News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sony DD-1EX Electronic Book Player by qbasic_forever on Monday February 22, 2021 @04:58PM (#26231223)
Early minidisc players/recorders will forever be a unique and coveted item for some folks. Sony made a curious 'mistake' in those early units where they added recording functionality AND a fully digital S/PDIF input with zero copy protection or restrictions. You could plug an early portable minidisc recorder straight into a digital audio output from a high end (at the time) CD player to make digitally bit-perfect rips of CDs, or plug it into the digital output of a mixer board to make great live music recordings. You could even get a minidisc drive for computers and copy off your bit-perfect music rips to upload and share on the internet. Very, very quickly Sony realized their mistake and later minidisc players removed S/PDIF inputs (but left the outputs). Nowadays HDMI, etc. have all baked in copy protection to the wire protocols. So for a very short period of time minidisc was this odd little thing that was an enormous threat to the future of the music industry.
Re:Sony DD-1EX Electronic Book Player by turtlebits on Monday February 22, 2021 @06:21PM (#26232011)
Minidisc compression wasn't lossless. I'm pretty sure CD rips on computers existed before then.
Re:Sony DD-1EX Electronic Book Player by Klwohu on Monday February 22, 2021 @07:45PM (#26232580)
Objectively, ATRAC was worse than CD as a compressed format. But it was actually very cleverly done, and it sounded better than MPEG audio at the same bit rate.

What killed the format was Sony's aggressive policy of forcing you to use their software.