News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by cool_dude85 on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @01:40PM (#26241019)
Hard disagree. We can censor, for example, child pornography, bomb-building tutorials, and revenge porn. I'm not going to fight against censoring them on the grounds that allowing them to be censored will allow anything else to be censored too.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by LanceH on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:35PM (#26241796)
For all of those, they passed a law which has to stand up to judicial scrutiny.

Leaning on a company to eliminate speech is censorship without review.

edit: removed extra word

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by amadeuspagel on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:12PM (#26241505)
> child pornography, bomb-building tutorials, and revenge porn

None of these things are misinformation.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by swirepe on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:39PM (#26241834)
Technically true, but try building a bomb from one of those tutorials
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by dddddhf on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:06PM (#26242208)
I have as a teenager made acetone peroxide and ammonium nitrate pipe bombs from instructions printed at the library. They worked ;)
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by mjevans on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @01:58PM (#26241293)
Incorrect. We can __prosecute__ against those who break the law. We __must not__ censor, because that is the slippery slope; all the more so when it is done without judicial oversight in an adversarial review system.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by leesalminen on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:17PM (#26241559)
Agreed. If something is explicitly illegal, then that’s grounds for censorship. If something isn’t explicitly illegal, then it shouldn’t be censored. The First Amendment in the US provides for nearly limitless free speech, with very few exceptions. That’s how we should police speech online.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by betterunix2 on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:02PM (#26241366)
That is a distinction without a difference. You are talking about the mechanics of censorship.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:28PM (#26241688)
It isn't. There are two differences.

The first is that prosecutions are retrospective. If something is true and you can't stop anyone from saying it, only punish them after, then people who are willing to sacrifice their freedom for the truth can't be silenced. There is also less incentive to punish them because the cat is already out of the bag, and people are more willing to push back against a prosecution for speaking a truth that they've seen survive an adversarial public debate.

The second is that prosecutions happen in courts bound (in the US) by the First Amendment, and the prosecution fails if the defendant was engaged in protected speech. Facebook or Comcast/MSNBC (note: the same company) deciding what constitutes "misinformation" with no accountability for over-censoring is not that.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by jefft255 on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:06PM (#26241438)
If I understand correctly, you're claiming that we __must not__ censor child pornography? Isn't prosecution a form of censorship anyways? I think what you're saying is a textbook example of a slippery slope fallacy.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by leesalminen on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:18PM (#26241579)
Following the law is a slippery slope? I’m pretty sure the parent is saying that because child pornography is explicitly illegal, it can (and should) be censored.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by jjeaff on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @05:44PM (#26244001)
I believe this is the same logic being used to sensor covid deniers, false cures, and fraudulent election crackpots like our last president.

The latter type of lie incites people to insurrection and riles up violence, the other two cause people to do things that may kill themselves or others.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by leesalminen on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @06:00PM (#26244175)
Last time I checked no court of law had convicted the former President of any criminal offense. So, no, I don’t see how that logic was used to censor him.

Same for false cures to diseases, nobody imprisons pseudoscience witch doctors for recommending vitamins to cure cancer. (Maybe if they claimed to be a medical doctor?) If that were so, I know of a half dozen people in Boulder that would’ve been in jail by now. Certainly no court had convicted any of these people of a crime prior to censorship.

So, as far as I can tell, these people had been censored without having committed (or at least convicted of) a crime.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by jjeaff on Friday February 26, 2021 @05:21PM (#26280555)
He got off on a technicality. Even many of those that voted not to convict said that they thought he was guilty. They just didn't think they could convict a non-sitting president.

False cures for diseases, yes, people absolutely go to jail or receive massive fines. Sometimes on charges of fraud, sometimes on charges of endangerment. If your fake cure doesn't actually do harm (and is just useless) then you can usually get away with it. A quick google search will show you multiple stories about criminal charges for fake covid cures.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by Vaslo on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:26PM (#26243085)
Except the items you cite are done on a fringe. Almost half of America is conservative, hardly some fringe.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by sneak on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:27PM (#26241665)
See, even these descriptions which you presumably think are clear distinctions are not objective categories of information.

Do drawings count? How about deepfakes? Pyrotechnic display textbooks?

You're going to need a judge, and that judge is going to wield power.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by goatcode on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @01:54PM (#26241235)
>Judging what is and is not misinformation must always be in the hands of the people

You disagree with letting censorship be decided on democratically?

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by vkou on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:00PM (#26241333)
The thing about democracy is that there are so many levels of government - and quite literally any decision made by a democratically elected government can be condemned as undemocratic (Because some other layer of government - or better yet, a Joe on the street - does not agree with it.)

This is how you get people shouting about how a democratically elected president, who was given, by a democratically elected congress, powers to operate a regulatory department, is acting undemocratic-ally [1], when he appoints someone those people don't like to head that department.

What those people forget is that in a democracy, you can't in good faith cherrypick outcomes as 'undemocratic'. You can only ensure that the process for making changes is democratic. If the people you elect decided to turn your country into a police state, well, that sucks, but that's a democratic decision that they've made - and as long as you can vote them out, it can be democratically reversed. Prohibition was reversed, after all, communist witch hunts eventually ended, it's no longer illegal to ride in a train car while black, people in the US are no longer jailed for writing pro-German newspaper articles, and we no longer round up entire ethnic groups, and concentrate them in a camp (Which are all hallmarks of a police state. They are no longer present in our society, thanks in part to a democratic process. Other hallmarks still are, but if enough people care, we'll eventually get around to them.)

[1] Despite neither the constitution, the law that brought that department into existence, the judiciary, nor years of precedent requiring that the department must be ran by an elected official, or that the department's every decision [2] must be voted on by Congress.

[2] As it turns out, it's quite democratic for an elected official to defer decision-making to an un-elected underling. That's fine. What makes this democratic, is that you can punish the elected official, if the underling behaves poorly, by voting them out. As long as all power flows from an elected office, this thing works. What is not fine is if the un-elected underling is not appointed, or fire-able by an elected office, or by an agent of an elected office. That's where the difference between democratic, and undemocratic lies.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by goatcode on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:22PM (#26242399)
> democracy

> democratically elected president

That's not really what I was talking about.