Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by spenrose on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:19PM
(#2647294)
See http://thinkprogress.org/yglesias/2011/06/12/243047/a-follow... . "The Mercatus Institute’s freedom score was significantly linked to (by state)- lower educational attainment (measured by percent of Bachelor degrees or higher), lower population density, lower per capita GDP, increased infant mortality, increased accident mortality, increased incidence of suicide, increased firearm mortality, decreased industrial R&D, and increased income inequality."
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by nickff on Sunday June 12, 2011 @06:40PM
(#2647576)
It may also be interesting to study whether freedom is a leading (or lagging) indicator of prosperity, as it is likely that laws have a gradual impact, not an immediate one.
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by nowarninglabel on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:20PM
(#2647297)
If you don't want to read the whole thing, basically in the authors' viewpoints: smoking, motorist, mandatory health care, and gun laws lead to a state being less free. To make states more free, get rid of any such laws. If you don't agree with how the authors measure freedom, then you probably won't agree with the conclusions they came to (I certainly don't).
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by driverdan on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:50PM
(#2647369)
It's impossible to take into account every law. Many of those issues impact personal freedom. Government regulation of personal freedom is a fine gauge for overall freedom.
How would you have done it? What issues would you have selected?
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by Steko on Sunday June 12, 2011 @06:37PM
(#2647571)
"Government regulation of personal freedom is a fine gauge for overall freedom."
Some of us disagree.
"How would you have done it? What issues would you have selected?"
The most important things I would look at are education outcomes of the first and second quartile (of household income) and the diversity of employment available.
I would also look at pollution levels, highway fatality rates, incarceration rates, certain crime rates, certain disease rates, services received for those dreaded taxes, entertainment and cuisine options, we could go on...
Big towns don't become cities and cities don't become big cities and big cities don't turn into metropolii through coercion. They're big because people run away from South Dakota and never go back. Freely.
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by gwright on Sunday June 12, 2011 @06:48PM
(#2647590)
You seem to be listing a variety of quality of life issues, which I don't think is quite the same as 'freedom'. I'm not suggesting that it wouldn't be worthwhile to investigate those issues, just that it seems to be a different focus than the linked report. Your focus would seem to compliment rather than refute the goals of that report.
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by Steko on Sunday June 12, 2011 @07:24PM
(#2647633)
I think you're totally missing my point. Not only the government encroaches on your freedom. You can't just look at the highway regulations as encroaching on your freedom without also looking at the guy slamming into your car* as encroaching on your freedom too.
* which may be the direct result of a lack of regulation. See: Montana.
The corporation polluting your water source is encroaching on my freedoms. People that break into your house encroach on your freedoms. People that breath smoke in public areas that give other people cancer encroach on our freedom.
More saliently for me freedom involves fundamental choices. People want to say what they want, read what they want, go where they want, do what they want, eat what they want. Kids that are undereducated have their choices (read: freedom) massively curtailed. People that live in an area where everyone is a farmer have their choices (read: freedom) massively curtailed. If I want to get thai food for dinner and there's no thai restaurant for 300 miles my choices have been curtailed. If the local library doesn't stock Harry Potter my freedoms have been limited. If the internet is too crappy for netflix my freedom is limited compared to elsewhere.
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by gwright on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @05:31PM
(#2654858)
I don't think that equating "choice" with "freedom" is all that helpful in understanding choices or freedom.
They aren't the same thing and insisting that they are just makes it hard to talk about either concept.
Generally when people talk about 'freedom' in a political sense (which is what the original report was about) they are talking about the way government limits actions and not about how your particular circumstances are different than someone else's.
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by chairface on Sunday June 19, 2011 @09:21AM
(#2670808)
I don't see a freedom listed anywhere in these comments that doesn't come down to the ability to make a choice. In fact, I think a pretty good working definition for "a freedom" is "the ability to make a choice".
Furthermore, the government plays a big role in _increasing_ the number of choices available to people in the first and second income quartiles, as Steko suggested. Looking only at limitations that government places on freedom reveals your bias.
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by asolove on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:03PM
(#2647261)
This is a very interesting report. I would add one anecdotal piece of information: having lived and visited all around the US, the places I would consider living permanently (California, Washington, New Mexico, Maryland, New York) all rank as significantly less free than their neighbors. I have no idea what this means.
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by Steko on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:36PM
(#2647342)
This is not a freedom index. This is a freedom from government index.
Apparently it's cool if you're oppressed by your neighbor playing loud music all night or the company upstream dumping toxic waste into your water supply but we've stepped over the line if the government steps in and tries to actually price negative externalities like you know Hayek[1] and Friedman[2] endorsed.
