A few minutes with Wikipedia and a calculator would also lead to the conclusion that transmission losses in the worst case of having to transmit the power the longest straight line within Chinese borders are somewhere between 5 and 10 %.
1. If you are the Communist party and you are planning electricity for a 5M inhabitants city in 2007, growing at 9% (doubling every ~7 years, electricity use is highly correlated with economic growth), you need to make the plants 10 times bigger than needed for them to last 20 years
2. Mining equipment is placed next to the source of electricity
3. Corrupt officials are co-opted (just turn on that turbine that is wasted working capacity for you, and I'll pay you in cash)
4. Profit?
FWIW, I think this doesn't happen exclusively in China but in every place where there's idle energy capture potential.
https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/09/const...
Also, the green power generation requires the manufacturing and distribution of things like solar panels, which is not currently CO2-neutral and has other environmental impacts.
There are also theoretical (if not real) limits to how much you can actually expand grid capacity. Mining already even in conservative estimates consumes a lot of power, and unless PoS is fully rolled out it will continue to consume more and more, which will put increasing strain on local power grids.
That’s the funny thing about this genre of arguments (Bitcoin improves GPU tech; Bitcoin subsidizes clean energy) — even if true, the gains will only be realized if there’s a crypto price crash, since otherwise mining absorbs the gains that it is responsible for by definition.
Similarly, one can point out all the advances that the Apollo program brought that are unrelated to space travel. COVID brought in lots of scientific insights that will bear fruit regardless of whether we have to deal with any other coronaviruses in the future.
The broken window fallacy does not consider the benefits from improvements of technology that may result from destruction. Suppose that smashing a bunch of windows would lead to permanent improvements in glassmaking efficiency. In that case, the benefits in the long run would far outweigh the short term costs. Of course, that's not a given with any form of destruction, but I am arguing that it is the case with cryptocurrency.
Like I said, not all destruction is destined to create excess value, but some destruction is, and I am arguing that this is the case here specifically. A counterfactual where this money would've been spent on something even more beneficial doesn't really matter. It wasn't spent that way and it could also have been spent in numerous other ways that are even less beneficial.
I think the opposite is true. Now that we have cheap GPU accelerators, the machine learning revolution is taking place. But where does that cheap GPU accelerator come from? Clearly, the more frivolous "gaming demand" was paving the way for machine learning, not the other way around. It's similar for mining.
> All the crypto boom did is create shortages and raise prices.
Rising prices are a signal to the market that production needs to be increased, which lowers prices in the long term. Shortages are short term.
The post you were replying to is disagreeing with this. Power made available for extremely low cost next door to a hydroelectric dam etc. might be technically "on the grid" in that there is some connection between that town and the rest of the grid, but if the long-distance transmission lines are already at maximum capacity (which is usually the case, otherwise power wouldn't be any cheaper in those towns than anywhere else) then that surplus power is de facto not available to the rest of the grid.
Not necessarily in the sense of having their own physical wire, but if the path from the power generation facility to where the mining is taking place doesn't take up any long-distance transmission capacity (which is why power in those towns is cheap) then it's de facto the same thing.
> there's still a huge amount of mining that would by necessity have to happen on the grid. If consumers or small-time business owners get involved in crypto they have no choice but to use the grid.
If they want to participate as full nodes, sure. Maybe they shouldn't. And even if they are, they're going to be an insignificant fraction of mining volume.
This is a hypothesis, but where is the evidence, i.e. actually increased CO2 emissions? My argument is that most of this mining is using electricity that would otherwise not be used or produced. That is why it is so cheap in the first place.
If the power was literally not being used the cost would be negative - this is a real thing that happens. If it costs you more than $0/kWH you are creating demand and potentially increasing CO2 emissions.
That isn't really related. Like I said, it's possible the temporary spikes in prices can make mining with fossil fuels profitable, but that is in the short term.
> If the power was literally not being used the cost would be negative - this is a real thing that happens.
Price only goes negative when there is too much energy produced, but downregulating production would be even more expensive. This is mostly a problem with wind energy combined with coal or nuclear plants. Otherwise you would downregulate production so you don't have to pay the penalty. Consuming this excess energy in a profitable manner would keep prices above zero.
Most of the mining happening in China, for instance, is happening near non-CO2 emitting plants (hydropower, wind) where energy is virtually free most of the time. The increased demand for energy that is otherwise of little value may in fact be financing a rollout for renewable energy. The primary problem with renewables like wind power today is not production capacity, it is storage.
It stands to reason that at least some mining temporarily leads to increased CO2 emissions due to revenue exceeding the cost of fossil fuels. However, this only happens in the short term, because of difficulty adjusting revenue to the point where only the very cheapest energy sources remain competitive, and these are not fossil fuels. Furthermore, the increased demand for more efficient semiconductors finances the R&D required to lower the power usage of all computing into the indefinite future.