Re:Speeding up Chrome's release cycle
by hartator on Thursday March 04, 2021 @01:54PM
(#26346528)
I rather them to slow down and address the performance issues.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Have they given any follow-up to the https://chromeisbad.com fiasco?
Well, if by "fiasco" we mean "a random person wrote some random observations about his computer and chrome on some random website" then, probably they don't really need to follow up on it...
Loren Brichter is a long-time Mac developer and hardly a "random person"; and his claims were based on anecdata from multiple machines and Twitter reports. Pareidolia is certainly a reasonable null-hypothesis (similar to 99% of computing rain-dances, like repeated defragmentation, or "closing" iOS apps). But assuming the problem isn't completely coincidental or imagined, it would still be good to get to the bottom of it, whether the root problem is Apple's or Google's.
Just now noticed the bug-tracker thread: https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=115840...
I think it's important and may explain a lot. The fact that they started looking into this is a good sign.
I've always wondered what the slowdown with having chrome or not was and this could explain it.
Re:Speeding up Chrome's release cycle
by jasonvorhe on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:30PM
(#26347014)
Has there ever been a deeper investigation into this that goes beyond "I did a thing on my computer and something changed somehow"?
Looks like a MacOS issue to me. I used Chrome for years on my x201 with i3, it idled only a few degrees above room temp with Chrome open.
Release cadence and performance issues are orthogonal.
Frequent releases just mean you get updates as they become available. That doesn't mean they can't take on longer-term issues that need several release cycles to complete.
Chrome project has a pretty robust system of continuous benchmarking where regressions are automatically detected and filed as bugs, and the causing CLs are automatically found by bisection. For example, a recent regression:
https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=117656...
What, in your expert opinion, is missing from this regime?