News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by kwanbix on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:38AM (#26313509)
Move to Bitwarden. It has a great free version but if you want to support them, you can pay 10 USD per year. Less than 1 dollar a month. Really reasonable.
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by tchalla on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:56AM (#26313614)
Bitwarden has one critical feature that makes it unusable. For example, one feature that has been "in the works" for last 3+ years : "auto-save newly created passwords with a prompt" [0]. I understand that it is a different model than LastPass but 3y+ for a critical feature is one of the reasons BitWarden is not the first choices.

[0] https://github.com/bitwarden/browser/issues/320

PS - If this issue does not occur for you personally, great but it does not for me and many others. Thus, it is unreliable.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by toyg on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:57AM (#26313961)
To clarify: the issue is that autosaving works only some of the time, not that it doesn't exist. From observation, it seemed to be overly keen at one point (prompting excessively) and now is very shy (not prompting even when it really should). At least that's my experience on Firefox. Seems to work better on FF/Mac than FF/Win.
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by tchalla on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:36AM (#26315720)
In my case, the some of time is almost never - macOS /Safari and macOS / Firefox.
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by simias on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:30AM (#26314156)
I'm using pass as my password manager but I heard a lot of good about bitwarden so I decided to give it a try, that would be one fewer thing to administrate for me.

One very important feature for me is having a command line interface because I have a bunch of scripts that need to be able to query the password manager. Fortunately bitwarden provides a first party CLI that seems pretty fully featured, so I was optimistic.

Anyway, I try to install bitwarden-cli through AUR and I see that one of the dependencies is nodejs.

Oh no.

Right so it's a javascript thingy. I'm a bit shocked, but then I decide that I'm being silly and it's what all the kids use these days and it's just a programming language and who cares. So I decide to push forward and install the binary version of the program (installed size is 65MB, as a comparison point lastpass also provides a CLI tool written in C that's 0.2MB installed).

Since I don't know how the tool works, I decide to launch it without argument to get the usage. It takes 0.6 seconds to display the usage. That's with a hot cache.

Oh no.

So that's the story of how I kept using pass. I know that some people will say that it's not that big of a deal, and I know that for bitwarden's devs it might make sense to implement their client that way because it lets you reuse some code and get good portability, but I just can't even. I'm running on an overclocked desktop computer capable of executing billions of instructions per second, I can play 4K videogames at 60 fps but apparently I get 1.6 UPS (usages per second) with this tool. It unironically makes me sad that this is the state of software engineering nowadays.

Reading this thread it seems like it's a mess when it comes to privacy too, so I suppose I dodged a bullet.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by fdw on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:09AM (#26314437)
I agree that the Bitwarden cli is awful. You have to log in, and store the token it gives you manually so that it knows you're logged in.

However, I found https://github.com/doy/rbw , and alternative OSS cli written in Rust, and it's exactly what I wanted. (Disclaimer: I liked it so much I wrote a rofi integration for it.)

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by simias on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:30AM (#26315071)
If I had known about this client I might be using bitwarden today! Thank you for that.
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by jeroenhd on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:40AM (#26314218)
I've never had a use for a command line password manager so I've got to ask: how does this fit into your workflow? I'm honestly mostly using a password manager in my browser and on my phone; I don't need command line authentication all that often.

I didn't even know LastPass had a CLI, but it seems like it's a rewrite of the algorithm and surrounded toolset in C.

I can understand why the Bitwarden devs didn't want to go through the effort, though. The tiny minority of Linux-users that want a command-line password manager is not exactly worth a lot of development time, so I figured they just put their JS library in a NodeJS application and called it a day.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by simias on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:28AM (#26315051)
I don't do a lot of "serious stuff" on my phone, so whenever I need to input a password there I just display the password on my computer and enter in there, if I regularly needed to access my passwords however my current solution would be unusable.

As for my workflow I don't have any auto-fill on my browser, I just use "pass -c my-password-entry" to put it in the clipboard and paste it from there. It's arguably less secure than having it autofilled I suppose, but it hasn't been an issue so far (and pass clears the clipboard after 45 seconds to mitigate the risk).

Then I have a bunch of scripts for starting my VPN connections, my email client etc...

