News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by prox on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @01:05PM (#26253287)
As an neophyte in QM, my mind boggles of the extraordinary energetic nature of these particles, and that this happens on a universe scale level, with laws of nature governing the same response everywhere.

Also how many different levels of scale there are, from giant structures in space, to our solar system, to our human experience, to cells, atoms, quarks and I wonder if there are more such levels down to the planck scale.

Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by officialjunk on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @01:15PM (#26253435)
i would bet there are more levels we are not currently aware of. could also be a fractal.
Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by whatshisface on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @08:40PM (#26258722)
Thermodynamics dictates that energy will spread out into all available degrees of freedom equally. If there were extra DOFs, they would either have to be frozen out at human-reachable temperatures, or inaccessible due to not interacting with anything, or else they would appear to us in the form of mysteriously disappearing heat.

Unfreezing new DOFs at high energy densities is the modus operandi of accelerators like the LHC. Everything that happens there can be seen as doing that for different purposes.

Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by Strilanc on Thursday February 25, 2021 @01:30AM (#26260300)
Quantum mechanics puts even more constraints on unknown degrees of freedom, because information leakage into ancillary systems has observable effects on interference patterns.
Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by centimeter on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @01:50PM (#26253941)
Action quantization (colloquially "planck scale") suggests limits on how small these things can get (very small size = very high momentum, which is not observed).
Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by gizmo686 on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @03:37PM (#26255479)
Assuming are understanding of physics is correct at the plank scale. We already have 2 different theories of physics that are not completely consistent with each other, and we have no empirical evidence of anything near the planck scale.
Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by brianberns on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @02:39PM (#26254580)
But electrons are considered to be point particles, so they would have infinite momentum in this case?
Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by fungiblecog on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @03:36PM (#26255465)
No. They are vibrations of the electron field. There are no point particles in the standard model.
Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by ben_w on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @03:20PM (#26255235)
σ_x * σ_p ⩾ ħ/2

The product of the uncertainty in each is always at least some constant. They can still be point-like without you knowing where they are; and also knowing exactly where they are regardless of if they are point-like or extended means there is no defined momentum rather than it is defined as infinite.

That said: (a) you can’t pick a number from the set of Reals with a continuous uniform distribution, so I guess you can’t ever have perfect knowledge of the location ever even in principle, and (b) I’m self taught so likely only have a half-understanding.

Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by centimeter on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @08:35PM (#26258681)
“Point particle” is an approximation that doesn’t accurately predict reality. It only works at large actions.

Classical is R^3, quantum is R^3 -> C. (Sort of; this glosses over a lot.) Objects don’t really have a concrete location; they have complex-valued distributions.

Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by 6nf on Thursday February 25, 2021 @03:55AM (#26261014)
I'm pretty sure electrons are not considered point particles?
Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by qubex on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:50PM (#26267358)
Pretty sure they are. They’re leptons, and elemental (within the confines of the Standard Model, at least).
Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by centimeter on Thursday February 25, 2021 @06:47PM (#26269863)
Something being a lepton has nothing to do with whether it's a point particle.

Pontryagin duality of position/momentum (which comes from both QM and Relativity, depending on your perspective) rules out the physical existence of point particles. It would require infinite momentum to have zero extent.

Re:Decades-Long Quest Reveals Details of the Proton’s Inner ... by idclip on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @01:39PM (#26253771)
The truth of all meditations .. there is only up, and down, The rising and falling of transient phenomena ... it seems to be sentient, too! To think, thought is so deeply rooted; matter giving form to matter ... sweat, tears, sadness and joy ... so interlinked with the lowest forms of the blocks that make us all up!

Truly awe inspiring on a grand scale. Its no wonder the ancient greeks attributed gravity to Aphrodite‘s magic .. i honestly find it so fitting; its love all the way down!