News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:33PM (#26545639)
Careful. "Consciousness" may just be a language issue. It seems like a profound concept but it's really just a word with a very vague and complex definition.

If someone tried to formalize "consciousness" it would be a technical book about 1000 pages long or something and all we're doing is debating about what goes in the book.

It's very similar to the question what is "life?" I mean we understand that biology is just carbon based molecular machines, debating what "life" is as a general concept outside of biology is not a profound issue, it's just a language issue and you'd just be debating what the definition of a word "life" should encompass.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by roughly on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:47PM (#26545830)
I agree.

The ultimate question of consciousness regards the phenomenological experience of being - what is it? Where does it come from? What does it mean about us? Who else shares it?

Any theory of consciousness that doesn’t address those questions may indeed be addressing some version of how we might define consciousness, but it’s redefining the mountain from the foothills - justify it all you like, but nobody’s giving you credit for the summit.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by dangoljames on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:28PM (#26548201)
Before any of THOSE questions can be asked, we first have to arrive at some sort of consensus concerning what constitutes a phenomena...
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by matt-attack on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:05PM (#26547048)
> Who else shares it?

Or what else shares it?

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by roughly on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:39PM (#26548331)
At the point at which we can determine with certainty something else shares a phenomenological experience of consciousness, I think we're obligated to grant it personhood.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by matt-attack on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:55AM (#26551871)
Not sure about that. There is a hypothesis that what you describe is simply a fundamental property of matter:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panpsychism

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by simiones on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:40PM (#26546660)
That's precisely the problem - we can't yet formalize the concept we understand as "consciousness", and so any attempts to find a physical/mathematical definition are almost doomed to fail, as they can't really guarantee they are defining the actual concept we have in our minds when we say "consciousness".
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @01:56PM (#26558012)
My argument is a bit more subtle. I'm saying asking what "consciousness" is like asking "what does it mean to be American."

Does it make sense to attempt to find a mathematical definition of "American." No because being American is largely a made up concept. It's a complex category no doubt but it is not fundamental to the structure of the universe.

I'm saying "Consciousness" is the same thing. It's an ingrained concept we feel is fundamental, but if you think about it, it's really just a made up word.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by simiones on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @03:05AM (#26564327)
To have a complete accounting of the entire universe, we need at some point to have a mathematical model of the human mind and human society. If we did, we could then give a formal definition of "what it means to be American" or "what does seeing green feel like", and indeed "what is consciousness".

Regardless of what you think the mind is (if you believe, like me, that it is fundamentally a physical computer, or if you believe it is something else entirely), our picture of the universe is never going to be satisfactory until we can account for how we integrate with it. So yes, for every made up human notion, there needs to be some way to physically define that human notion, if we had a physical model of the human mind (even if that definition is as simple as "an illusion caused by such and such series of events").

It may well be that consciousness is not a fundamental concept in the sense that it is a uniquely human illusion, not something that could not be properly extended to non-human agents. But even if that is true, it doesn't mean that there can't be a precise definition of how the feeling of consciousness arises in humans, what properties of our minds make us think that we have this property and that it is important.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Thursday March 25, 2021 @03:41PM (#26584501)
>But even if that is true, it doesn't mean that there can't be a precise definition of how the feeling of consciousness arises in humans,

You could say this about "American" as well. Trying to pinpoint the formal definition of "American" is likely possible but also completely pointless because it's an arbitrary made up concept. Just like consciousness.

As a user of the word. You don't even know what it means. All you know is that when you look at something, your brain automatically tells you what is conscious and what is not. Your brain does the same thing with "American." Attempting to formalize this category is pointless.

>what properties of our minds make us think that we have this property and that it is important.

The property in your mind that does this is the same property that effects the word "American." It is the recursive nature of consciousness along with the ambiguity of the category that imprints the word with a false sense of importance.

The reality is, consciousness is simply a line of demarcation between calculator and computer or bug and human. Somewhere there is a boundary where we classify something as conscious or not conscious. What's actually going on is a gradient, and the hard boundary is made up by humans. There is little fundamental importance where you place this boundary at all.

For example are humans more conscious than a bug? Is a bug more conscious than a Machine learning AI? Is a machine learning AI more conscious than a calculator. There is very little importance in how you answer these questions. If an AI is more conscious than a calculator... so what? You arbitrarily defined your boundary to be there. You can arbitrarily define it to be anywhere you want, technically.

