News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by kjrose on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:03PM (#26459151)
My explanation is that Bitcoin is precisely the opposite of anonymous. If everyone started to use a currency like this it would almost impossible to hide transactions without obviously using something like a "bitcoin laundry service" which in itself would be easy to make illegal.

Essentially, you want to guarantee a way for governments to be able to track every transaction, this would be the way to do it.

That being said, I am not anti bitcoin, I just don't see it as a privacy thing.

Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by laurent92 on Sunday March 14, 2021 @07:01PM (#26460377)
Fun thing, I looked it up for banknotes. Turns out there are only 15 billion euro banknotes. Fits in a Postgres database! Most of the cycles are extremely short: Withdraw at the ATM, pay at the bakery, back to the bank. If banks took note of note numbers, it would probably be straightforward to trace 80% of the transactions. And trace banknotes that stayed 6 months offline, and those that are always withdrawn by someone and used in a specific suburb (=possible drug deal), especially when he pays everything else with credit card.

Of course it is 20x less efficient than tracking Bitcoins, and requires input sources from several places, but it’s fun to know that even banknotes are quite easily traceable.

Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by hypersoar on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:56PM (#26459713)
You can actually test that regulators are doing exactly this. There are a few digital currencies which (attempt to) protect the anonymity of all transactions. Monero is the most popular such coin. Go try and exchange some directly with fiat currency. You'll find that it's quite a bit more difficult than with bitcoin. Most legitimate exchanges don't take Monero to stay within anti-money laundering regulations.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by baby on Monday March 15, 2021 @12:26AM (#26462627)
Looks like coinbase, kraken and binance have zcash. What do you make of that?
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by rendx on Monday March 15, 2021 @09:49AM (#26466061)
Only the unshielded variant.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by baby on Monday March 15, 2021 @07:02PM (#26470448)
So? You unshield and transfer to the exchange.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by thatswrong0 on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:11PM (#26459232)
Yeah I don't know how anyone with a cursory knowledge about how it works would think that it's about privacy. Especially when there are alternatives (such as Monero) that do explicitly try to solve that problem.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by acdha on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:23PM (#26459379)
Have you ever known someone who got involved in some MLM scheme and didn’t want to admit that they a) didn’t check the sales pitch and b) have no way to make more money than they put in unless they convince you to buy something? Bitcoin is the tech version of that.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by kjrose on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:44PM (#26459606)
This is also true for gold, silver and any other currency.

The value only exists because someone else is willing to exchange it for goods or services.

Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by acdha on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:56PM (#26459721)
You’re leaving out a lot: gold and silver have significant industrial usage and aesthetic demand so while their rates fluctuate the floor is based on thousands of years of consistent value. You can certainly lose money buying high and selling low but there’s no equivalent to the way Bitcoin could fall below the cost of running the network if people switched to something else because only a few major holders have a significant reason to use it. Since it’s such a small fraction of a percentage of the global economy, almost nobody other than speculators would notice.

That brings me to why your point is wrong: sovereign currencies are backed by governments and that means that there is some intrinsic demand because that currency is used to pay taxes and is paid to civil servants, contractors, etc. In all but the worst run countries that has a substantial anchoring effect. Bitcoin has nothing like that, which is one reason why it’s so volatile – which is great for a speculator but not anyone writing contracts with values set in BTC.

Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by dkersten on Sunday March 14, 2021 @07:27PM (#26460597)
> You’re leaving out a lot: gold and silver have significant industrial usage

Most of the traded gold sits in a vault and is never touched as then it would need to be retested for purity or something. Sure, if the economy would crash to the point that gold-as-an-investment-instrument is worthless, you could take it out of the vault and sell it for industrial use, so it has at least some intrinsic value, but I doubt it would retain a lot of its value if everyone tried doing that.

Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by acdha on Sunday March 14, 2021 @08:04PM (#26460934)
That’s why I said floor: if you buy gold now, you might not be able to sell it for as much as you hope but it’s exceedingly unlikely that the value will drop to $0 because industrial users will still use and people will keep buying jewelry. You might have to sit on it for a while but thousands of years of history suggest that demand will persist.

