news networks and every one of them is aligned with a political party.
Because that's what happens when there are so few of them. If you have dozens then they each carve out a niche. One caters to socialists, another to libertarians, another to moderates etc. You get a greater diversity of viewpoints and, importantly, less tribal warfare because there is more overlap between any given pair of outlets.
And it thwarts the even more problematic attempts by partisans to capture the incumbents and enforce ideological conformity through them, because it's not as effective if you have a dozen other competitors who aren't just shills for the other team (and therefore have credibility) rightfully pointing out the lies told by competitors they otherwise agree with and keeping each other honest.
What we need is less media consolidation. More competition. Applies to the media as much as the tech companies.
Both seem to ignore the fact that whatever worked in year X will not work in year X+50, because the society, technology and politics moved on.
One of the defining movements of the last hundred years was the fact that the cost of disseminating opinions and news was slowly becoming affordable for more and more corporations, small teams or even individuals. Thanks to technological progress, the voices out there multiplied, as did their audience. And people unhappy with a certain journalistic narrative found it cheaper and easier to broadcast their competing perspective.
Such a chaotic world cannot be subject to effective content guidelines such as the defunct fairness doctrine, just like the modern world of highly educated professionals cannot be ruled by hereditary nobility.