Please, no. This is exactly what makes Safari all-around worthless, despite all the hard work they put into it.
Chrome will get forked the minute they do this, and the forked version will restore that functionality, and I will immediately install that fork and uninstall Chrome.
Keep in mind that I said that the legacy extension system should remain in place, for people such as yourself that wish to utilize it.
That said, I wouldn't characterize Safari's content blockers as worthless. It's not as effective as Firefox's ad blockers, but I still rarely see ads. If I had to guess, I'd say under five ads per month manage to sneak through.
This is exactly what Chrome's Manifest v3 offers. As they put it: "There's a new declarativeNetRequest API which lets extensions modify and block network requests in a privacy-preserving and performant way."[0] MV3 went live earlier this year so you can build on it now, but no word on when extensions will be required to migrate.
Manifest v3 has been widely criticized [1] for weakening ad blocking which of course aligns with Google's self-interest. It's a tough balance to strike.
[0] https://developer.chrome.com/docs/extensions/mv3/intro/mv3-o...
So yes, it's technically possible to observe network requests but in practice few should be doing it.
"Hesitant" doesn't convey the level of fear everyone should feel after reading "Has acess to: All data on all websites".
Same applies to apps, of course.
By the way, I think a pi-hole is safer than an ad-blocker extension, but I'm not sure. What would I be opening myself to if it gets hacked and my DNS server is now the enemy?
They could track where you go online via the DNS requests ( the sites at least ), and they could mess with anything unencrypted.
Used to be if an HTTPS site loaded an HTTP script resource it provided a dangerous place middlemen could invade your secure session.
chrome, IE ( presumably now Edge as well ) and firefox rightfully block mixed content by default, and have for some time
https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/Security/Mixed_...
( the mentioned Firefox 23 came out in 2013, so like I said, a while )
Probably not going to be all that popular on HN, but this is why I'm very hesitant about using extensions on Firefox (and I suppose Chrome too, but it's been a while since I've used that browser). I'm not going to audit the source code of these extensions, so why should I trust them with privileges to essentially record every website I visit?
I wish Chrome and Firefox would adopt a content blocking system similar to Safari, where the author of the ad blocker can essentially tell the browser what content to block, but the ad blocker itself doesn't get any information about user activity. This could exist alongside the existing extension system, in case additional capabilities are needed.
Yes this is less powerful than giving the ad blockers content to all the user's browsing history, but I'd happily exchange less effective ad blocking in exchange for enhanced privacy