The search for what "consciousness" means is essentially just looking for where our brains have collectively chosen to draw this line of demarcation. It is searching for an arbitrary property that is essentially made up by the human condition.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by networkimprov on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:27PM (#26546460)
The essential feature is subjective experience of sensations, referred to as qualia. I've seen no debate about that.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualia

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by pmcarlton on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @12:10AM (#26551016)
Scroll down to the section "Critics of Qualia", and you will find a lot. I agree with Dennett and others that the concept does not make sense.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by dvfjsdhgfv on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:16PM (#26547227)
In Buddhism, there are separate words for consciousness and qualia. Moreover, many different consciousnesses are recognized.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by AnimalMuppet on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:34PM (#26546558)
I'm not an expert, but I strongly suspect that you haven't looked for debate very hard. I strongly suspect that there is a fair amount of debate on that question. In fact, I'm pretty sure I've seen debate on that question, right here on HN.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:54PM (#26546875)
The first sentence on that Wikipedia page:

"In philosophy and certain models of psychology, qualia (/ˈkwɑːliə/ or /ˈkweɪliə/; singular form: quale) are defined as individual instances of subjective, conscious experience"

Shows that qualia is defined in terms of "conscious experience." If qualia is an essential feature of consciousness then the Wikipedia definition is a recursive definition.

The definition of the word "Sword" is "Sword" which is true but tells me nothing at the same time.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by Zuider on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:25PM (#26548867)
Ostensive definitions can be indistinguishable from tautologies. A definition which ultimately boils down to a formula such as:

"The thing that is indicated when you say 'that thing there!'"

appears linguistically empty, because its meaning is not found in the words, but in something extra-verbal that it is intended to point to.

The problem in the debate surrounding consciousness is that there are two basic positions to hold, which are often talking past each other:

1) Oh yes, I see what is being indicated! There is something to discuss.

2) There is nothing here but a meaningless verbal tangle which will disappear when it is untangled.

This problem is similar to, but more intractable than discussing the color blue with someone who has always been blind. The blind person may never actually experience what it is to see blue, the 'qualium,' but there are physical hooks such as the associated frequency of light, and a tangible consensus amongst those who are not blind as to whether an object can be called blue or not.

The latter is missing from the problem of consciousness, which makes it a far more difficult and fascinating problem.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @01:11AM (#26551352)
>and a tangible consensus amongst those who are not blind as to whether an object can be called blue or not.

>The latter is missing from the problem of consciousness, which makes it a far more difficult and fascinating problem.

You are talking about whether some topic can be observed. The example you cite is observation through sight. A blind person cannot observe color. Observation is the key to gathering evidence. The words an "observation" and a piece of "evidence" refer to the exact same concept. Thus your statement is equivalent to saying Blind men can only gain knowledge about color through evidence and that consciousness lacks any sort of evidence.

Many things in this world lack evidence including Scientology and Creationism. We classify some of these things as absurd. Other things are classified as religion or something that is not absurd.

In my mind the logic is equivalent. The vast number of possibilities of the unknown renders most unobserved theories to be by probability more likely to be absurd. Thus Christianity is just as absurd as Scientology. However extraneous factors influence Christianity to be perceived differently even though logically the foundations come from the same absurd unobservable arguments.

Consciousness I believe is much of the same thing. A linguistic phenomenon lending weight to what is otherwise absurd by default. It is just a complicated category where the capability of being able to have certain thoughts is classified as conscious. Or should I say the ability to be aware of certain things? I'm not sure? Fascinating yes but if you look carefully at what I was actually fascinated about you'll see that I'm just talking about how to define a word. Is "consciousnesses" awareness or thought? A definition of a word is not profound.

The profoundness you feel is again just a linguistic illusion. It's similar to the question: "What does it mean to be American?" American is purely a made up word and basically just a over complicated category with nothing intrinsically interesting about it outside of American culture.

To sum it all up. A recursive definition and lack of evidence renders the whole quest to discover what consciousness is quite uninteresting.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by wk_end on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:22AM (#26551693)
Whenever I encounter someone trying to tell me that consciousness is ill-defined or not a real thing that actually exists (which happens surprisingly often), I feel like I’m taking crazy pills - or perhaps that philosophical zombies walk among us. Not only am I 100% sure that (my) consciousness exists, it’s literally the only thing I can be 100% sure exists.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @01:32PM (#26557695)
I was about to debate your point. I decided to flag you instead.

