News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by tdoggette on Sunday August 03, 2008 @11:14PM (#265932)
He's not wrong. Apple's garden-walling was become extensive enough that it's gone beyond ensuring a good experience for their users, and has started to damage the platform. This should have been obvious to them since jailbreaking became so common, but I guess it hasn't quite sunk in yet. Apple needs to allow people to use their platform, or it won't become as good as it deserves to be.
Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by charlesju on Sunday August 03, 2008 @11:52PM (#265964)
I respectfully disagree. I think it is important to wall off the platform and sandbox the environment. This prevents things like stack attacks with walled off memory and background processes doing things it should not.

With so much personal information on the mobile phone, it'll be a complete nightmare if one of the applications is really a virus that spreads as a background process. Since it can contact your ENTIRE contact list, such a viral infection can crippling. In fact, in the Jailbroken iPhone community there have already been a couple of viruses.

But on the other hand, they should open up a couple more APIs, the camera, specifically.

Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by tptacek on Monday August 04, 2008 @12:45AM (#266007)
None of the limitations being discussed with the iPhone have anything to do with whether programs are vulnerable to "stack attacks". The iPhone doesn't even have background processes. And "virus" is just a scary-sounding word for "program that deletes important files on your behalf". Don't run those.

I respect the "walled garden" as a business decision; it's Apple's platform, and maximizing its revenue is their prerogative. As a technical safeguard, there's no evidence that it works.

Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by tomsucks on Monday August 04, 2008 @03:30AM (#266090)
Here's my top: http://pastie.org/246884

MobileSafari, MobileMail, MobilePhone, all running in the background. fairplayd is the fairplay daemon, commcenter manages communications (all of them), springboard is the desktop, lockdownd is the little thing that checks to make sure the phone is activated (and locks it down if not)

only the top three apps (bash, top, sshd) aren't there on a vanilla iPhone. Apple's apps will run in the background, but other (app store) apps exit completely when you return to the home screen.

Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by tptacek on Monday August 04, 2008 @11:14AM (#266324)
Sorry, you're right. Apple can do whatever it wants on their phone, as you've pointed out. Evil third party developers can't.
Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by tomsucks on Tuesday August 05, 2008 @04:22PM (#267833)
Technically, good nda-abiding sdk-using $99-paying developers can't, evil ones that write their apps for jailbroken phones can ;)
Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by stcredzero on Monday August 04, 2008 @11:20AM (#266334)
AFAIK, the iPhone does have background processes. Apple just won't let you have at them!

Apple could easily write a specialized API that lets you run virtualized background processes. This would be an improvement on the current situation, but it would maintain heightened security.

Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by jonknee on Monday August 04, 2008 @12:51AM (#266013)
That's a valid point, but is the same for Mac OS X. You have even more personal information on your desktop. Thankfully we're not limited to a single source for Mac OS X apps.
Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by dejb on Monday August 04, 2008 @08:14AM (#266199)
From what you are saying you'd think the iphone is the first phone OS capable of running third party apps ever. Other phone OS's have been able to do this for 5 years and many of them haven't needed to restrict users so badly including Windows Mobile, Palm OS and in some cases Symbian.
Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by axod on Monday August 04, 2008 @03:16AM (#266085)
Completely disagree. As a consumer, I just want the thing to work. The best way to ensure that, is to have control of the platform.

The lack of a glut of apps, some badly written is hardly damaging the platform, it's maintaining the quality of the user experience, which I'm extremely glad about.

Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by Tichy on Monday August 04, 2008 @12:50PM (#266440)
So why are Apple's customers not demonstrating in the street for Apple to lock down OS X? I think the ability of 3rd-party developers to write software for OS X is a great risk to the usability and stability of the platform. I don't think Apple-Users need anything but iTunes and Photoshop, anyway.
Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by jcl on Monday August 04, 2008 @09:52AM (#266250)
As the article points out, this is exactly the same argument they made to justify the webapp-only restriction in the previous iteration. That particular restriction has now been lifted and the world has not ended... It makes you wonder why the restriction was there in the first place, and how important the current set of restrictions will turn out to be.
Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by axod on Monday August 04, 2008 @11:33AM (#266352)
webapp-only restriction? You make it sound like creating the whole native app infrastructure was as simple as them clicking [enable].

