News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by vbezhenar on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:25AM (#26292577)
This is a good approach. Country must be able to control content served to their citizens. And that ruling should not be extended to other countries. Citizens can either elect different president or use VPN.
Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by postingawayonhn on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:37AM (#26292638)
Freedom of speech/expression is a right of every individual on this planet. Any regime that does not support that should face pushback from its citizens, businesses, and other countries.
Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by imgabe on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:42AM (#26292989)
I agree, but in practice what would happen is Turkey would just block Facebook if they refused to comply. Facebook can't grant freedom of speech to people. They have to take control of their government and demand it for themselves if they want it.

Facebook has made it clear they don't care about free speech anyway, as they'll happily ban anyone who jeopardizes their ad revenue.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by cblconfederate on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:15AM (#26293543)
The moral thing to do is let the government ban them. The problem lies in the fact that totalitarian governments use social media to manipulate their own citizens and often run campaigns against them. By siding with the government in serious issues they make it even more difficult for citizens to "demand their freedoms", siding with the devil
Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by sdeframond on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:04AM (#26293137)
Respectful nitpick: maybe you mean "Freedom of speech/expression should be a right of every individual on this planet"

Also, one thing is to wish for universal freedom of speech, another one is for a given community, or country, to impose its views on free speech (and limitations thereof) to another community.

Edit: typo

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by boomboomsubban on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:24AM (#26293254)
>should be

No, "is" is correct. Everybody has the same intrinsic right to free speech at birth. You think that given communities should choose for themselves whether that right can be infringed.

This is basically the US' answer to the "divine right of monarchy." If you say that speech "should be" the right l of every individual, you are giving the government an automatic place of authority over the citizen,claiming they get to choose what rights people have.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by sdeframond on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:34AM (#26293298)
Yes it is correct, in theory at least ;)
Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by boomboomsubban on Monday March 01, 2021 @05:13AM (#26301273)
There is no "theory," these things aren't based on science.
Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by sdeframond on Monday March 01, 2021 @08:15AM (#26302433)
What I mean is that I don't know any community without practical limitations on free speech.

The way I see it, we decided as a society that every individual was entitled to fundamental human rights. We also decided in practice that it would be good to put limits on some of these rights, especially when one interferes with another (try insulting a cop or denying the Shoah for example, or insulting the King in Thailand, etc etc). Different communities/countries have different views on what limitations to apply, even though they may all agree on these fundamental human rights.

Regarding FB's policy in foreign countries, the case can made that they should respect those countries' choices, even though they are different from USA's choices. Otherwise it can arguably be perceived as US imperialism.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by boomboomsubban on Monday March 01, 2021 @12:08PM (#26305041)
Everything you mention is separate from my point, which has nothing to do with free speech. You're view is that practical limitations on free speech are limits placed on a freedom granted you, while I'd say they are infringements allowed on my inherent right.

Your notion that this is a small nitpick, or a theory that may be disproved is the wrong way of looking at it. It's two separate ways of looking at the same thing, neither more or less true than the other.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by sdeframond on Monday March 01, 2021 @04:51PM (#26308941)
> they are infringements allowed on my inherent right

Are you implying we should be allowed to say anything, without any exception?

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by boomboomsubban on Monday March 01, 2021 @06:52PM (#26310146)
I'm implying that we naturally have that right, but we have decided to place limits on it.
Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by cblconfederate on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:11AM (#26293176)
It is a Human Right according to the UN declaration.

https://www.un.org/en/universal-declaration-human-rights/

both Turkey and facebooks home, the US , have signed it

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by sdeframond on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:24AM (#26293255)
That's correct.

As an anecdote, I was pretty shocked when some foreigner friend told me "universal" human rights can actually be perceived as more of a "western imperialism" thing. While I still think human rights are a thing, I can understand that they have been used hypocritically many times through history.

Regarding TFA, I am unsure whether I'd rather FB to impose US's views on freespeech to Turkey or to respect whatever the local government is telling it to do.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by LegitShady on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:53AM (#26294680)
>Regarding TFA, I am unsure whether I'd rather FB to impose US's views on freespeech to Turkey or to respect whatever the local government is telling it to do.

You have it backwards, facebook et al will slowly kill free speech in the US while claiming to be pro free speech.

We have before us the greatest setup for fascism in history, and these tech companies should allow themselves to be banned from countries before cooperating with governments to silence speech.

Instead expect them to help authoritarians silence dissent.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by sdeframond on Sunday February 28, 2021 @01:02PM (#26295388)
I am very wary of FB. In fact I deleted my account about 10 years ago (God knows I had to jump through hoops for this). Still using Whatsapp but mainly Signal.

Truth is one does not need Facebook at all. Don't rely on it for getting news, don't rely on it for giving news.

> these tech companies should allow themselves to be banned

So you expect Big Corp to have a conscience? How cute :P

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by jankassens on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:10AM (#26293508)
Even with free speech as a right, there’s still the conflict with other rights.

E.g in the USA, slander or sexual content is limiting what you can express.

In Germany, Holocaust denial and nazi symbols are illegal.

The vast majority of people in these countries seem to agree with these limitations. (I don’t know about the Turkish situation)

The ranking of rights when they’re in conflict with each other is fascinating to me as it can be pretty different by country.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by KDJohnBrown on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:18AM (#26294373)
Who exactly bestows these rights upon people?

Governments? Türkiye outlaws free speech through arbitary terror laws (see: HDP politicians imprisoned, members of Grupo Yorum who died of hunger protests for not being allowed to sing). Turkiye also has libel laws which basically outlaw free speech. tayipp has successfully sued many thousands of people for speaking afainst him.

