News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by iso1210 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:16AM (#26293549)
Does that make the information actionable? Does being an INTJ allow a prediction on anything else other than being an INTJ?

What is the point in clustering them? If your team is 75% ravenclaw, 20% Hufflepuff and 5% other, how does that help? Are you going to go out and try to recruit a Slytherin?

What if your team is 45% Rachel, 15% Chandler, 20% Joey?

What benefit do you get from clustering people in this way?

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by RogerL on Monday March 01, 2021 @01:24AM (#26300207)
You are spot on. I would suspect that everyone that I work with falling this cluster. You could sum us up as a bunch of nerdy engineers, and I don't think anyone would really take exception with that.

But it captures almost nothing except a very small range of behavior. We are very different people. 'Sally' lights up whenever she talks of her children, but mostly pines to be a librarian one day. we have cluster b people, we have Jokers and humorous people, perhaps a bit of Asperger's, adventurers and the meek, storytellers, partiers, tea totalers. One seems to live for firing people, another I'm pretty sure I cannot model another human mind. some of us paint, play music, others disdain that stuff. Jocks and couch potatoes.

Those that say they use the mtbi for self-understanding puzzle me, because it tells you nothing of any of these very human traits. knowing somebody has one of the cluster b traits for example tells you a lot about how you might need to modify your behavior to interact with them successfully in a work environment, and MB days nothing. I could go on and on on what it is not measuring.

Yeah we're engineers. I knew that. I didn't need the test.