In contrast, Bitcoin’s hashes have no industrial or aesthetic value and they’re not even linked to the concept. If Ethereum becomes more popular, cryptocurrencies could be successful as a concept even if Bitcoin speculators have millions of dollars worth of inputs nobody wants to buy. Since there are almost no situations where someone has no other options for a transaction, it’s really for the network to collapse if the price drops below the mining threshold - the number of people who are going to pay a premium to avoid PayPal/Square, wire transfers, etc. is unlikely to be enough to support an intentionally inefficient architecture.

Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by baby on Monday March 15, 2021 @12:28AM (#26462637)
Bitcoin has a floor too: the black market. Go to any dark market and they’ll only accept Bitcoin. This is why even if Bitcoin crashes massively it’ll always have a value. Now that still doesn’t explain why gold and bitcoin are valued that high currently.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by thatswrong0 on Sunday March 14, 2021 @06:43PM (#26460212)
Pardon my babbling - maybe I'm naive but thats why I'm way more on board with ETH over BTC because it can at least facilitate new sorts of.. financial instruments and products (call it what you will, but the fact that NFTs are currently popping off for some artists is pretty cool to see, even if it feels contrived), whereas the value of BTC is basically resting entirely on its first mover advantage. And this is to say nothing of the energy requirements and ecological costs of proof of work..

It's hard for me to just accept the fact that hype drives demand, and demand sets the price. The hype can be a meme or be seemingly ignorant of better alternatives, but it doesn't matter the speculative feedback loop can apparently irrationally sustain itself for a long time.

I really wonder what the next major recession is going to look like.

Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by acdha on Sunday March 14, 2021 @07:09PM (#26460442)
Basically, I’d look at the hard demand as people who _need_ to have a particular asset: if you have a contract saying you’re paying me in Bitcoin that means that you’re going to pay the fees needed to keep the network operating. Very, very few people have those and so in most cases the decision is either based in the belief that you’ll be able to sell for a greater value later or an ideological belief, neither of which is especially stable.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by baobolus on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:13PM (#26459251)
It's impossible to make coinjoins ("bitcoin laundry service") illegal as they can be run p2p and over tor. EDIT: you can of course make them illegal, however it's impossible to enforce that.

You could however make "accepting" coinjoined UTXO's illegal, but the lightning network fixes this (you can use coinjoined coins to open channels, lightning payments do not know the payer).

If a government decides you need to do full kyc to buy a coffee, then it might be time to emigrate :D

Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by gruez on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:24PM (#26459384)
>If a government decides you need to do full kyc to buy a coffee, then it might be time to emigrate :D

The more likely scenario would be that it's treated like cash. You're not going to be questioned for using it to buy coffee, but if you decide to buy a house with a sack of cash they'll start asking questions.

Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by kjrose on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:44PM (#26459601)
Precisely. They would be able to look into any transactions or series of transactions trivially. However in most cases won't care.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by acdha on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:19PM (#26459332)
It’s trivial to require all businesses not to touch transactions involving a list of addresses. Once that happens, all these games fall apart because trying to obscure the identity means that people will only participate in them if they intend to break the law and after the first busts they’ll learn that it’s a bad idea to publish that intention to a public ledger.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by gruez on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:25PM (#26459392)
You can't say "don't touch coins from these addresses" because it would be trivial to DoS people by sending dust from a blacklisted address to other people's wallets.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by acdha on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:41PM (#26459569)
If they sent more than infinitesimal amounts, it’s unsustainable; if they don’t, it’s easily filtered — and that’s assuming that they didn’t just direct you to send the amount to some dump address if you wanted to disavow it. Simply telling a few large exchanges to do that automatically would take care of the majority of users.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by throw99c on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:57PM (#26459736)
You have to be loaded to consider DoSing with current transaction fees anywhere near practical.

And it's not like the government couldn't fine the businesses equal to say, 1.5x the amount transferred from the blacklisted address.

Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by grumple on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:09PM (#26459217)
This is the real answer. It allows governments around the world to easily track all of your transactions- without subpoenas or laws required.
Re:Why Isn't Bitcoin Banned Everywhere? by kjrose on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:43PM (#26459587)
I'm amazed at how many people don't get this. Like the sec would kill for this level of control.