It's clearly not the piece of paper, because I can get many pieces of paper at the store for much less than a dollar. It's not the ink either, since even if I were to get the same ink that's used to make US dollars, mine would be worthless. It's not the pattern of the ink on paper either, as even a photocopy of a bill is worthless. It's not the combination of the paper, ink, and pattern of the ink on paper either, as even if one were to were to pay their taxes with a facsimile of a real bill, they would get rejected.
The intrinsic value of a US dollar comes from the fact that the US government is saying that these specific pieces of paper and metal are special. These special pieces of paper and coins are the only ones that they will accept for payment of taxes, and that's the intrinsic value of them.
It's not terribly unusual for old coins and banknotes to be removed from circulation and then losing their status as legal tender. I haven't found examples from the US specifically, but there is no reason to believe that it couldn't be done.
Also, I believe I've read that the US does not declare old money invalid like a lot of countries do. It might be a collector's item worth more than face value but in theory you can still spend it.
The intrinsic value in a painting is that I enjoy it.
Not how much effort went in to make it, not the market around scarcity and status, but the art. And in that case, indeed the intrinsic value is largely the same between the original and any high quality reproduction.
You are both wrong and right.
I'm not sure what you thought was so absurd about the idea that a painting has no intrinsic value over a print. You are right, it doesn't (assuming a quality print that is pleasing to look at).
It has much other value, but not intrinsic. All the other value is just "we all just decided it's worth a lot of other stuff".
All the other value in a Picasso is the same as the value of paper dollars and bitcoin. Exactly as you say.
[0]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/242138/percentages-of-us...
There are about 154 million tax returns filed per the IRS, and 128 million households. It seems like a lot of returns if half of them don't pay taxes.
It seems like about 78% of tax returns involve paying taxes, in fact. A tax return isn't necessarily a household, but is it that far off on average?
https://www.coindesk.com/ohio-becomes-first-us-state-to-allo...
Which is to say, there's no such thing as intrinsic value. There are scarcity-inducing constraints, including constraints pertaining to market access through intersubjective laws. We mistake the "intrinsicness" of the US dollar to its ubiquity, like fish in water.
As such, it has at the very least the value of being the sole currency that can be used to pay US taxes.