News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by lwhi on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:12AM (#2643820)
"It's even more sad if you think that while all this was going on in the Linux desktop, Apple has successfully launched an unix desktop that has been stable and usable for years. So it is possible and in a short timeframe, which means that Linux on the desktop is a failed experience."

You're comparing apples with pears :)

Apple design an OS for a supremely limited range of hardware. Your comparison isn't fair.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by CrLf on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:35AM (#2643865)
It is, if not only because Windows (NT) also matured during the same timeframe and doesn't run only on a limited set of hardware choices. If Microsoft could do it, Linux could have done it as well. In fact, Linux supports a vast number of hardware component choices and platforms, even obscure stuff. It basically runs on everything, except if that happens to be a laptop or any kind of standard desktop PC hardware components.

In 1998, with a much more immature Linux and X11, it was in some ways ahead of the competition. I remember looking for a free computer in my universities' computer labs and when I had to settle for one of the old and slow 486DX machines, being able to run Netscape remotely on one of the Pentiums being used by another student just fine, fast for me and unoticeable for the other guy.

Windows NT was a joke back then. It has almost no hardware support. When Windows 2000 came out there were even graphics cards better supported on Linux.

But from the Windows 2000 lineage we now have Windows 7, even though Microsoft stood still for so many years with Windows XP.

Meanwhile, Linux gained eye candy, when you are lucky enough to get it to work. The desktop evolved, but Linux did not, and the gap is widening.

BTW: today the decent graphics card marked is mostly ATI/AMD and Nvidia. OS X supports a large number models from both vendors (even those that were never shipped by Apple). How does that fit with the notion that Apple has a more limited set of hardware to support than Linux does?

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by cookiecaper on Saturday June 11, 2011 @06:14PM (#2645022)
Windows works only because everyone accommodates Windows. Just like any other OS, without vendor support you are not going to get very far on hardware compatibility. OS X severely limits the range of applicable hardware and Apple has enough muscle to get support for its models and configurations.

While I agree generally that a lot of boneheaded moves occur on the Linux desktop (like Pidgin->Empathy), I don't think berating hardware support for not being equivalent to Windows is fair. Also, it's usually wrong; I have always had to install drivers every time I have installed Windows in the last five years, but I have only had to install drivers in Linux on a few occasions (MadWifi back before ath9k was around, Broadcom wireless on a friend's Dell laptop, uvcvideo before it was included in the kernel).

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by lwhi on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:37AM (#2643870)
The comparison being made was between Apples Unix-like OS X and Linux. In any case, Linux is formed through community - while Windows is formed by a commercial entity.

Which features of the 'evolved desktop' does Linux currently lack?

EDIT: it seems you've edited your text, and no longer speak of an 'evolved desktop', so perhaps my question isn't relevant anymore.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by CrLf on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:42AM (#2643882)
"Which features of the 'evolved desktop' does Linux currently lack?"

Reliability and usability. Pretty important features, IMHO.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by lwhi on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:45AM (#2643889)
With respect, I don't think those are features. They're attributes.

I have no issues with reliability or usability on my current Linux desktop.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by richmassena23 on Saturday June 11, 2011 @10:34AM (#2643988)
It's precisely the features-level thinking that gets in the way of a usable Linux desktop.

How many more reimplementations of basic functionality on the major desktop environments do we need? It seems like whatever the current window manager is, and however well it works, it'll be thrown out and a new one will take it's place, and take a few years to do what the old one did. We'll throw out the audio stack again at some point. X isn't good enough, so we'll throw that out. Since Wayland isn't network transparent, there will be twelve different ways to add it back in and five incompatible ways to run old X applications on top of it. When those aren't sufficient, we'll throw it out again and start over, ad nauseum. And this applies to most things on the system that are "good enough".

Linux on the desktop is stuck in the 90% category, where 90% is implemented (and as we know, this represents 10% of the work). It's always tempting to avoid the unsexy 90% of the work and write from scratch. The end result is throwing increasing amounts of the baby out with the bathwater.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by lwhi on Saturday June 11, 2011 @10:41AM (#2644005)
This is why I fully support what's going on with the ubuntu desktop. While I love the open source model, I think we need more cohesive top down decisions if we want to be able to use a desktop with a cohesive feel.

I really feel natty is heading in the right direction.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by Joeri on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:22AM (#2643838)
OK, how about this: if the linux community can tell me which subset of hardware it runs as well on as OS X, I'll buy that hardware and nothing else.

I want a linux laptop, with good battery life, stable suspend/resume, solid CPU performance, 3d graphics sufficient for light gaming, and a high-quality fit-and-finish. Which one do I buy?

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by jrockway on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:45AM (#2643887)
I don't know about the "light gaming" aspect. Is the default Sandy Bridge GPU good enough? If so, how about the Thinkpad X220? I got one and it's wonderful. The Wifi reception is stunning, WiMax works, it suspends/resumes instantly, and it lasts for 10 hours on a charge. As for fit and finish, it has the magnesium roll cage, so you can run it over with your car and it probably won't break.