> I feel like I’m taking crazy pills - or perhaps that philosophical zombies walk among us.

Basically the above is an insult. Essentially you're calling me and anyone with a differing opinion then you "crazy" or a walking philosophical zombie. Literally you're just trying to get around a technicality by indirectly labeling me. Might as well just say "Reading your post I feel like I'm taking crazy pills."

Feel free to debate my points but nobody feels good when they're labeled as crazy.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by Zuider on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:00AM (#26580353)
Consciousness is something that is directly observed. In fact, it is perhaps the most directly observed of all phenomena. The problem lies in deciding how to think about it, and how to speak of it.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Thursday March 25, 2021 @04:03PM (#26584712)
So? it's still pointless. Gender is observed to. Is it interesting to discuss all the possible gender categories that can exist? No because a lot of these gender categories were made up in the last decade.

I am saying consciousness is just an arbitrary category for an arbitrary set of phenomena. Trying to codify this arbitrary category is like trying to codify what it means to be American, or what it means to be Trans or whatever. It's Pointless because the complexity within these categories are purely made up.

I'm saying consciousness is the same thing. Is an Ant conscious? Well it depends on your arbitrary classification of what it means to be conscious. And that's the point. It's Arbitrary. It's made up. It's not worth talking about what it is to be American in a scientific paper anymore then it is to talk about what it means to be conscious.

Some may argue that an ant is conscious because it feels pain. Others may argue that consciousness does not involve pain. And if you observe this from a very high level you will see the argument is simply about a definition of an arbitrary word. It is not interesting to debate about vocabulary.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by amanaplanacanal on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:38PM (#26546632)
The problem with that definition is that it’s subjective. You can only know for yourself, but not for anyone else. That makes it completely useless.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by TheOtherHobbes on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:48PM (#26546772)
Of course it's subjective. That's the whole point.

And knowing for yourself still needs an explanation.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by fatsdomino001 on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:51PM (#26546825)
Qualia is actually only a subset of consciousness, generally referring to the coarsest types of consciousness (i.e. that which is readily identifiable). But qualia is by no means the entirety of consciousness.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by patcon on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @09:02AM (#26554471)
> debating what "life" is as a general concept outside of biology is not a profound issue

I'm not sure this is true. I think I disagree with much of your neat frame-setting here. For example, some of my favourite recent podcasts from complexity science involve clever folks like Sara Imari Walker discussing "life" as what emerges from a dense information well.[1] These questions are not just simple inventories.

But yes, I do agree that this may be just "a language issue". But there are other streams of thought that are actively promoting language into a more respectable realm of complexity science, where "just a language issue" actually downplays what may be going on in that "resolving" process of language itself[2] (h/t Nicole Creanza, whose research in birdsong & human cultural evolution is profiled)

tl;dr - I would argue that these questions are "profound" all the way down, if we start looking at it in the right way.

[1]: https://complexity.simplecast.com/episodes/40-ImRdTdBt

[2]: https://complexity.simplecast.com/episodes/22-yTXhvGCS

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:07PM (#26558152)
>Walker discussing "life" as what emerges from a dense information well

This is still a language thing. Nothing new is uncovered here. All Walker did is imbue complexity onto a vocabulary word. No new information was introduced. The profoundness is an illusion.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by patcon on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @11:30AM (#26568493)
I'm grateful for the reply :) I respectfully disagree. You have me asking myself why though. I'm thinking about this quote by Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes:

"For the simplicity that lies this side of complexity, I would not give a fig, but for the simplicity that lies on the other side of complexity, I would give my life."[1]

I'm also thinking about Copernicus and how people were actually modelling planetary motion in workable ways before him, though perhaps with a few more variables.

