As far as surgical “regret” is concerned, of all elective procedures, sexual reassignment surgery has the lowest regret rate of all.
That being said, how can you quantify your response regarding surgical regret in your answer formally?
And, 91% of all responding surgeons "would require a mental health evaluation prior to detransition."
So, once again, nasty politics seem to stem from the clash of totalizing vs nuanced beliefs. "Gender reassignment is a mental disorder" "There is no mental disorder associated with gender reassignment"
* Too many variables between bodies
* Humans don't follow protocols perfectly
* They take too long
* They fail too often, leaving sunk costs
* Experiments are hard to do ethically
And most importantly: you can't just sit and do nothing. When a person is dying or suffering, it's cold comfort to say, "Nobody has paid for a rigorous study, so we're not going to do anything at all".
Psychological problems are even harder. They're nearly impossible to quantify. You can certainly quantify people after they've killed themselves, but until then you've got little more than their self-report to go on. You can make up questionnaires, like they have for ADHD and depression, but what are they calibrated against? In the end, it's just "I feel like X", and they believe you or not.
A sibling comment answered your question pretty well: yes, we can tell that untreated trans people kill themselves at a higher rate. But even so, statistics are less useful than they might appear. They wouldn't have even begun to perform these surgeries unless somebody just took it on themselves to do it, and the first ones were pretty crude. They've become extraordinarily good, and based not on perfect scientific rigor, but just the anecdotal reports of people who say "I need this".
The science helps rule out quackery, which is absolutely critical. There are things that obviously don't work, and the people who sell it know that they don't (or are deliberately avoiding learning). But even a lot of real medicine is less simplistically scientific than we'd like to believe.
One could not, because the concept of “mental illness” is not, as such, defined in terms such that any phenomenon can be empirically validated to be a manifestation of it. Particular named mental illnesses are more or less defined, but there is no underlying rubric by which those definitions can be validated as mental illness.
Section 4 is what you want (table 4.3)
Truly honestly curious. I can't admit to understanding the state of mind in this group of clearly marginalized people, but I can't wrap my mind around the decision to not allow others as well as these same people to freely discuss what is effectively open research.
Aren't there statistics that seem to indicate an even higher suicide attempt rate post-op? This seems like something that should be discussed, if it is true (and if its not, then even more so... to set the record straight).