Re:Journalists Start Demanding Substack Censor Its Writers
by insickness on Thursday March 11, 2021 @02:16PM
(#26427833)
There's no way you could classify Greenwald as only having written meta-commentary on journalism unless you've never read anything else by him in his entire storied career.
Re:Journalists Start Demanding Substack Censor Its Writers
by Barrin92 on Thursday March 11, 2021 @02:19PM
(#26427866)
there is indeed no way I could classify his whole career like that, which is why is used the qualifier 'nowadays'. I am very aware of the amount of investigative journalism he has done. But the point is, that takes institutional support, it cannot be done with a bunch of fans online. And in recent times he has almost exclusively written about nothing else but the online drama surrounding his persona or other journalists.
Re:Journalists Start Demanding Substack Censor Its Writers
by adamcstephens on Thursday March 11, 2021 @03:23PM
(#26428578)
It’s almost like you didn’t read the post, which while a meta commentary on journalism also explicitly calls out recent non-meta articles he has written.
Re:Journalists Start Demanding Substack Censor Its Writers
by Barrin92 on Thursday March 11, 2021 @03:36PM
(#26428705)
I did read the post, and I actually also read the articles in qestion, which also themselves are basically about how the press reported on this or that drama of the week.
With the additional bonus of throwing in increasingly strange and deranged attacks on the Democratic party in particular, probably because it sells well with his newfound audience. This is not 'adversarial, bold investigate journalism', he was allegedly promoting at the Intercept, now he's writing op-eds on the news headline of the week and whining about NPR in every other article.
One is that this entire thing, from both sides has devolved into essentially neverending meta-commentary on journalism, rather than well.. actual journalism.
I have sympathy for people who go independent because they want more freedom and the bosses at the news outlets were breathing down their necks. But people like Bari Weiss, or even Greenwald nowadays are not better. It's nothing but victimhood and uninteresting internal journalism drama between the renegade journalists and the establishment. At the end it seems like they all just profit from the noise.
I have serious issues with the state of mainstream journalism but this antagonistic patronage based system where readers have parasocial attachment to their substack heroes is also terrible. Editors, fact-checking, investigative journalism and so on need resources, at the end of the day most of substack seems to devolve into blogging to a fanbase. There are some nice niches, for example I've been following China scholars on substack who report on the internal politics of China in a way you won't find in general media outlets, but a lot of the most popular people on the site right now seem to try to capitalise on the political environment.