Nah. It was pointed out already that this is the same idea that Gerber tried with its "real people" foods a while ago. It's a clever idea, but it doesn't spread enough via word-of-mouth to actually negate negative feelings.
Re:Vista Blind Taste Test
by mattmaroon on Thursday July 31, 2008 @04:12AM
(#262802)
I'm guessing MS is planning on spreading this by a lot more than word of mouth. They're launching a humongous national campaign in all forms of media, on which they'll probably spend more than the entire worth of Gerber.
I can't even find any info on this Gerber Real People (though I only tried searching for that) but my guess is they have little or no similarity. And there are plenty of viral ads that actually did work, including one by Microsoft promoting Halo.
But that one worked because people liked the looks of Halo to begin with. You can't get around a common mentality by pointing that mentality out. People don't change that logically.
Why do you consider this ad, that presents itself as a blind test but is clearly not, brilliant?
Re:Vista Blind Taste Test
by mattmaroon on Thursday July 31, 2008 @04:10AM
(#262801)
Because the <1% of the population that would realize it's not valid science is entirely outside of their target demographic. The point of the ad is to make people think "maybe I've been wrong in believing the bad stuff I read about Vista" and this will accomplish that with almost all of the people who see it.
I just think word of mouth is usually stronger than any marketing campaign, so if people are telling their friends that they hate something, trying to convince them otherwise throught advertising looks to me like a waste of money and time.
Anyway, most people who buy a computer and don´t buy a mac can´t escape from vista, linux is not mom ready yet, so why waste time convincing people to choose vista rather than telling them they may need a new computer?
Re:Vista Blind Taste Test
by mattmaroon on Friday August 01, 2008 @07:24PM
(#264613)
Because people have a choice between Windows and a Mac. MS, for the first time in as long as anyone my age can remember, has a viable competitor.
Could this be the start of Microsoft finally not sucking at advertising?