Re:MI6 defaces Al Qaeda website with Cupcake-making recipes
by paganel on Monday June 06, 2011 @05:06AM
(#2624144)
Remember kids, when the civilians hack other people's webservers it's "cyber-terrorism", when is the Government the one that does it, it's "cyber-warfare".
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:MI6 defaces Al Qaeda website with Cupcake-making recipes
by redthrowaway on Monday June 06, 2011 @07:14AM
(#2624314)
Until we start seeing hackers actually blow up computers or shut down major sectors of the economy, while issuing political demands, I refuse to call them "cyber-terrorists". It's such a stupid, meaningless, USA PATRIOT Act-esque piece of fluffy propaganda. Not every criminal is a terrorist. Nor every airline passenger, but I won't even get into that.
Now, that's not to say that some of these groups wouldn't do those things if they could. I can see a significant proportion of Anonymous deciding to take out the NYSE in retaliation for some bill or other, if they had the capability. Still, that's not terrorism, just crime.
Re:MI6 defaces Al Qaeda website with Cupcake-making recipes
by ender7 on Monday June 06, 2011 @05:44AM
(#2624193)
Similarly, when I kill my neighbor I'm a "murderer", but when I kill my country's neighbors I'm a "soldier". Such distinctions are important.
I would be careful trying to equate hacking into Sony with hacking into Al-Qaeda.
Re:MI6 defaces Al Qaeda website with Cupcake-making recipes
by furyg3 on Monday June 06, 2011 @06:56AM
(#2624292)
If you or your country did not follow established protocol and international law for killing your country's neighbors, you are both a "soldier" and a "murderer".
Likewise, if MI6 defaces an online magazine without following established protocol as well as international law, they are engaging in "cyber-terrorism" in addition to "cyber-warfare".
Such distinctions are important. :)
Re:MI6 defaces Al Qaeda website with Cupcake-making recipes
by Apocryphon on Monday June 06, 2011 @01:14PM
(#2625471)
Perhaps there will be a Geneva Convention for cyberwarfare in the future. Though perhaps a different city for the international protocols to be signed in is in order.