News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Funds for Open Source by artembugara on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:50AM (#26579566)
There is one basic thing about open source and market economy:

1. People open source for free. They already do that. So, there is no real need to pay them as they are willing to do so for free. Greatest minds work for open-sourced projects.

2. If you want to pay/fund/support open source. Great, but these numbers we're talking about (like $1k/mo) are nowhere near what devs make at corporations.

I think Funds for Open Source is a great initiative! I just do not think it can be a real alternative to a career path.

I think the best open source support is done by big companies who open source their work. For example, Airflow by AirBnb.

Re:Funds for Open Source by cassepipe on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:58AM (#26579643)
I would rather make 1k a month and work on something I like on my terms than to have a stressful/meaningless job around the clock with unpaid working hours all around. There only so much shit you really need. And you need time for your friends/loved one. You'll live poorer but longer.

Edit : This is not a fantasy about poverty being more genuine. Poverty makes you die sooner. My point is a life spent running after money and positions is a meaningless life.

Edit 2: I may have a bias here since I live with under 1k a month, under my country's minimum wage that is .

Re:Funds for Open Source by breakfastduck on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:28AM (#26579974)
Appreciate that's the case for you, but under 1k in either the UK or US or many European countries is completely untenable for independent living.
Re:Funds for Open Source by cassepipe on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:59AM (#26580335)
I live in Paris so it's quite expensive. Not making a case about my lifestyle which is quite spartan I admit but I am tired of reading people complaining they can't make a living with only 3k a month, like my father, which feels kind of obscene to me. The reason my father is complaining about his financial situation all the time is because is always trying to buy shit to compensate the time he lost doing the job he doesn't like. It all ends up in the basement and when the basement will be full, it'll finally end up burnt in a land fill next to a village in Malaysia or something. Don't be my father.
Re:Funds for Open Source by breakfastduck on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:01AM (#26580367)
I'm more surprised you can even pay rent in Paris & eat for <1k a month.

You have to remember peoples circumstances too - many people have families or live in very expensive areas, they can't just suddenly stop everything to live on a lower amount like an individual can.

Re:Funds for Open Source by cassepipe on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:18AM (#26580579)
I think I live in an expensive area. Rent is 500 euros a month (which is cheap, but I get what I pay for). Phone is five euros/month. So is internet (shared). I don't pay transportation because I think it should be free since I am not polluting common air with a car. Else I have a bike. Then I have 400 euros that need to be shared among food (which is swiftly shoplifted if expensive ;), clothing (which I already have plenty so I am fine) and nights out (which at the moment is rather quiet you know why). I cut my own hair or ask a friend. Short period of more intense work paid for all the *ware. Rather fine I must say.

As I said my point is not to say that everyone should be like me although I like to show off how not-wealthy I am for the high of moral superiority. My point is that thinking you need more money is often intricated with irrational emotions. It has happened to me various times to have someone I know is doing fine complaining about being "tight". When a person that's poor say "I have no money", it's means the account balance is dangerously close to 0,when a well off person says so, it means "I wish I did not have to cut down expenses so I can maintain my standard of living".

Re:Funds for Open Source by breakfastduck on Friday March 26, 2021 @08:28PM (#26598600)
I want to be able to buy stuff I'm interested in or buy equipment to learn new skills.

I don't think there's any shame in wanting > than the lowest possible money to achieve that.

Re:Funds for Open Source by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:21PM (#26583593)
> it means "I wish I did not have to cut down expenses so I can maintain my standard of living"

Well, we did move on from living in caves for a reason, you know.

