Also, if your observation above is in fact correct and investment banks continue basing their pricing on what they've done for the last 20 years, then I wouldn't worry about the government coming in and messing with their business - reliance on logic like "it's how we've always done things" is sure to bring about obsolescence first.
The scary thing is this probably speaks volumes about the insidious effect of the banking industry on the US economy. (BTW - I am a brit and living on the UK but I care because if the US economy goes I'm pretty sure it'll drag the UK and most of western europe down with it.
I'm getting more and more worried about the US.
I understand what you're trying to get at - giving investment banks an incentive etc. - but the high degree of conformity doesn't make sense. Even large slices of small pies won't interest banks much, and similarly only a small slice of a huge pie ought to interest them plenty.
To be frank, price competition exists in banking but most companies dont care about it. There are a lot of IPO's that take place and you'd be amazed how many of them "fail". You just dont hear about them because they are so small and underwritten by smaller banks. Big/successful companies dont care about the arbing the 100-150 basis points and risk jeopardizing the success of their IPO by picking someone other than Goldman.
Is what it is. The law of unintended consequences tells me that should the govt try to mingle with this practice, the outcome will likely be that bigger/more desirable companies get preferred treatment (like Google attempted to do) at say 6-7% while the relatively smaller companies pay a liquidity/desirability premium to make up for it. Same thing happened to credit card rates, which are now at all time highs...