Edit: Installed neverputt on this machine. Works fine with the settings maxed out and the resolution at full screen.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by eropple on Saturday June 11, 2011 @12:10PM (#2644204)
Good machines. I have an X201 and am looking at getting an X220. Linux is not my primary OS on it, but I've installed it (SSD has Windows, HDD has Linux, I swapped in the HDD experimentally) runs very well and seems to be fully supported on all the hardware I care about. The X220 seems to share these characteristics.

And yeah, it's a complete tank. The only downside I have is that both models seem to have issues with Sandforce SSDs and resuming from sleep, but that's a hardware issue instead of an OS one.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by jrockway on Saturday June 11, 2011 @01:37PM (#2644371)
I'm running mine with an Intel 320 SSD, and it's pretty good. (Only downside is that I always encrypt my laptops and I accidentally got the 1 processor variant that doesn't have the AES instructions. Doh!)

Also, the mobile broadband does not work under Linux, despite the fact that the datasheet for the card says "Linux is fully supported". It will show up as a serial port (well, four of them) after you edit the kernel source (sierra.c) to contain this card's USB vendor/product ids. But without a firmware loader and firmware, you can't actually use the broadband. I feel that this will be fixed soon, though, as the Gobi 2000 is quite popular for Linux and this is the Gobi 3000.

The GPS does work.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by eropple on Saturday June 11, 2011 @06:58PM (#2645097)
If I'd been buying a SSD new, I probably would have gone with an Intel one, but I had a Corsair lying around. Whoops.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by jdietrich on Saturday June 11, 2011 @10:38AM (#2643997)
I've just switched to a Lenovo X201. Everything worked perfectly out of the box with Ubuntu 11.04, with the exception of slightly erratic battery life reporting. The experience overall has been more straightforward than any Windows install I've ever done and not too far behind OSX.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by rbanffy on Saturday June 11, 2011 @12:17PM (#2644215)
I am happy with an Acer netbook and a Dell i5 latitude. The Acer isn't fast, mostly thanks to its slow hard disk, but the Dell is good enough. Its GPU won't win any speed contests.

If you feel adventurous, burn a copy of Ubuntu on a USB stick and go to a computer store. Last time I did that I promised the salesman I wouldn't harm their display computers and the guy let me boot a lot of them under Linux so I could check what worked and what didn't.

I'll soon replace the Acer with a Vostro v130. It's small, light and has a configuration that comes with Linux preinstalled. I'll reinstall it immediately, but it's good to know it works.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by aw3c2 on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:41AM (#2643881)
Look into Lenovo. The Thinkpad T61 works very well with Linux from what I know.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by Derbasti on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:46AM (#2643891)
Yeah, that is the point. Just a decent system. At some point, even somewhat higher prices are not too much of a problem provided it works.

Two months ago, me and my father spent two weeks to find one decent laptop for my sister member that was not crippled by a crappy screen, poor battery life, atrocious build quality or weight. And that was meant for a Windows system. We both have jobs, so if we had billed these hours, we could have easily got some really expensive gear just for that.

Adding to that the effort spent for researching hardware compatibility and configuration... This is just nuts.

To come back to the point, I want something that just works. I used to use Linux for several years. Like many others, I ended up with Apple at some point. I simply found out that I preferred to spend money on something decent over wasting time to find a cheap deal.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by Symmetry on Saturday June 11, 2011 @11:40AM (#2644122)
Getting any thinkpad thats been out for at least 6 months will generally work as a rule of thumb.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by mgkimsal on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:35AM (#2643866)
Exactly. The "linux community" doesn't really care if you use it or not, and manufacturers haven't really wised up to the fact that they could possibly sell more if they focused on supporting, say, Fedora X on a limited range of hardware. I suspect that the testing and licensing issues might end up costing them more in the short term than they'd make in increased sales, but I also suspect they'd garner a loyal fanbase and make more $ in the long run.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by hackoder on Saturday June 11, 2011 @04:07PM (#2644725)
Another vote for a thinkpad. I have the t410 with core i5 540m, dedicated nvidia nvs3100, 9 cell battery and 128 gb ssd. Everything works. Suspend, resume, wireless, 5-7 hrs working with virtual machines. The build seems to be pretty good but the MBP seems sturdier to me. People seem to rate the thinkpad as having superior build quality but I feel that the screen and parts of e chassis have flex (no flex on the mbp).

I recently switched from a Mac and I definitely miss it at times but there is enough in the thinkpad/ubuntu combo to hold me over for now (openbox, good tiling managers, source code that is open to scrutiny etc).

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by iskander on Saturday June 11, 2011 @10:28AM (#2643967)
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by absentbird on Saturday June 11, 2011 @10:27AM (#2643964)
From what I have read System76 is a linux only computer vendor that has very strong hardware support.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by cookiecaper on Saturday June 11, 2011 @06:17PM (#2645026)
Buy from System76. Not only do they use "known good" hardware configurations, but they include software called "System76 Driver" that automatically performs any magic necessary to support your machine's full range of features, like modifying udev files, etc.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by lwhi on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:27AM (#2643851)
I would say, do some research :) I won't deny using Linux requires a greater investment of time than many other platforms. Whether it's worth that investment is up to you.

