This is the thing that regularly gets lost in the minimum wage debates. Some jobs suck more than others. Amazon warehouse jobs suck kind of a lot. You spend all day standing up and doing manual labor. Because that's what it takes to make unskilled work produce $15/hour in value.
You pass a law requiring competitors to do the same and the ones who were paying $10/hour but workers had more down time, will have to make them more like Amazon jobs. In other words, will have to make them suck more.
There are a lot of people for whom that is not a good trade off. For a 20 year old who can physically do the Amazon job, it might be a good choice in order to make more money. For a 60 year old who can't physically do the Amazon job, taking away the less demanding job they can do is really screwing them over.
The best answer to this is that we shouldn't have a federal minimum wage.
Minimum wage is one of the depression era policies like price controls that were instituted before we knew better. It is a price control.
The reason we still have it is politics. Notice that the advocates of raising the federal minimum wage are overwhelmingly from states that already have a state minimum wage above the federal one, and could set their state's minimum wage to anything higher as they like, since it's a floor, not a ceiling. So why do they care?
They care because the cost of living is different in different regions. $7.25 might be a living wage in El Paso while $15 might not be in San Francisco. But California doesn't want their tax base moving to Texas, so politicians from California want federal laws that make it more expensive to do business in Texas. They want to deprive lower cost of living areas of their competitive advantage.
You can tell something is fishy when most of the supporters of raising the federal minimum wage represent zero people who actually make federal minimum wage, and the representatives of the people who do make federal minimum wage are the opponents.
And actually instituting the policy screws over the people it's supposed to be helping, because then the jobs stay in higher cost of living areas and the higher cost of living causes more harm than the lower wage would have in the lower cost of living area.
And politicians from Texas want to institute tariffs on China and other countries with lower labor costs than Texas. Everyone is playing the same game to maintain their outsized share of the pie.
But that’s not going to happen, so it depends what benefits me and my closet tribe members. Currently I’m in a high cost of living area with very high minimum wages, so I’m for high minimum wages.
If I could make a suggestion, don't do that.
What benefits the tribe's leaders is not the same thing as what benefits the members of the tribe. Elected officials want a larger tax base because once they have enough to provide a basic level of services necessary to prevent the population from revolting, the excess can be diverted to cronies. What that means to you is that you and yours pay more for housing and have a more wasteful government; it's not a benefit to you. Not fighting against it would tend to raise your cost of living by increasing competition for local resources.
But also, that mindset is poison. Once you admit to a willingness to be inconsistent for the benefit of tribal conflict, you're no longer engaged in good faith negotiations. You're making a declaration of war against your own countrymen. Then it's might makes right and the strong taking from the weak. And they don't stop at the other tribe. Put kleptocrats in power and they don't just steal for you, they steal from you. If that's not what you want, you have to refuse what causes it.
> Federal UBI and no minimum wage or any other subsidy to anyone.
> But that’s not going to happen
That's what people say about everything, until it does.
But it doesn't happen on its own. If you want something you have to work for it.
I truly don’t understand why so many think that someone doing less than what it takes to live (alone, independently) should be paid a living wage. Food, housing, energy, care, ... all take productivity; if someone can’t produce enough to cover their own needs, they need be recognized as a dependent and treated as such. It’s not your obligation to pay me a living wage just because you need floors swept or burgers flipped.
You don't really need US-made goods, just buy the ones made in China. You don't really need an appliance repair service, just throw it out and buy another one. Fixed income people don't really need low priced goods and services, they can just pay more (somehow).
You're making the assumption that the alternative isn't worse.
> Makes traffic better too since they're not commuting.
Or makes traffic worse in the alternative because the higher-paying job involves a longer commute (and higher transportation costs that eat the extra money), which is what had made the lower-paying job viable to begin with.
> Offering crappy jobs is bad because people might actually take them; now they don't have the free time needed to find better ones.
This is patronizing. If something is really worse for people then why are they doing it? Are you certain that you're smarter than them and know more about their circumstances than they do?
> It reduces economic productivity and it might be cheaper to just pay them unemployment.
You've identified a serious flaw in the unemployment system. Taking a bad job causes you to lose it, remaining unemployed doesn't. Replace unemployment with a UBI. Now you don't need a minimum wage.
That's right, that's what we're doing. There are better systems than a flat minimum wage like wage boards since they're more flexible, but Australia uses that system a lot and yet also has a $20/hr min wage underlying it. (The Nordics don't have one at all because they use sectoral bargaining contracts. Should probably get one though.)
> This is patronizing. If something is really worse for people then why are they doing it?
Personal responsibility doesn't exist at the level of societies. Sometimes you just get scammed, and it takes a while to get out of the situation if you do. Banning bad jobs is useful the same way banning any other scam is.
> Replace unemployment with a UBI. Now you don't need a minimum wage.
UBI substitutes for unemployment here but it's not the same because the funding source is different. In particular the one for UBI doesn't exist. The US did just pass basic income for childcare though.
