News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by smoldesu on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @12:18PM (#26569221)
As little as I like to do this, I think it's important to bring up the "autism" topic, because I see way too many autistic programmers being thrown under the bus for stuff like this. To start, the three smartest programmers I personally know are autistic, and all of them struggle to make sound judgement calls at the drop of a hat. I've seen them lambasted in IRC channels for saying stupid things or slipping up a function name when writing documentation, but every one of them could out-code their harasser at a moments notice. I get the feeling we're in the same boat with RMS, since I've seen his behavior before in neurodivergent programmers: hard-headedness, dedication to a fault, and speaking his mind even when the social repercussions could blow up in his face. His Aspbergers is part of what makes him who he is, and I'd rather have a distastefully transparent board member than a muzzled figurehead. I value Stallman's voice, and I honestly feel bad that his slips are being sensationalized now.
Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by smsm42 on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @05:00PM (#26572845)
I think getting physiology in this is just wrong. I don't know whether RMS is on the spectrum, and whether he would have been diagnosed as one if he passed some tests. I think it's beyond the point - even non-autistic people can make bad judgements, make mistakes, behave awkwardly, be stubborn and behave in socially awkward manner. Making it like "if we find a bad statement in your past, we're going to ruin your life, but if you have this magic paper then it's ok" - is not how you solve a problem or people's lives being ruined. RMS's voice is important not because he may or may not have certain condition, but because of what he's been saying and doing for years. It's not about autism, especially not about making it yet another "protected identity" checkbox.
Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by NelsonMinar on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @12:21PM (#26569271)
Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by smoldesu on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @12:32PM (#26569433)
I agree with a lot of the stuff being said here, but it's entirely tangential to what I talked about. Our "cancel culture" is more focused on zooming-in on the minutia than the big-picture. I love my autistic friends, and never once would I describe their behavior as mean-spirited or "jerk-like". I treat them with patient respect, and they reciprocate the sentiment. I personally know that 2 of those 3 friends love RMS (haven't asked the third :p), and I fail to see what harm he can cause by rejoining the board. Stallman envisioned a free world, where people can communicate openly and without censorship. When people try to silence him, they're only showing how little they understand his goals. You can love him, you can hate him, but you can never stop him. I personally disagree with many of his opinions, but I fully support him coming back to the FSF. Richard Stallman embodies freedom, so he belongs there, regardless of his political or personal opinions.
Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by Arnt on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @02:11PM (#26570923)
It's not a matter of his political or personal opinions, it's about behaviour. It's about whether the FSF wants to be welcoming to either people who behave like rms or women.

rms, if you by any chance read this: you're supposed to make the ladies laugh. If you talk to women (and talk only, leering is verboten), and make smile and laugh, sometimes a brassiere comes off and noone is unhappy afterwards.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by sascha_sl on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @06:23PM (#26573771)
You should read the accounts of the few people that spoke up about working for or with the FSF despite their overreaching NDA. They have nothing good to say about Stallman as a leader. His reputation alone makes him ineffective as a person to rally behind for a lot of people, despite the fact they contribute to FOSS and share more of the ideals of the free software movement than the open source movement.

You can stop Stallman, and you should, lest his ideals and the FSF drop further into irrelevance.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by Corazoor on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @01:09PM (#26570042)
The article misses the point the grand parent is making: People with autism lack (to varying degree) the ability to decode social clues and - based on that - behave in socially agreeable ways.

Since the other side (non-autists) can usually not distinguish between disregarding social norms on purpose (being a jerk) or by accident (autism), autists are often judged as jerks. Escpecially since the high frequency of "social fuckups" rules out "normal" human mistakes.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by jeswin on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @12:32PM (#26569441)
"If you've met one person with autism, you've met one person with autism." - Dr. Stephen Shore
Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by yongjik on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @04:32PM (#26572505)
https://twitter.com/migueldeicaza/status/1173981287037751297...

> I hosted rms many years ago in the 90’s, what was supposed to be hosting your hero for a ~3 day thing became a ~2 month nightmare. I joined a small club “never host rms ever again”. To cope with it, I used to collect the horror stories.

> He met a woman on the first evening in town, and extended his stay. One day, I came home from work and she had moved in.

