News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by tomc1985 on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:24PM (#26548155)
C# is tied to .net, and the cross-platform story on that framework is...complicated

Java is tied to JVM

Swift is tied to MacOS.

Of course, with the exception of JVM, they are all nominally "cross-platform" in the OS sense of the word. But I haven't seen any substantial Linux/Mac .Net codebases yet, same with Swift on Windows

Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by travv0 on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:39PM (#26549475)
The cross-platform story of .NET hasn't been complicated in a while. It's fully cross-platform between Windows, Linux, and macOS and has been for a few years.

Edit: I just saw the person that you replied to said the same thing, so I'm not sure why you're pushing that it has a complicated cross-platform story.

Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by tomc1985 on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @12:32AM (#26551154)
So... pretty much everything I could do on .net framework runs on Linux and Mac now? Even Winforms, or WPF?

To be fair I haven't written .net code in like 10 years, and the docs explaining how to navigate the transition from framework to core were extremely confusing. Has that soup of different technologies solidified any?

Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by travv0 on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @10:21AM (#26555348)
> So... pretty much everything I could do on .net framework runs on Linux and Mac now?

No, which doesn't really matter since we're talking about .NET, not .NET Framework. Poor naming choice by Microsoft I guess.

Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by nullsense on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:33AM (#26551751)
The docs can be summed up as:

TL;DR rewrite it - there is no migration path!

Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by rafaelvasco on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:21PM (#26550263)
C# ? Not complicated at all. In fact it's currently one of the most cross platform language/runtime in existence after .NET Core appeared, and now more than ever with .NET 5.0. I even managed to AOT compile code and run it without a trace of .NET. Just amazing.
Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by nonbirithm on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:42PM (#26550406)
C# is a really good language, but I had nothing but problems trying to develop with it on Linux exclusively. MonoDevelop doesn't support Linux anymore since a bunch of proprietary components were added to it (and this isn't even mentioned on its homepage), so you have to use a community fork. That didn't bode well for me. The fork didn't have packages for my distro and I couldn't get it to compile for two hours. VS Code wasn't much different, given I couldn't seem how to get OmniSharp working for my project. Eventually I found the only thing that worked half the time was Rider, which actually allows you to manage NuGet packages but costs $139. And still, I often had to load and unload projects or even create new projects entirely just to get it to find the new assemblies I added.

It left a bad taste, but maybe that was because I wasn't using a distro like Ubuntu.

Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by Const-me on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:59PM (#26550934)
Matches my experience. Linux runtime worked great for me, SDK has not. To use it to full extent, I think you have to develop on a Windows PC with Visual Studio. However this way you can only debug on Windows i.e. if you want debugger, the project has to be runnable on Windows too.
Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by oblio on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @03:51AM (#26552217)
Use Rider.
Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by metaltyphoon on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @12:08AM (#26550990)
What a weird case. I have successfully used dotnet core on these distros (alpine, centos, fedora, debian, ubuntu) without a single problem. If you don't mind, what distro are you using ?
Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by nonbirithm on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:44AM (#26551814)
Arch Linux.
Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by rafaelvasco on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @08:02AM (#26554020)
Yeah, I tested it on Ubuntu, had no problems. But yeah, VSCode doesn't cut it completely. Rider is as better or better than VS in some regards but it's paid.
Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by nullsense on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:37AM (#26551771)
I use Ubuntu + Rider and works pretty darn good for me.
Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by socialdemocrat on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:23PM (#26550272)
Swift is not any more tied to macOS than C# is tied to Windows. Compiler LLVM and everything is open source and cross platform. Not all the libraries but that holds true for C# as well, last time I checked.
Re:Crystal 1.0 – What to expect by metaltyphoon on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @12:09AM (#26550997)
C# (CLR specifically) is not tied to windows and hasn't been for a while now. Perhaps the last time you checked was pre 2016 ?