I should add that my pass's GPG key is stored on a yubikey and I need to physically press the button to decrypt, so that adds a pretty good layer of protection.

So yeah, I realize that my use case is incredibly niche, but I do think that being able to use your password manager in scripts could be useful in some cases even for people who are less enamored with the terminal than I am.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by cutthegrass2 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:04AM (#26314399)
For me I have 1 use case - logging onto a Cisco Anyconnect VPN.

Since I do this multiple times per day I wrote a simple bash script that invokes Anyconnect and supplies the VPN credentials it pulls out of my password manager. I alias this script in my shell environment so it's as simple as typing "vpn" to get logged onto the corp network, saving the hassle of mousing around to get onto the VPN.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by bspammer on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:42AM (#26315196)
I use it fairly regularly for cases where I want to input something sensitive on the command line, and not have that stored in my bash history.

For example something like

curl -u user:"$(pass SomeSecret)" https://api.website.com

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by Fnoord on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:32AM (#26315670)
> I use it fairly regularly for cases where I want to input something sensitive on the command line, and not have that stored in my bash history.

Nice usage.

You could also use HISTIGNORE variable, history -d, or unset HISTFILE. Here are some examples [1]

[1] https://www.rootusers.com/17-bash-history-command-examples-i...

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by pizza234 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:30AM (#26313811)
Bitwarden is a reasonable alternative, but it's important to be aware of the weak points compared to Lastpass (which IMO, makes it a good-enough-but-no-great-choice).

Autofill is relatively poor (it fails even on HN!). Also, Lastpass has a convenient timed expiry that doesn't work (well) on Bitwarden (BW will expire the login when the browser is closed).

All in all though, I do support the recommendation, in particular, because Lastpass works extremely poorly on Firefox (at least, that's what caused my switch some time ago).

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by juriansluiman on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:40AM (#26313866)
> Autofill is relatively poor (it fails even on HN!).

Autofill is much more customizable than LastPass afaik. You can both define how (domain)name matching should occur as you can have multiple entries to match.

This means you can have instagram.com (as website) and androidapp://com.instagram.android (as app) which will use the same autofill entry.

If you configure name matching correctly, any site should be able to provide autofill. My HN entry does match with news.ycombinator.com with default matching settings. But matching settings include hostname / domain name / starts with and even regex!

> Also, Lastpass has a convenient timed expiry that doesn't work (well) on Bitwarden (BW will expire the login when the browser is closed).

You can specify BW timeout settings. Even further, you can define if BW should lock the session (only a password is required to unlock) or if a sign-out is required. With a sign-out, you also need to provide your MFA if applicable.

Time outs can happen directly (after autofill), after an amount of time (1/5/15/30 minutes or 1/4 hours) or upon closing the browser.

So tbh, there is plenty to configure Bitwarden to suit your needs.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by satysin on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:17AM (#26314078)
I have yet to find a site that autofill fails on. Hacker News works perfectly for me and always has.

As for Bitwarden locking (expiring) when the browser is closed, I disable that as my system is secured so locking the vault in the browser is overkill for me.

My only real complaint with Bitwarden is the macOS app lacks TouchID support.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by akvadrako on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:12AM (#26314047)
> Autofill is relatively poor (it fails even on HN!).

In what context? I found Autofill poor on Android for FF before I gave it the "draw over other apps" permissions. Otherwise I've only seen it fail on a few sites out of hundreds, mostly with weird login flows.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by Fnoord on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:35AM (#26315709)
> Autofill is relatively poor (it fails even on HN!)

HN Autofill works perfectly well for me with Firefox + Bitwarden extension on macOS (I know it also works with other combinations). If it does not seem to work, select a password field. Does it for me.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by rsa25519 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:38AM (#26313855)
> it fails even on HN!

Huh, weird, it works fine for me in Firefox.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by toyg on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:58AM (#26313967)
Same here. I reckon some people set up their passwords manually, or didn't pay attention when creating the item, and now their URL-based autofill is screwed up.
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by janandonly on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:50AM (#26313580)
added bonus, Bitwarden has " only " two trackers in it

https://community.bitwarden.com/t/remove-embedded-trackers-f...