Religion? Turks are mostly muslim. Blasphemy, apostacy, mocking the prophet or drawing pictures or him are all punishable by death in Islam.

The concept of universal or inalienable rights is noble and righteous in theory, but imaginary in practice.

Turks have allowed Tayipp to stomp all over the constitution (illegally acting as prime minister when he was president, rewriting the constitution under a state of emergency, violating libel laws by regularly insulting kurds, chp, hdp, christians, jews and zoroastrians, violating the secularity laws and arresting hundreds of thousands of people under allged ties to fetö), and Turks keep allowing it.

Even Atatürk banned turbanli women from working in government.

Turks have willingly rejected western-style free speech for a relatively improved economy and a sense of national pride.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by vbezhenar on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:47AM (#26292689)
> Freedom of speech/expression is a right of every individual on this planet

I'm not aware of any country with unlimited speech. Definitely not US or EU countries. I'm not observing huge pushback from US citizens, business and other countries when Facebook and Twitter tried to silence Trump and some other conservative leaders. There are topics that are forbidden by law to discuss in EU, for example to deny Holocaust. Those are examples of lack of freedom in so-called "free" countries. So obviously freedom of speech is not universal approach and some limitation of that freedom is an accepted norm.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by kristianc on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:18AM (#26292861)
This is simply tu quoque - clearly there are limits to free speech in every country but where possible the right to free expression should outweigh the the state’s desire to silence political opposition.

Twitter was a pretty good example of this actually - protecting people’s right to hear from the President (despite him saying and doing many things that would have got regular users banned) right up until the point where he led an insurrection on the Capitol. I don’t think you can argue anything other than Twitter taking their responsibility to free speech incredibly seriously - to the point where they were often accused of being complicit to juice user metrics. And perhaps do some research into Joel Kaplan before you claim the same of Facebook.

Clearly this is not in the same realm as Holocaust denial (which is incidentally also legal in roughly half of the EU countries).

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by wyattpeak on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:07AM (#26293155)
> This is simply tu quoque

Not the original poster, but I don't think it is.

The problem is that, since all countries acknowledge that there should be limits on speech, it's inappropriate for one country (or company, for that matter) to decide what should be the limit in another country.

If it were black and white, there'd be a much stronger case. But this is a company saying "our shade of grey is preferable to yours".

I obviously don't agree with what the Turkish government demanded, but I'm unconvinced that this in particular is a strong argument for a foreign company to decide to overrule local law. And I really think that should be a very high bar.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by kristianc on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:47AM (#26293376)
The issue is that once you go down that road, you preclude discussion of any issues by one country / company if that country also imposes limitations.

You need to pick a principle somewhere - and I’m not sure ‘we’ll simply block access to any material the host government finds objectionable’ is going to be one that’s going to lead us toward a better world.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by marshmallow_12 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:36AM (#26292955)
> Freedom of speech/expression is a right of every individual on this planet

I do think that it's slightly more nuanced. On certain issues there is no freedom of speech. This is when it is determined that the opinions expressed are detrimental to the human race and largely false. Nazi beliefs are in this category. They are so harmful to the public that individual freedom is quashed. incitement to murder is another. You certainly don't have freedom to say everything you like. That would lead to anarchy.

Edit: the only true freedom is freedom of belief. You are free to believe anything you like. However you may not always be allowed to pass on those beliefs. The press are given gag orders all the time, it's not the most fundemental human right.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by LegitShady on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:56AM (#26294702)
>This is when it is determined that the opinions expressed are detrimental to the human race and largely false.

Then any speech that threatens power structures will be determined to be detrimental, and banned.

The only way to protect speech is to protect speech, even if you dislike it. That's why the ACLU, before they were coopted as they are today, defended nazis in illinois.

Don't be short sighted, be long sighted. Today its nazis, 60 years ago its was activists. Same rules.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by marshmallow_12 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:51PM (#26295252)
I'm not saying that it's a clear cut issue. I think there are definite cases when freedom of speech causes more harm then good. If someone will preach that we must kill every single person with 8 fingers, for example, we will curtail his freedom with very little consideration.
Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by statstutor on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:47AM (#26292690)
I don't agree with Turkey's law in this case, but you're saying that we should impose our laws and values on all other countries, and also that online services should not have to abide by any laws, with the internet as essentially a lawless state.

I view those both as bigger problems.

Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by anovikov on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:40AM (#26292657)
Why? If we are certain that values of free speech are important for national success, then if others suppress them, fine! It only provides us competitive advantage, let them suffer from their mistakes.
[dead]
Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by anovikov on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:39AM (#26293676)
I'd say, only option for caring about that is if we actually suspect that values of free speech and personal freedoms in general are NOT important for development: rather, those are the luxuries which we simply can afford because we're rich. And it's wise to press values onto poor countries to prevent them from becoming richer and thus a threat to us. The experiment of helping countries to become rich so they become friendly, failed on China and Russia examples: becoming rich they got only more hostile just because they could, so assumption that it's good to separate countries into friendly or hostile regardless of how is their economy going, and simply suppress growth of the latter, seems a wise one.
Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by sneak on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:46AM (#26292685)
Why should any person, elected or otherwise, be permitted to decide what another adult human being is allowed to read?
Re:Facebook blocked posts by a militia group opposed to the ... by amanaplanacanal on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:55AM (#26293782)
Because “rights” aren’t real, but power is. Rights are whatever you can take by force or negotiation from the strongmen who want to run your life.