Re:Funds for Open Source by cassepipe on Thursday March 25, 2021 @03:40PM (#26584490)
Yeah that's exactly the reaction I get from those people when you tell them that maybe they don't need that new expensive sofa to replace "that one that is already four year old": "Why u want me to live in a cave? " So I guess there are only two ways of living : Either live in a cave, or have two big SUV because you know why moving 1500 kg of plastic and metal anywhere I go when I can move 2500 kg? I wish I could insert a Louie Ck video snippet saying "I deserve a golden watch"
Re:Funds for Open Source by artembugara on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:29AM (#26580727)
I think my co-founder (CTO of NewsCatcher) is in a very common situation. He's in a 500 euro flat in 13th district.

It's literally everything in one room. Everything.

Re:Funds for Open Source by DocTomoe on Friday March 26, 2021 @08:22AM (#26591208)
You make that sound like it is a problem, when "having a room for yourself" was considered a luxury only 100 short years ago, when you would have shared that very same room with four family members.

Living in a small flat (essentially everything in one room) even though I would not have to economically, it taught me about sufficiency and the cost of buying things. Empty spaces tend to fill up with stuff you buy. If you do not have empty space, you buy less, which is good for your mental well-being and the planet.

Re:Funds for Open Source by cassepipe on Friday March 26, 2021 @11:10AM (#26593074)
True. But you also need empty space not to feel trapped in a cage or else you'll catch that cabin fever.

You can always go the park provided you got into that discipline, that you there is a park less than ten minutes away or that it's not too cold/raining/snowing: Not ideal. And it might a shitty square surrounded by cars.

Mentally, it is also very helpful to have separate spaces for different aspects of your life. When your room is also your office and your kitchen, it doesn't make for good sleep, good work or good cooking.

Relevant videos : https://youtu.be/LO1mTELoj6o https://youtu.be/snAhsXyO3Ck

Re:Funds for Open Source by xbar on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:53AM (#26580274)
I think it is likely an alternative career path for a handful of FOSS unicorns whose work is so instrumental that private corporations desperately need their work to continue.

Among us, some "entrepreneurs" will produce 100 little projects and try to get them all funded and then Show HN how they make a living off of dozens of lightly funded projects.

Funds for Open Source will globalize some work inasmuch as some developers will get paid some money in places where no development career paths exist now. Look at the World Economic Forum's Global Competitiveness report and you can find at least 20 countries where tech companies do not hire.

To your point, the reason people open source for free is that they cannot produce free software and get paid. There is no way for them to be compensated for working in alignment with their own values. Funds for Open Source attacks that problem.

I don't know that Funds is a good organization, or that they are fair in their pricing, or whether they are the best equipped private, for-profit company to wedge themselves between free-thinking developers and the corporate entities that consume their work for free, but I think the business model for Funds makes a lot of sense.

Re:Funds for Open Source by ocdtrekkie on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:54AM (#26579608)
The problem is that projects by big companies are often encumbered by their business decisions. Companies rarely find privacy profitable, so it's usually the first feature to get rid of, but if they use or need an open source tool that respects privacy, they may pay for it.

Funds from tech companies won't alone make open source development sustainable, but it'll help.

Re:Funds for Open Source by prepend on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:01AM (#26579677)
All projects are encumbered by business decisions.

I think open source improves on this problem because now I can fork and extend because a company open sourced something. This is not perfect, but it’s better than when I can’t.

I think a better approach is trying to encourage more of a gift economy with people working on stuff for free and sharing it.

It’s funny how I’m willing to accept some hair and do work myself as part of a community, but if I have to pay for it, I lose that community motivation.

For example, I’m willing to spend time writing up an issue for an OSS project with a test script, etc. but I won’t do that for a commercial company.

Re:Funds for Open Source by piamancini on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:37AM (#26580063)
You have a point! The goal though is not for one FUND to support they entire ecosystem but for many funds supporting it. 1k from one fund and 3k from another for example + recurring subscriptions from individuals, end up adding up. (disclosure, I am OC co-founder)
Re:Funds for Open Source by lallysingh on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:42AM (#26580146)
I don't think the $1k/month would fully cover a full time engineer. A few similar contributions would. Or an engineer doing this work as a side project.