Re:A Discriminatory Algorithm Wrongly Accused Thousands of F...
by stonecraftwolf on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @12:47PM
(#26479305)
Isnt that also just not how the Pareto principle works? Doesn’t it say that 20% of inputs (people accused of fraud) are responsible for 80% of outputs (cases of fraud)?
So this is actually exactly backwards. On top of being frighteningly amoral, I mean.
Re:A Discriminatory Algorithm Wrongly Accused Thousands of F...
by kgin on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @12:57PM
(#26479477)
Yeah if that's really what they're doing, they've misunderstood the pareto principle pretty much on every level, from what it is to how someone might attempt to apply it.
Re:A Discriminatory Algorithm Wrongly Accused Thousands of F...
by leto_ii on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @12:54PM
(#26479432)
I checked the original article, it doesn't explicitly refer to the Pareto principle, it just calls it the 80/20 rule. Normally by this it's understood that you should be referring to the Pareto principle, but it seems they've invented another 80/20 rule (that makes no sense and is not related to Pareto).
Re:A Discriminatory Algorithm Wrongly Accused Thousands of F...
by rvanlaar on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @12:53PM
(#26479396)
I'm Dutch and am following this scandal for quite some time. This article strikes me as being odd.
Yes, computers were used in the decision process and no I don't believe them to be algorithms.
It was specifically coordinated and covered up from the top. As your highlight shows, it was specifically designed this way. Which means it was a business process.
"In one of the more egregious examples of the lack of humanity in the authorities’ approach, a report from Trouw revealed that the tax office had baselessly applied the mathematical Pareto principle to their punishments, assuming without evidence that 80 percent of the parents investigated for fraud were guilty and 20 percent were innocent. "