I don't personally know any autistic person, but this doesn't sound like autism. How many autistic person visits a new town, goes into a bar, and brings back a woman to your friend's bedroom, without asking the friend first? This sounds more like a run-of-the-mill asshole.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by sascha_sl on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @06:14PM (#26573706)
I'm sure Stallman has issues with social judgement, but that would just lead to awkward situations that resolve when the person notices they're out of line. Stallman will sit on his bad calls. I'd guess this is just what happens when your entire career is built on your stubbornness, and you get applauded for it instead of scolded.
Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by phasnox on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @01:22PM (#26570224)
I'm trying to fight my own bias here, but.. I really don't know what to think.

On one hand I'm totally against cancel culture for things like:

- How you voted(e.g. Trump/Biden)

- Your political views on any subject

On the other hand, Stallman has called for the killing of babies with Down Syndrome.

So, could I associate with someone like that?

Could I comfortably work with someone that(for example) calls for the killing of babies if they where jewish, black etc.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by smsm42 on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @02:25PM (#26571120)
> Stallman has called for the killing of babies with Down Syndrome.

I've been in OSS for decades. I've actually argued with RMS personally on certain subject (he called me evil, which I disagree with, but that's not the point). I've read a lot of his writings and a lot of writings about him. I never heard about this until today. I have no idea what RMS actually said on the subject (you didn't provide a quote, as it usually happens) but whatever he said, it's clearly wasn't something very important among all his body of work, if mostly nobody heard or cared about this so far.

In fact, I can't bring myself to care about RMS's views on the subject right now - even if your most uncharitable interpretation is completely correct (I am 99% sure it's not, but even in unlikely case it is) it's completely immaterial. RMS has never been and never will be in a position that such an opinion would matter for anything, he has never killed any babies and has never contributed or influenced anything that mattered in this area. He did, however, contributed a lot and mattered a lot in other areas.

One of the most idiotic and toxic features of cancel culture is reducing the immense complexity of the person's life to one - almost always distorted and misinterpreted - statement and focusing on it as if it were the only point ever. There's no "someone like that". "Someone like that" is a bullshit - no one is "like that", and "like that" is an insanely awful criteria to guide your actions. Literally everybody has done something in their life some people may not like. One can disagree with somebody on some subject and still agree with them on other subjects. That's how human society works. People can not be reduced to a single "like that", and shouldn't be. Get out of Twitter and purge it out of your system, for the benefit of yourself and humanity.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by phasnox on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @07:05PM (#26574208)
> One of the most idiotic and toxic features of cancel culture is reducing the immense complexity of the person's life to one - almost always distorted and misinterpreted - statement and focusing on it as if it were the only point ever.

I actually agree with this.

I never said "cancel him", I said it would be hard to support.

Although I strongly disagree with what he said, I can and should be able to work with people I strongly disagree with, otherwise society would collapse.

I have actually changed my mind :o

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by qrbLPHiKpiux on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @07:23PM (#26574386)
Cancel Culture is a real problem. An unfair one.

I may disagree with what someone says but I will fight with them for their right to say it.

I'm transphobic because I will never under any circumstances be with a transgender man who will never be a woman.

There - Will I be canceled?

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by DanBC on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @04:22PM (#26572397)
This is a lot of words to defend someone when you -as you say - don't know what he said nor what he meant.

The fact that many people in open source don't care about Stallman's defence of eugenics says a lot.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by smsm42 on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @04:51PM (#26572727)
> This is a lot of words

That's your response? "too long, didn't read"? Well, good job, I guess, here's your participation trophy.

> The fact that many people in open source don't care about Stallman's defence of eugenics says a lot.

No, it actually says nothing at all. That's the whole point, which you may have understood if you bothered to actually read. RMS's views on random subjects is just idle thoughts of a random dude, and nobody in any community owes anybody any care about what random dude once said about random subjects. If RMS were nominated for the Secretary of Health, then his views on reproductive decisions may be slightly more relevant. Call me back when that happens.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by sascha_sl on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @06:32PM (#26573866)
The point is that maybe you should stop doing a theoretical defense in 1000 words and head over to stallman.org and read up on the words you're defending first.