Lastly, I'm thinking of "Object-Oriented Ontology: A New Theory of Everything", by Graham Harman. I don't subscribe to it fully, but it raises a case for how a truly explanatory theory of our universe MUST encompass fiction and metaphor and language as "real". So if true, then physics must have explanatory power over what happens in language. So I really don't vibe with the downplay of "just a language spin for the same thing", because new terms/framings are crucial to the ecology of science/tech/progress. Discovering "a language thing" is sometimes no less a discovery than finding a new sub-species of toad. The toad is just an instantiation of information in a different substrate, if you get my drift :) a dense network of biochemical interactions vs a distributed network of neural interactions. The universe doesn't care that we find one substrate more intuitive and innate (language). The objective universe "sees" each as a manifestation of novel information that self-reinforces and persists its structure through time

Thanks for giving me the opportunity to work through this thought :)

Disclosure: My background is not just tech, but biochemistry: the nitty gritty chemical mechanics of life. I'm wondering if this gives me different context on how important Imari's discovery of these new framings and models.

[1]: http://www.jonkolko.com/writingSimplicityComplexity.php#brea...

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Thursday March 25, 2021 @03:56PM (#26584641)
>So I really don't vibe with the downplay of "just a language spin for the same thing", because new terms/framings are crucial to the ecology of science/tech/progress. Discovering "a language thing" is sometimes no less a discovery than finding a new sub-species of toad. The toad is just an instantiation of information in a different substrate, if you get my drift

This sentence is in itself wordplay. You are aware of the differences between the toad and the toad subspecies. To imbue both with a different word is a separate thing disconnected from the actual differences.

Words that encompass categories may help us humans understand things, but these are just tools for us to understand certain things, they do not change reality itself.

In fact words can create illusions of categories that don't exist from certain perspectives. For example what does it mean to be "American." It's a complex word with a complex category but largely pointless in the grand universal scheme of things. The category only exists because humans formed out pure chance a country called America out of all the possible countries and empires that could have existed.

I'm saying consciousness is the same thing. It's as arbitrary as asking what it means to be American. Now it may not feel this way but humans are born with large consistent biases that are very hard to remove. Almost all cultures believe in the concept of gods even though scientifically the concept is arbitrary. My claim is that consciousness is a similar thing. It is an illusion.

You do not actually know what the word consciousness means. You just know when something belongs in the consciousness category and when it does not. Much of the question is to find out what the algorithm is actually doing in your head. I think this endeavor is pointless because the algorithm is arbitrary. Whether you consider an ant to be consciousness or not based off certain qualities is uninteresting and arbitrary.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by animanoir on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:47PM (#26545846)
I agree with the language part you said. I find worrying that Wolfram is not talking enough about it.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by barefeg on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:26PM (#26546452)
It’s because it’s probably not possible to define within the standard “toolset”. Look at for example the thoughts of the definition of energy by R. Feynman. You might think us physicists for sure can define energy. After all it’s one of the basis of physics. But it turns out it’s not possible without circular arguments
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @01:46PM (#26557871)
It's possible that energy is a sort of axiomatic property. Meaning it can't be further deduced or explained similar to a mathematical axiom.

I doubt consciousness is such a thing though. Asking "what is Consciousness?" is like asking "What does it mean to be American?" Being American is purely a made up phenomenon and my argument is that although it is may not seem this way, the word consciousness is largely the same thing, just a complex category.

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by airhead969 on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:05PM (#26547927)
English is an awful for scientific communication due to its inherently complex rules and ambiguous lexicon. It's great for marketing and business though!
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @01:20AM (#26551392)
I would argue you're talking about "human language" itself as all languages have some word that is similar to consciousness. That being said, I largely agree with your overall point.
[dead]
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @01:41PM (#26557823)
Don't tell me to fuck off.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Thursday March 25, 2021 @11:41AM (#26581633)
Dang. this guy told me to fuck off and I flagged him and you're completely ignoring this?
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by loopz on Thursday March 25, 2021 @05:28PM (#26585624)
I'm sorry. Was hoping it was motivational to know oneself better.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by dang on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:07PM (#26588094)
Please do a better job of disambiguating your points from personal insults. It's not surprising that your comment landed as an insult.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...

Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by neonological on Thursday March 25, 2021 @07:59PM (#26587244)
Mods, You've warned me before to not aggressively respond to attackers and flag them but, ignoring this is wrong. The guy just flagrantly delivered an insult to my face.
Re:What is consciousness? Some new perspectives from our phy... by dang on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:06PM (#26588088)
If I read the GP comment correctly, it was intended more as a philosophical point (albeit a bizarre way to put one) rather than as a personal insult.