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by ro_bit on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:54AM (#26313602)
I feel like these trackers (Firebase Analytics and Visual Studio Crash Reporting) need to be looked at in context of the data they actually send and who they report to. According to the thread

> In the Mobile apps, Firebase Cloud Messaging (often mistaken for a tracker) is used only for push notifications related to sync and performs absolutely no tracking functions. Microsoft Visual Studio App Center is used for crash reporting on a range of mobile devices. In the Web Vault, Stripe and PayPal scripts are used for payment processing only on payment pages.

Compare this to LastPass where it was feeding data to Google Analytics and MixPanel, which do much more invasive levels of analysis in general.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by Nextgrid on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:23AM (#26314110)
Crash reporting within a password manager is a serious liability considering memory dumps would often contain secrets or encryption keys.
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by thetanil on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:23AM (#26313771)
Firebase is Google. I don't know why they deserve different levels of trust. If Firebase has your permission to harvest your sync info, there is no reason to think this doesn't get copied right on over into googles 'track every click and movement' apparatus.
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by sofixa on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:59AM (#26313974)
Firebase is Google, yes, and the name of a suite of mobile-related products. They have ML Kit, Crash analytics, configuration management, auth etc.

Also, Firebase Cloud Messaging is the only way to have push notifications on Android.

Using either of their products ( outside of Firebase Analytics and maybe Firebase Auth) isn't tracking users and isn't harvesting user data. It's using tools to make apps, that's it.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by Nextgrid on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:22AM (#26314105)
This assumes you're trusting Google. Technically you are still sending a lot of data to them (IP address and persistent identifier, which would allow them to correlate other info they gather from other sources) and they have the capability to use it for nefarious purposes if they decide.

Google is a malicious actor as a result of their business model and has already demonstrated their willingness to breach the GDPR with the non-compliant tracking consent prompts they use on their services, so it isn't that far-fetched to believe they can also use data from other services in ways you don't expect, especially when they can have plausible deniability.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by smitop on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @12:02PM (#26317457)
The Firebase Data Processing and Security Terms [1] (section 5.2.1) limit Google's usage of any data they obtain through Firebase and would seem to prevent that sort of tracking.

[1] https://firebase.google.com/terms/data-processing-terms#5.pr...

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by iCarrot on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:59AM (#26313979)
Also in the same thread, you can download the no tracker version from F-droid.
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by chronolitus on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:57AM (#26314342)
Love bitwarden and use it every day (paid user).

I like almost every part of the experience except an annoying issue where the autofill doesn't work on firefox android (everything latest version). it shows up 10% of the time, for a few milliseconds. I've seen similar issues dating back from a year ago (https://github.com/bitwarden/mobile/issues/784). Makes me wonder how such commonly used things can be so broken for so long (see also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26296339).

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by behringer on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:40AM (#26315762)
Lastpass is the same way.
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by francis-io on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:20AM (#26313756)
I setup bitwarden_rs recently on my own server with traefik in front. I use the android app and browser plugin which point to my own instance. Currently it's only working on my home network, but I'm working from home.

This setup seems fine for me. It seems faster and snappier than Lastpass, but that might just be down to the fact it's hosted on my LAN. All in all, I'm happy I moved and happy I'm now in control of such sensitive information as my passwords.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by aquir on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:38AM (#26313851)
I done the same after the first breach and when they almost doubled the yearly sub free. Bitwarden is open source and works just fine. Had no issues with it
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by int_19h on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:06AM (#26314020)
https://lesspass.com/ is another interesting option.
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by sneak on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:16AM (#26314070)
Bitwarden grants full remote access to your computer to the Bitwarden developers if you use the desktop app.

https://github.com/bitwarden/desktop/issues/552

The issue has been reported and they refuse to fix it.

This bug renders the Bitwarden encryption irrelevant, as the Bitwarden devs can always access your passwords regardless if they choose.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by codys on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:36AM (#26314190)
For those just scanning the comments, "full remote access" is just being used to mean "has an automatic update system" here
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by sneak on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:43AM (#26314242)
An interaction-free automatic update system is, by definition, RCE, which is equivalent to full remote access.

