News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The US IPO cartel by barrkel on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @09:37PM (#2631704)
That narrative doesn't explain the discrepancy. Why hasn't competition altered the rates?
Re:The US IPO cartel by tedunangst on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @10:17PM (#2631781)
Would you be more likely to eat at a restaurant that had a big "Tips are only 10% here" sign in the window?
Re:The US IPO cartel by barrkel on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @10:23PM (#2631789)
If one restaurant has a "default" service charge of 10%, and another has 20%, it very probably will sway me to the 10% one, yes (these figures will be printed at the bottom of the menu, are normally added to your bill but you can ask to have them removed, and the menu will be at the door or window, visible from the street, I believe it's a legal requirement). But then tipping culture is different in the UK.

I understand what you're trying to get at - giving investment banks an incentive etc. - but the high degree of conformity doesn't make sense. Even large slices of small pies won't interest banks much, and similarly only a small slice of a huge pie ought to interest them plenty.

Re:The US IPO cartel by tedunangst on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @10:54PM (#2631857)
The point wasn't really so much about the incentive, but just that service fees are often cultural. Conformity doesn't come from economic forces, but cultural ones.
Re:The US IPO cartel by jamesaguilar on Wednesday June 08, 2011 @12:25AM (#2632014)
I think there's a big difference between service fees on a $10 dinner and a $100 million-$5 billion IPO. In particular the extent to which they are affected by custom is probably different considering the size of the sums. And the reason for the "tip" . . . nobody feels bad about giving an investment bank as little as they can get away with, but with tips it's a different story.
Re:The US IPO cartel by lefstathiou on Wednesday June 08, 2011 @10:46AM (#2633284)
Financial services industry operates more like healthcare and law than say consumer products with regard to pricing practices and competition (in the context of advisory, not lending). You wont find a lot of doctors or lawyers bragging about how low their rates are because price is a perceived indicator of quality. That being said, a convention began a long time ago that a fair price to pay to a top notch bank is 7% and everyone has stuck to it. If you were a client and were quoted 8%, you would demand to know what makes you different than the hundreds of other (perhaps weaker) companies that got a better deal. If you were quoted 5%, unless the circumstances were extraordinary, the dozens of companies in the pipeline are going to expect the same treatment. So the question to the investment bank comes back to this: why rattle a system that works and is accepted as is?

To be frank, price competition exists in banking but most companies dont care about it. There are a lot of IPO's that take place and you'd be amazed how many of them "fail". You just dont hear about them because they are so small and underwritten by smaller banks. Big/successful companies dont care about the arbing the 100-150 basis points and risk jeopardizing the success of their IPO by picking someone other than Goldman.

Re:The US IPO cartel by scottkduncan on Wednesday June 08, 2011 @11:02AM (#2633369)
I would be curious to know if you have any ideas about why this convention doesn't hold in Europe? Is it less important to signal quality by working with a top bank? Are regulations different? As a finance outsider, it seems that European banks would be playing a very similar role to their American counterparts and financing a comparable range of companies. The difference in the spread is quite striking.