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by drewcrawford on Sunday June 12, 2011 @07:00PM
(#2647609)
All freedom can be understood in terms of the authority that is displaced [1]. The net amount of liberty, strictly measured, is always conserved [2].
Individual freedom is a restriction upon xenophobic groups; economic freedom shifts the needle in favor of those with the capital; emancipation grants rights to slaves and strips them from slaveowners. The water flows the other way too: you can talk about the "freedom" of Kim Jong Il or Stalin to murder their own people.
The entire political discourse in this country (and, to some extent, HN) will be frozen until we can move past merely reciting mechanically that helping one group comes at the expense of hurting some other group. If we put half as much energy into either throughly examining the moral underpinnings of which groups should be elevated or abased[3], or empirically studying the possible utilitarian effects of this[4] as we spend reciting talking points at each other, we would have a great many of the world's problems already solved.
[1] Understand that I'm trying to be morally neutral here, "freedom" and "authority" are being used descriptively, not prescriptively. Obviously a great many of us have strong opinions that slavery is bad, etc.
[2] By this I mean in any individual exchange, you are taking freedom from one group and are assigning an equal amount of freedom to another group. Human perception can differ a great deal: punishing a murderer has an enormous negative burden upon an individual, but it has an equal and opposite impact to society at large, albeit amortized over a great number of people. This can be hard to see in some cases. Also, I am not claiming that a policy in the long run cannot raise all ships; that is a function of tenth-order consequences, and I (and the parent) are talking about first-order ones.
[3] And by this I mean: is it right to take something from this group and give it to this other group? Under what circumstances? Is inequality bad? Is it bad in proportion to the amount of inequality? Is it still bad if everyone has a sufficient floor of resources that meets their basic needs? These are interesting questions; our current political discourse is not.
[4] And by this I mean: What are some local maxima and non-local maxima for economic output as a function of regulation? If we plot creative output as a function of IP law, what will the graph look like? Can we do empirical studies to confirm or refute the underlying basis for legislation (controlling phenylephrine reducing methamphetamine production, for example)? These are elevating questions that inspire us to learn about our world. We are nowhere close to having this kind of conversation.
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by techiferous on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:43PM
(#2647352)
Want 100% freedom? Move to an uninhabited area and live by yourself.
I think it goes without saying that when you have relationships with people, you give up a little bit of your own freedom. It's not surprising that areas with higher population density are scored as having "less freedom".
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by russell on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:12PM
(#2647278)
No thanks. CA is 48th. They can keep their definition of freedom. I appreciate the no smoking bans and the gun control laws and short term disability (which I had to use this year). They dinged the labor laws, but in CA you can move from job to job without being sued for a non-compete clause. If we are so unfree, how come we have Silicon Valley.
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by te_chris on Sunday June 12, 2011 @05:52PM
(#2647490)
I read their state summary of Cali and their "solutions" were just weird. They prescribed to just out-right cut spending, without specifying anything in particular, just the typical "cut spending". Also, gun control being a limit to freedom? What a strange way to view the world.
Politics presented as research are not useful for anyone really.
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by mw63214 on Sunday June 12, 2011 @03:45PM
(#2647226)
Thanks for posting this. I may be able to tie it into something I've been thinking about lately. Here's a link to my previous post. May seem like it's off-topic, but to me it's dead-on.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2625009
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by amock on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:38PM
(#2647346)
South Dakota has one of the lowest unemployment rates in the country and during my few visits to the state I didn't find any problems with the culture there. Why do you think it isn't doing well culturally and economically?
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by Aloisius on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:57PM
(#2647383)
It is in the bottom 50% of GDP per capita in the United States (26th).
If economic or personal freedom were any indicators of success, I'd expect it to at least be better than average (it is quite a bit below, $47,275/person for the whole US and $37,375 for South Dakota).
Re:Freedom in the Fifty States - An Index of Personal and Ec...
by hugh3 on Sunday June 12, 2011 @05:55PM
(#2647504)
There's a loose correlation between freedom and economic/cultural attainment. It works on large scales and explains the difference between, say, the United States and North Korea.
On smaller scales though, such as comparing different states within the US, other things tend to dominate -- in particular the presence of big cities, which are positively correlated with economic and cultural attainment and negatively correlated with freedom.
Honestly, if this graph were the best case we have for the proposition that freedom is nice then it'd be a pretty weak case.
Another study investigating the link between the two would be interesting but is a non sequitur here.
How would you have done it? What issues would you have selected?
Some of us disagree.