The Bitwarden devs can always access your passwords at any time if they choose to do so, as a result. This, to me, is as serious a vulnerability as lacking encryption in the first place.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by gruez on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:27AM (#26315624)
How do you feel about browsers or operating systems that are updated on a monthly/weekly basis? Do you not upgrade them ever? Do you set them to manual update but blindly accept all the updates? Or do you manually update only after performing a detailed code review of all the source code changes, along with doing a build yourself to make sure nothing malicious was slipped in?
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by sneak on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:07PM (#26320748)
I disable automatic updates on all software on my machines, and update them periodically on a schedule, using downloads that are verified as authentic.

I'm not sure where the rest of your questions come from. "Do you not upgrade them ever?" does not logically follow from being opposed to the major security vulnerability that no-interaction automatic binary modification poses.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by brigandish on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:58AM (#26314353)
How do they decrypt the vault without the master password?
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by sneak on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:00AM (#26314368)
By replacing the client code with code that exfiltrates the password the next time you enter it.

Alternately, brute forcing the client password is straightforward due to their use of a too-fast KDF and low iteration count.

https://github.com/bitwarden/jslib/issues/52

https://github.com/bitwarden/server/issues/589

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by brigandish on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:45AM (#26315217)
I agree that automatic updates should have a toggle, Signal desktop is another client where the devs won't provide one and have even taken egregious steps to prevent blocking it. Run in a reduced-privilege account though and either client will still require your assent via the admin rights to install.

You're also right about the KDF but to be fair to them the devs say they'll accept work from a fork[0] to Argon2, if and when it's done (properly).

[0] https://community.bitwarden.com/t/switch-to-argon2/350/24

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by jeroenhd on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:54AM (#26314315)
That's a very disingenuous way of putting it. If you use the application, there's auto update functionality (with a confirmation dialog box) if:

- You're on Windows and not using the Windows Store version or a "portable" version of the application - You're on macOS and not using the app store version - You're on Linux and you're using the AppImage version

Given the security-sensitive nature of the application and the target audience (mostly non-technical people), I think it's not a bad thing that this software has auto update functionality.

If you want to be free of this behaviour, you can either install the application through your system package manager/app store so you can control the update behaviour there, or run a development build of your vetted version of the source code.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by sneak on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:59AM (#26314357)
It doesn't have a confirmation dialog box, it simply notifies you that it has already happened. You can't easily prevent it. The vulnerability has already occurred by the time the dialog box is displayed.

If you simply reboot your computer, the new code executes.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by jeroenhd on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @07:32AM (#26327522)
Does it? From what I could tell from the source code, it seems like it should ask first.

Even still, auto update is a feature, not a vulnerability. It's the only way to get non-technical people to patch their software because people are afraid of change. Even if there's a huge vulnerability in Bitwarden, tons of people won't click the "yes update please" button because they're afraid updates change the way the tool works or break something.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by sneak on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:05AM (#26340260)
> Even still, auto update is a feature, not a vulnerability.

Autoupdate is fine, so long as it's opt-in. It is a massive vulnerability if not, amounting to the same control as a standard remote access toolkit: full RCE.

> It's the only way to get non-technical people to patch their software because people are afraid of change.

Not only is this a factually incorrect statement, it also contains a presumption that Bitwarden's developers have some right to decide for the end user what software runs on their computer, when the end user is the final authority, for better or worse, on what code is allowed to run on the hardware they own.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by Caligatio on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:05AM (#26314407)
You should read your own bug report for the way to disable auto-updates: either use the portable version or set the ELECTRON_NO_UPDATER=1 environment variable.
Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by sneak on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:12AM (#26314457)
It's easier to just chown the app to a user different than the one running it (so it can't self-modify) than it is to set env vars for GUI apps in macOS.

I run a fork of the client now anyway, and bitwarden_rs on the server. I didn't want to deal with it but the dev responses to security reports are terrible.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by Caligatio on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:43AM (#26314691)
There was a single dev response to your bug and it was the above solution.

Your phrasing and tone are quite harsh as others in that bug commented and seemingly agreed by the community judging by the fact you got more thumbs down reactions than thumbs up. Combined with the fact you're not even a paying customer, you really need to evaluate whether your approach was appropriate.

Re:LastPass Android app has got 7 trackers in it by sneak on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:53AM (#26315304)
Truth isn't a popularity contest, unfortunately.