If you do want to make the change, you might as well get used to the disparity now ;)

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by patrickaljord on Saturday June 11, 2011 @03:32PM (#2644638)
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by qjz on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:26AM (#2643846)
MacBook Pro!
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by sciurus on Saturday June 11, 2011 @03:17PM (#2644587)
The latest revision of the Macbook Pro (8.1) is not well supported by Linux. For example, there's no driver for the built-in wireless. Even the older revisions have many features that need manual configuration to work.

https://help.ubuntu.com/community/MacBookPro

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by wpietri on Saturday June 11, 2011 @04:11PM (#2644732)
"Apple design an OS for a supremely limited range of hardware. Your comparison isn't fair."

It is totally fair, because each person has to decide whether they're going to use Linux or MacOS.

Saying it isn't fair is basically saying that MacOS is and always will be a better desktop choice, because Apple picked a solvable problem and the Linux desktop community didn't. I don't know that's true, but that's definitely what "not fair to compare Linux and OS X" means.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by mongol on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:17AM (#2643828)
It might not be fair but at the same time, isn't it true?
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by lwhi on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:18AM (#2643830)
No. Desktop Linux is designed to be device independent. OS X isn't.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by acous on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:40AM (#2643878)
OS X runs on multiple architectures with a wide variety of hardware. You can build a PC out of parts and run OS X on it. Just because the drivers are limited doesn't mean it isn't portable. The thing about OS X is that when the drivers are there, it works reliably and with a minimum of fuss. You can't say that about Linux.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by rjbond3rd on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:54AM (#2643910)
> when the drivers are there...

That's a big qualification.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by acous on Saturday June 11, 2011 @10:28AM (#2643969)
You'd be surprised at the variety of hardware that's supported. Loads of graphics cards, many sound devices, nearly anything USB, lots of chipsets and CPUs.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by rjbond3rd on Saturday June 11, 2011 @03:56PM (#2644697)
Hey, what's a good laptop to use, now that the Dell Mini 9 is so old?
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by pyre on Saturday June 11, 2011 @10:29AM (#2643973)
How's CIFS/SambaFS or NFS support these days? I remember people spouting how Mac 'just works' when I could easily cause a kernel panic if the mount started timing out (or if I put the machine to sleep without unmounting it).
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by acous on Saturday June 11, 2011 @10:46AM (#2644022)
It seems better :) I think the finder was rewritten for snow leopard and I haven't noticed the same horrible clunkiness in relation to slow/unreliable network shares. That said, I nearly always use AFP or SFTP for moving stuff around so those protocols could still be dodgy.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by lwhi on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:48AM (#2643898)
"The thing about OS X is that when the drivers are there, it works reliably and with a minimum of fuss. You can't say that about Linux."

I think you're either trolling or are genuinely misinformed. If it's the latter, please accept my apologies.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by acous on Saturday June 11, 2011 @10:19AM (#2643955)
My relevant experience is with my htpc running linux and my linux/hackintosh dual boot machine.

Both machines are fully supported by Linux and the hackintosh is supported by community kernel extensions. Getting linux up and running for the htpc required a lot of fiddling with config files... adding refresh rates to X manually, custom ALSA configs to enable the audio device to show up correctly, accept the correct sample rates and stream 5.1 properly, adding extra PPAs to get video drivers that support one of the various forms of accelerated video decoding, scripts to shut down gnome when xbmc is running because it interferes with rendering for some unknown reason, messing with launchd because it launched programs that rely on all filesystems being mounted before they were mounted... that's just off the top of my head.

The hackintosh required a boot cd and a package for drivers that weren't natively supported. Once the drivers were installed, it worked. That's it. Everything that took days of tinkering and forum searching on linux just worked.

I have years of experience with linux and this was my first time trying OS X on an unsupported machine. So no, I'm not misinformed and no I'm not trolling, I thought HN was supposed to be civilized :/

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by lwhi on Saturday June 11, 2011 @10:29AM (#2643975)
"[..]You can't say that about Linux"

I don't see how you can make a categorical statement declaring that as long as drivers are written for OS X, OS X is more reliable than Linux.

Hackintosh != most people's experience of OS X.

Your experience will be particular to the hardware you chose, and the implementations you chose to follow.

In the same sense, I wouldn't declare that Linux is more reliable than 'X' because again, there are far too may variables involved to make a fair comparison.

I think a far more pragmatic approach is to accept that Linux can provide a very robust desktop solution - if the necessary investment in time and research is carried out. Largely, imo OS X is successful because this research has already been carried out on the users' behalf.

Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by acous on Saturday June 11, 2011 @11:35AM (#2644108)
Yeah, maybe "reliably" was a bad choice of words, reliability has little to do with it. I agree that Linux on the desktop can be fine if you have the time to set it up for your needs. I just think that setup time is not much fun after a while and not strictly necessary when you look at how the competition does it.
Re:The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop by Maro on Sunday June 12, 2011 @03:47AM (#2645997)
Somebody could try creating a Linux distro that focuses on certain hardware and "just works" on that hardware. Something like "Lenovo Linux" that only works on high-end Lenovo laptops.