"How would you have done it? What issues would you have selected?"
The most important things I would look at are education outcomes of the first and second quartile (of household income) and the diversity of employment available.
I would also look at pollution levels, highway fatality rates, incarceration rates, certain crime rates, certain disease rates, services received for those dreaded taxes, entertainment and cuisine options, we could go on...
Big towns don't become cities and cities don't become big cities and big cities don't turn into metropolii through coercion. They're big because people run away from South Dakota and never go back. Freely.
* which may be the direct result of a lack of regulation. See: Montana.
The corporation polluting your water source is encroaching on my freedoms. People that break into your house encroach on your freedoms. People that breath smoke in public areas that give other people cancer encroach on our freedom.
More saliently for me freedom involves fundamental choices. People want to say what they want, read what they want, go where they want, do what they want, eat what they want. Kids that are undereducated have their choices (read: freedom) massively curtailed. People that live in an area where everyone is a farmer have their choices (read: freedom) massively curtailed. If I want to get thai food for dinner and there's no thai restaurant for 300 miles my choices have been curtailed. If the local library doesn't stock Harry Potter my freedoms have been limited. If the internet is too crappy for netflix my freedom is limited compared to elsewhere.
They aren't the same thing and insisting that they are just makes it hard to talk about either concept.
Generally when people talk about 'freedom' in a political sense (which is what the original report was about) they are talking about the way government limits actions and not about how your particular circumstances are different than someone else's.
Furthermore, the government plays a big role in _increasing_ the number of choices available to people in the first and second income quartiles, as Steko suggested. Looking only at limitations that government places on freedom reveals your bias.
Apparently it's cool if you're oppressed by your neighbor playing loud music all night or the company upstream dumping toxic waste into your water supply but we've stepped over the line if the government steps in and tries to actually price negative externalities like you know Hayek[1] and Friedman[2] endorsed.
[1] http://businesspublicpolicy.com/?p=1186
[2] http://www.angrybearblog.com/2007/10/friedman-externalities-...
Individual freedom is a restriction upon xenophobic groups; economic freedom shifts the needle in favor of those with the capital; emancipation grants rights to slaves and strips them from slaveowners. The water flows the other way too: you can talk about the "freedom" of Kim Jong Il or Stalin to murder their own people.
The entire political discourse in this country (and, to some extent, HN) will be frozen until we can move past merely reciting mechanically that helping one group comes at the expense of hurting some other group. If we put half as much energy into either throughly examining the moral underpinnings of which groups should be elevated or abased[3], or empirically studying the possible utilitarian effects of this[4] as we spend reciting talking points at each other, we would have a great many of the world's problems already solved.
[1] Understand that I'm trying to be morally neutral here, "freedom" and "authority" are being used descriptively, not prescriptively. Obviously a great many of us have strong opinions that slavery is bad, etc.
[2] By this I mean in any individual exchange, you are taking freedom from one group and are assigning an equal amount of freedom to another group. Human perception can differ a great deal: punishing a murderer has an enormous negative burden upon an individual, but it has an equal and opposite impact to society at large, albeit amortized over a great number of people. This can be hard to see in some cases. Also, I am not claiming that a policy in the long run cannot raise all ships; that is a function of tenth-order consequences, and I (and the parent) are talking about first-order ones.
[3] And by this I mean: is it right to take something from this group and give it to this other group? Under what circumstances? Is inequality bad? Is it bad in proportion to the amount of inequality? Is it still bad if everyone has a sufficient floor of resources that meets their basic needs? These are interesting questions; our current political discourse is not.
[4] And by this I mean: What are some local maxima and non-local maxima for economic output as a function of regulation? If we plot creative output as a function of IP law, what will the graph look like? Can we do empirical studies to confirm or refute the underlying basis for legislation (controlling phenylephrine reducing methamphetamine production, for example)? These are elevating questions that inspire us to learn about our world. We are nowhere close to having this kind of conversation.
I think it goes without saying that when you have relationships with people, you give up a little bit of your own freedom. It's not surprising that areas with higher population density are scored as having "less freedom".
This is off topic in the worst way.
Politics presented as research are not useful for anyone really.
If economic or personal freedom were any indicators of success, I'd expect it to at least be better than average (it is quite a bit below, $47,275/person for the whole US and $37,375 for South Dakota).
On smaller scales though, such as comparing different states within the US, other things tend to dominate -- in particular the presence of big cities, which are positively correlated with economic and cultural attainment and negatively correlated with freedom.
Honestly, if this graph were the best case we have for the proposition that freedom is nice then it'd be a pretty weak case.