UBI does not substitute for minimum wage though, because it doesn't have the effect of eliminating bad jobs. In practice min wage seems to have other positive effects from this like forcing employee productivity to increase faster; in the limiting case with a monopsony employer it even increases employment because they have no other pressure to offer a market clearing wage.
Your position is that this is better for the people in the US who used to make that stuff?
> There are better systems than a flat minimum wage like wage boards since they're more flexible
If you want flexibility, just let the employee decide if the wage is too low. They're the person with the best knowledge of their own situation and also the one with the strongest stake in it.
> Personal responsibility doesn't exist at the level of societies. Sometimes you just get scammed, and it takes a while to get out of the situation if you do. Banning bad jobs is useful the same way banning any other scam is.
The patronizing thing you're doing is assuming that all low paying jobs are bad.
They almost universally have countervailing benefits. They're closer to where you live, have more flexible hours, are less physically demanding etc.
Because otherwise nobody would take them.
> UBI substitutes for unemployment here but it's not the same because the funding source is different. In particular the one for UBI doesn't exist.
Taxes don't exist? Unemployment isn't funded by a tax?
> UBI does not substitute for minimum wage though, because it doesn't have the effect of eliminating bad jobs.
That's exactly what it does. People have the UBI, so not taking a bad job doesn't cause them to starve, so nobody takes a bad job.
Except that now it's the actual bad jobs they don't take, based on their own understanding of their own circumstances, instead of a bureaucracy's flailing incompetent efforts to implement central planning from an ivory tower.
> In practice min wage seems to have other positive effects from this like forcing employee productivity to increase faster
This doesn't come for free. It most often comes by eliminating redundancy and slack, which increases efficiency but harms resiliency. It e.g. makes it more likely that productive companies go out of business, because when you have slack and something bad happens, you cut the slack and survive. If something else already consumed the slack and something bad happens, you go bust.
And there are already plenty of incentives to eliminate slack in favor of efficiency, so smashing the balance on purpose is counterproductive.
> in the limiting case with a monopsony employer it even increases employment because they have no other pressure to offer a market clearing wage.
A monopsony employer is a catastrophic tyrannical threat to everyone. Any solution other than "destroy the monopsony with righteous fire" is nothing but a suicide pact.
There are tasks I’d hire people to do, but it’s not worth enough to pay housing/food/care/heat/etc for.
Besides that, just paying people to do nothing works fine because they can do non-economic work (childcare/caretaking) or speculative things (write a book, go back to school) and US policy is heading back in this direction. We stopped with Reagan because voters tend to turn against welfare policies when you point out that black people are getting them.
You’re assuming paying people to do nothing will result in “unpaid” productivity greater than their UBI. This is not dominant human nature; all basic needs met, most turn to fighting/copulation/gluttony/drugs/sloth.
Oh, just noticed your racist BS at the end. Bye.
I am confident demand is infinite and people will not want to stop working if more basic needs are met[1]. It's the opposite - people don't produce efficiently if they're starving and they can't be matched to better jobs because they don't have the free time to find them.
> Oh, just noticed your racist BS at the end. Bye.
You seem confused since you're the one arguing poor people are naturally idle and will just get in fights with each other if made less poor! Luckily, I have the normal opinions of a person in 2020 and we can all see through through Reagan's "welfare queens" propaganda at this point. As for the evidence about American voters, you should see the people they elect, but also David Shor[2].
[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/09/the-fre... - note the part about poor people being idle became steadily less true until March 2020 and seems to be caused by poor Fed policy, not video games.
[2] https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2020/07/david-shor-cancel-cu...
I want to start a coffee roastery. Margins won’t be “livable” for a while, but do need added labor to start; you (a complete stranger) would punish me for not starting better than where the starting point is.
It is effectively illegal to be poor. The punishment is slavery or deaths of exposure and despair.
Billionaires are a failure of policy and should be treated as pirates, raiding the homes of their customers and employees.
It is illegal to be poor because progressives impose laws making zoning, housing, food, jobs, etc too costly and punishing any who attempt to make lower wages livable.
Billionaires are because they make accessible goods/services to greater percentages of limited populations.
World abject poverty has plummeted from majority to near zero in my lifetime. That was capitalism improving productivity of all.
Pretty sure you mean Nimbys, unless you're suggesting that building high density houses next to coal burning plants is perfectly fine and should never have been banned. There's a difference between zoning that increases prosperity, and zoning for selfish incentives that you would be wise to consider before casting zoning laws as progressive, when that's patently false[0].
>Billionaires are because they make accessible goods/services to greater percentages of limited populations.
>World abject poverty has plummeted from majority to near zero in my lifetime. That was capitalism improving productivity of all.
You imply causation without evidence. Billionaires use extractive and ethically bankrupt methods to undercut their competitors while skimming their plunder off margin between a fair price and their true cost. This is neither necessary, nor sustainable to ensure prosperity for all. This randian perspective is emotionally comfortable for the winners but tragically harmful to literally everyone else.
0. https://www.theamericanconservative.com/urbs/zoning-reform-i...