It's really not that hard.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by smsm42 on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @11:22PM (#26576240)
I know the words. The whole point is - for the third time - is not that those words aren't as bad as the Woko Haram on Twitter tries to present it, though this is also true. The point is even if they were what they claim, it still wouldn't be a reason for ruining somebody's life, because the whole concept of "people like that" is complete and utter bullshit. People are complex. Somehow most people people by now get that reducing somebody to their gender, or disability, or condition, or skin color, or ethnicity, or some other single trait is wrong. But it's still hard to get how reducing somebody to one single random statement - made years ago at that - is wrong. I am still not sure if it's performative obtuseness or geniune psychological blockage.
Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by howeyc on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @03:54PM (#26572124)
> On the other hand, Stallman has called for the killing of babies with Down Syndrome.

He did not say that. You make it sound like he's suggesting babies actually born should be killed. No. He's supporting the current practice of testing the fetus during pregnancy, and aborting if it has down syndrome.

Warning to others, this is what happens when you get caught up in cancel-culture wokeness, repeating allegations of others without verification. You end up repeating falsehoods as justfication, take things out of context, and confirm to onlookers you don't have the ability to form your own opinions through rational, logical thought.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by phasnox on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @06:56PM (#26574104)
A "fetus", as you call it, is a person. I'm not calling to cancel him, I just say its hard to support an individual with such despicable thoughts.

On the other hand, many of the signers support abortion in general, so it would be hypocritical of me to support them too.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @06:10PM (#26573660)
It's crazier than that. Stallman is being called out by the left/liberals/woke for a pro-choice position.

They don't have actual positions they believe in any more. They just have weapons they can use against people.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by CodeGlitch on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @01:39PM (#26570470)
> On the other hand, Stallman has called for the killing of babies with Down Syndrome.

Has he though? Has he actioned this idea, or was it just something he blogged about amongst 1000's of other thoughts that floated through his head?

One of my life lessons I think is worth pointing out, is that people's actions are far more important than what they say. And this is the problem with modern western society: someone says something stupid and everyone jumps on them as an opportunity to further their own cause.

So yes you can associate with someone like this, unless they DO something terrible.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by yrrr on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @02:11PM (#26570926)
Advocating for eugenics is doing something terrible.

Edit: I don't have an opinion either way, just clarifying that I believe advocacy is action.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by kemonocode on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @05:10PM (#26572978)
> On the other hand, Stallman has called for the killing of babies with Down Syndrome.

Would you mind providing a citation on this? Because I have yet to really read about it anywhere else.

EDIT: Ah, so it was a rather uncharitable interpretation on his views on abortion [0]. Again, a symptom of someone with zero social awareness and I'm sure it'd be thought to be beyond the pale for some people, but far from a genocidal maniac.

[0] https://stallman.org/archives/2016-sep-dec.html#31_October_2...

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by sascha_sl on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @06:30PM (#26573852)
I'm genuinely interested where you draw the line. Politicians (opinion: read that as mostly Republicans) have advocated for heinous things too. Your last point about feeling safe and comfortable working with such people applies especially to minorities that are severely affected by political policies. How is one "political" and the other is not?
Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by deadbytes on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @02:12PM (#26570951)
>calls for the killing of babies if they where jewish, black etc.

How is this in any way equivalent? Being jewish or black are not disabilities. Downs syndrome is a horrible condition that greatly impacts your quality of life.

I personally think abortion is horrible, but aborting babies who are going to enter life with awful disabilities is the least objectionable form of abortion there is.

You should be outraged at the millions of perfectly healthy babies that are aborted every year just for convenience. Not this.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by phasnox on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @02:28PM (#26571155)
>Downs syndrome is a horrible condition that greatly impacts your quality of life.

I disagree. Have you ever met one person with that condition?

The ones I've met, are happier than 99% of the people I know.

Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by smoldesu on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @04:15PM (#26572325)
Maybe you should tell that to rms instead of throwing anecdata at people who disagree with you.
Re:An open letter in support of RMS being reinstated by the FSF by DanBC on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @04:19PM (#26572372)
> Downs syndrome is a horrible condition that greatly impacts your quality of life.

People with DS frequently report greater life satisfaction that people without DS. The problem isn't DS, it's how people with DS get treated by the rest of society that's a problem.