I don't know if I'm a typical user, but I still use webapps most of the time. The native apps I've seen or tried are quite a mixed bag at the moment.

Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by ajross on Monday August 04, 2008 @12:12PM (#266401)
Considering that (1) the jailbreak folks had a dev environment within a month of release with zero support from Apple and (2) the phone shipped with a bunch of applications that had to have been written with, y'know, tools of some kind; I'd say that yes, it really was about as easy as clicking "enable".

Apple is a quick agile company and certainly has shipped products quickly in the past. You're honestly arguing that taking 13 months (or whatever it was) to release a native SDK was because they just couldn't do it any faster?

Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by mechanical_fish on Monday August 04, 2008 @12:54PM (#266445)
Of course the jailbreakers threw together a dev environment quickly. They didn't have to make a business decision to do so. They didn't need a budget or a strategic plan. They didn't need buy-in from anyone.

They didn't have to have their decisions vetted by a management team and a legal team. They almost certainly didn't do any usability testing or write a set of human interface guidelines. They didn't have to make design decisions that they could live with for the next five years, or (as with the decisions made by the designers of the original Mac OS) twenty-five years.

They didn't need to make an official announcement, or run a beta program lasting several months so that developers had a chance to have apps ready on launch day. They didn't have to invest in developer training materials or write formal documentation.

They didn't have to build an entire app store that was secure, cross-platform, usable by customers, relatively free of bugs, and ready to scale so that it would handle one million users in its first weekend.

And, when the jailbreak apps break, the developers don't get hammered by guys like Walt Mossberg, David Pogue, and every analyst and pundit on Wall Street. When end users complain that their phone battery life is too short, the jailbreakers don't need to respond. They aren't obligated to fix security holes or support developers who have problems. They aren't obligated to support anyone. They're open-source hackers, they can't get fired, and they always have the option to say caveat emptor and go do something else.

There's a reason why people pay for Apple's stuff. Apple adds value. But adding value takes time and money.

Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by ajross on Monday August 04, 2008 @01:07PM (#266463)
business decision ... strategic plan ... buy-in ... vetted by ... legal team ... formal documentation

If these are really the reasons for the SDK's delay and ugliness, then we should celebrate: Apple is already dying. This is just silly. Truly successful products (including the iPhone) happen without this stuff all the time, and these are never required criteria. Your list is just a list of excuses.

Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by mechanical_fish on Monday August 04, 2008 @05:27PM (#266797)
Truly successful products (including the iPhone) happen without this stuff all the time

Which products are you talking about?

And, if Apple is dying, pray tell which of its many competitors is killing it? They don't have to outrun imaginary competition, after all. They only have to outrun the competition that physically exists.

Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by axod on Monday August 04, 2008 @01:22PM (#266483)
As I said elsewhere, if you don't like it, don't buy one. Maybe the stores will actually be able to keep some in stock for a while.
Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by alexfarran on Monday August 04, 2008 @06:22AM (#266160)
Does that mantra come on a card with your iphone?
Re:Michael Tsai: Welcome to iPhone: Your Crappy Mac of Tomor... by axod on Monday August 04, 2008 @09:45AM (#266247)
Yeah they're currently brainwashing people to buy the iPhone which is sold out most of the time. In actual fact no one wants to buy it, as the average joe on the street is incandescent with rage over their restrictive NDA for 3rd party developers.

It's really tiresome to hear people whine and moan on and on about apple, and to label anyone that disagrees a fanboy.

If you don't like the iPhone, simple - don't buy one.