Another related fact is that military build-ups are very fuzzy these days given the amorphous nature of modern warfare. Sponsorship of private corporate armies in contested countries (a la cold war) is more likely than open conflict, because no one wants to risk destablizing everything (and if one were to go that way, nuclear weapons would suddenly be on the table). If a country and associated military can provide some logistical support without overt action, they can maintain plausible deniability (the sort of thing we are doing in Libya, for example, or our highly successful Bay of Pigs operation).
Also, "(and if one were to go that way, nuclear weapons would suddenly be on the table)." --- Do we have any practical defense against nukes?
I guess the answer is no. I was just reading The War Nerd (link posted further down by Bokonist). In the article, the US Naval Institute says "Ships currently have no defense against a ballistic missile attack." Since ships are essentially floating cities, that implies that cities have no defense against a ballistic missile attack. Therefore, neither side would use nuclear weapons.
EDIT: What was I thinking? A nuclear-tipped cruise missile is even better.
There are a variety of missiles which could potentially sink an aircraft carrier. ICBM has the longest range with the largest expense. Torpedoes (not really a missile) have a much shorter range so presumably the old principle applies -- if you can keep subs at a distance your carrier will be safe.
In other words, what you want to hit a carrier is the cheapest missiles where the launching platform (which could be a sub) are outside the range of the enemy, to present the largest quantity of missiles in order to overwhelm the defenses of the carrier.
ICBMs are most likely not the best way to do this, given their expense, but are worth bringing up since the basic principle is the same as in the cold war (shoot lots of ICBMS at a city/country to assure that some will get through).
Also, I believe whether or not any of the armaments are nuclear is fairly irrelevant since a non-nuclear missile (or two or three) can sink a carrier easily enough. That said, sooner or later someone (e.g. N. Korea) will use a nuke, and then all bets are off.
Nuclear torpedoes usually sink two ships - one of them is the target.
PS: For reference: USS SARATOGA (CV-3) - The "Sara" was struck by 2 bombs and 5 Kamikazi's while supporting the Iwo Jima invasion on February 21, 1945. She lost 123 dead with approximately 300 injured. But this attack did not sink her. She survived the war but did not survive the atomic bomb tests off of Bikini Atoll. She went under after undergoing her second nuclear explosion on July 25, 1946. She was a tough old girl. http://ffhiker.tripod.com/index-7.html
Edit: The US is also using much larger aircraft carriers now they they did in WWII. Picture a 100,000 ton boat with 2 × nuclear reactors AND 4 × steam turbines, vs the 36,000 ton Saratoga (CV-3). There are many reasons the US has not lost a carrier since 1945, suggesting they are an easy target is ignoring a lot of navel history.
There's also the fact that you don't have to kill the carrier to render it ineffective. A single missile hit to something like landing deck or the aircraft hangar can result in damage that takes months or years to repair, effectively removing the carrier from the battlefield.
Carriers are amazing amazing ships - I eould love a game solely focused on a war where an ultra vast ocean world made it such that all wars were carrier based and had vast submarine based support fleets.
It would be great to have physics sims that allowed us armchair admirals to test carrier strengths against such traps as nuke icbm and cruise missles.
I think the original article the report was in support of more funding for advances to the Aegis Ballistic Missile Defense System.
Regarding whether or not this is a practical asset, so much of military power is "soft" (you might say political, but I think that's an oversimplification), I don't think you could fairly call this an impractical asset. China has traditionally focused on maintaining power in there sphere of the world. As others have noted, the power of an aircraft carrier is that it allows you to project power globally. They could send the aircraft carrier to a lot of places that would make other countries unhappy, but not unhappy enough to actually start a military attack over it - thus the carrier would have been an effective tool.
From a more political perspective, there's been a regional arms buildup. India already has a carrier and is building more, and India and some other Asian countries have been buying up submarines.
Military defense strategy isn't all that much different than IT defense strategy. It means using layers of security. If your only defense against missiles is a single missile-defence system, you're probably going down.
This ideology is at the core of how how a US Naval Carrier Battle Group works. A carrier battle group (CVBG) is a complex interplay of various types of ships and aircraft with many layers of defense. The idea is to never let your enemy get in a position to execute a fatal attack.
If you want to take it further, think of it in Starcraft terms. No one asks, "Is a Terran Battlecruiser a political statement, not a practical asset?" Any reasonably talented Starcraft player knows that you don't send a Battlecruiser in to battle alone [1].
For example, this one carrier took years to build. Could it not be sunk simply by swarming it with ICBMs?
How many of those missiles do we have? How quickly could we produce them?
How would you defend a carrier from missiles? Any new ideas?
(I realize the carrier is likely a political statement, not a practical asset. I'm just wondering about the answers to my silly questions. Bored and daydreaming.)