I think this comes down to a fundamental miscommunication. No one is going to believe you are a heartless jerk for advocating for more efficient, effective practices in government. The values judgment comes in when the services being cut are those that provide tangible, critical value to individuals in society - think social welfare programs.
Because cuts are never accompanied by a plan for efficiency, cuts always mean services get worse. Therefore, individuals who receive vital services suffer. Then comes the 'heartless jerk' values judgment.
Maybe all budget cuts need to be precipitated by a process evaluation and bloat reduction.
The issue is, that game is too easy to rig and too tempting to play; for proof, see literally any large corporation's budget and planning processes. Fiefdoms abound.
I don't know how to fix the problem.
I have always said that I would gladly pay 75% of my salary in taxes, as long as everyone in society had easy, equal access to high quality education, quality, safe housing, nutritious, safe food, and high quality, timely healthcare.
The problem is, any society structured to provide those things will immediately be corrupted by greedy, power-hungry people.
Getting a little too philosophical, I think. Anyway. I don't know what the solution is, but I'm hopeful that there is one.
It seems weird to want to pivot to individuals being taxed and then comment on how much those individuals pay as a group, and not look at whether or not individuals being taxed are being taxed at a fair rate over time.
Yes, and if you look at my other comments here, I'm in favor of all individuals, regardless of wealth paying the exact same in taxes via a flat tax on consumption.
Whatever the flat tax percent is, it should be paid by everyone equally in proportion to their consumption.
For example, poor people have no choice but to eat, and their food costs won't be that much lower than a rich person's food costs (assuming artificially that everyone cooked at home).
Therefore, because rich and poor people will eat about the same amount of food, and the cost will be "about" the same, then the amount of tax paid will be about the same. But as a percentage of the person's income, the poor person will have a drastically higher burden of taxation.
And even if consumption tax proponents were willing to allow for luxury item tax rates, rich people would always have a way around it. For example, would renting an item be taxed the same as buying it? Or what if instead I receive access to my Ferrari as a perk of working for my hedge fund? The poor guy who buys the $2,000 used junker will have to pay consumption tax, but I won't.
For every rule there are probably multiple loopholes. And even if a fair system could be devised, it would never see the light of day because you could never get enough people to agree on what that system would be.
All of this is just pointless thought experimentation anyway; the current corporate-political structure likes the current system much better than they would like any radically different system. Therefore, nothing significant is going to change.
I wouldn't phrase it that way but I could see the argument for exempting only the most basic necessities from taxation such as very basic end-consumer foodstuffs (generic non-organic unbranded flour, eggs, milk, in-season domestic fruits and vegetables, etc, generic commodity processed food goods, if a company slaps a brand on it, it should not be exempt). For housing, maybe the first N dollars of housing costs where N is the median cost of the cheapest 10% of housing stock in a local market.
Whatever the decision that is made, the main thing that needs to be conserved is that everyone that votes should feel the pain of taxation for any consumption above and beyond mere existence. If we don't all feel the burden of paying for governance, how are we all supposed to take the same interest in making sure that that governance is spending taxpayer money wisely. This is especially important in a democracy where the majority can rule. What you can't have is a situation where the majority with the votes doesn't feel the burden of the governance they are voting for. That's a recipe for disaster.
> For example, would renting an item be taxed the same as buying it?
renting is consumption
> Or what if instead I receive access to my Ferrari as a perk of working for my hedge fund?
gifting is consumption. Stuff like this is already stuff that people have to include in their income taxes.
> For every rule there are probably multiple loopholes.
that's no different than for the status quo. loopholes are a fact of life in a system. the more complex the rules, the most loopholes there are
> All of this is just pointless thought experimentation anyway;
I disagree. It's important to identify the shortcomings of the current system and that is that it leads to voters that are drunk on transferism. If you don't identify such shortcomings, you can't fix them.
Do you have a source for your numbers?
https://www.ntu.org/foundation/tax-page/who-pays-income-taxe...
Besides, doing a trivial, quick Google search comes up with a few links to anti-tax lobby groups (such as the one you provided). However, a slightly less trivial, slightly less quick look at the topic reveals that the figures in the anti-tax lobby group reports do not include capital gains, or really anything outside of federal income. It doesn't even include payroll tax.
A few sources, admittedly biased the other way:
- https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/where-do-federal-t...
- https://theintercept.com/2019/04/13/tax-day-taxes-statistics...
- https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/10/08/first-tim...
- https://www.businessinsider.com/american-billionaires-paid-l...
Since payroll is proportional to income, that's even more federal revenue that is indirectly levied on the labor of the top 5% and 20%.
Once you include capital gains taxes, the top 5% and top 20% cover even more of federal revenue. The only portion of capital gains that isn't personal capital gains is corporate capital gains. A sizable amount of non-individual capital gains are hedge funds and retirement accounts, which once again are mostly funded by many people in the top 5% and 20%.
Any way you slice it, it's largely the top 5% to top 20% of so funding much of the operating costs of USA Inc. Everyone in the bottom 50% gets a 50% say while paying a mere 3% of income taxes and probably even less in taxes once you include all sources of federal revenue.
Waste is not virtuous and you cannot prosper by continually breaking and repairing the same windows.
there's also the argument that it's worse for a government to waste money than it is for a business. if someone runs their own business inefficiently, they are just wasting their own money. if the executives run a publicly-traded business inefficiently, this is a bit worse as they are wasting the shareholders' money. but an inefficient government is wasting everyone's money that they are compelled to contribute.
>a business that wastes more than it profits will eventually be sold for parts
How many startups linked on this very site throw VC money into furnaces and have nothing to show for it (not even parts) after a few years? Where did all the Yik Yak money go?
>a government isn't subject to the same constraints and can raise taxes or print money for a long time to paper over the rot
Overall that may be true but individual departments and programs are certainly subject to those constraints.
>an inefficient government is wasting everyone's money that they are compelled to contribute
I'm not thrilled about the billions that have been wasted developing the F-35 but that's exactly how representative government works. I don't get a vote in the decisions of Google or Apple.
But inefficient and providing service to everyone are not necessarily the same thing. Planned inefficiencies is what are important.
For example - the college I work at knows that we're going to lose our shirts on every nursing student, something to the tune of 25k loss for every student, every year in that program.
And because that is what the area needs, that is what we do. It's massively inefficient. It would, at a for-profit, be the first program to get cut.
But we can plan for that loss, and make up for it in other areas.
That's an efficient and effective inefficiency.