News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whimsicalism on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:58AM (#26214387)
> I do not understand this argument. The fact that bitcoin mining is profitable inherently means that society has already deemed it useful, no? Users would not pay for it if it were not useful.

Just because there is a market for something doesn't mean that "society" as a whole has decided that it is useful. There's an underground market on taking out hits on someone else, that doesn't mean that "society" has decided that murder is good.

> Who should do this evaluation? If not users freely allocating their own resources on the free market, then who?

A public body that is democratically constrained.

> Please define useful.

Welfare enhancing for humanity. Sometimes, a welfare enhancing step will involve losers and winners, you're right. For instance, if one person held $200 billion and the rest of humanity held $1, redistributing that money would almost certainly be a welfare enhancing step given diminishing marginal utility of the $.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by generalizations on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:17AM (#26214567)
We put far too much faith in centralized authorities to arbitrate standards of morality. How sure are you that such an authority will actually reflect the best interest of the people, and not itself?

> There's an underground market on taking out hits on someone else, that doesn't mean that "society" has decided that murder is good.

That's a great cherry-picked example, but there are far more examples of people freely purchasing what they deem to be useful, and even more examples of useless things disappearing because no one wanted them. Most failed startups we cover here are probably an example of the latter, and there's plenty of discussions of how to achieve the former on hn, too.

> Welfare enhancing for humanity.

Who gets to determine this, except the members of humanity themselves? Does some 'public body that is democratically constrained' know what's best for each individual person it's responsible for? Does it adhere to some ideology that dictates the universal moral good, whether everyone else likes it or not? How does a group of politicians living in their own little bubble know what's best for Joe Plumber in e.g. North Dakota?

What moral framework do you suggest that we inflict upon all of humanity?

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whimsicalism on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:28AM (#26214698)
> That's a great cherry-picked example

I consider it reasoning from the limit case - obviously the existence of a market is not sufficient to prove that society has decided it is good, as the counter-example of the market in murder shows. Nothing more behind that statement and I think that markets are often a powerful tool.

> What moral framework do you suggest that we inflict upon all of humanity?

You can't escape "inflicting" a moral stance on the world. In the hypothetical world where the one has $200 billion and the remainder have $1, perhaps the government is not "arbitrating standards of morality", but if they make it illegal for the 7 billion to steal from the one person who has $200 billion, they are taking an ethical stance and "inflicting" it on the rest of the world.

We're a socially cooperative species - obviously we need a way to govern the form of those interactions, even in order to have a functioning market in things.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by generalizations on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:38AM (#26214812)
> You can't escape "inflicting" a moral stance on the world.

Only if you start from the assumption that such things as bitcoin mining ought to be regulated in the first place. You're right - we are a 'socially cooperative species', and we're good at it. Leave us alone to cooperate and don't invoke some government authority.

I'm arguing that involving a governmental authority to arbitrate morality is a can of worms that really doesn't need to be opened here.

> Nothing more behind that statement

Fair enough, I thought you meant to take that statement farther than you did.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whimsicalism on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:53AM (#26214954)
> You're right - we are a 'socially cooperative species', and we're good at it. Leave us alone to cooperate and don't invoke some government authority.

So it's cool if I go to someone and take their bitcoins from them at gunpoint? Or start Mafia 2.0 and create my own protection racket here in SF?

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by jcpham2 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:52PM (#26216019)
Your crime, your time.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by ub99 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:50PM (#26216006)
I don’t understand - it’s like we have to repeat the same mistake over and over again. What industries have historically successfully self-regulated for the benefit of the society at large? Regulations and government involvement is why we don’t live in a slave society with a handful of militaristic barons.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by jfk13 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:39PM (#26215897)
> You're right - we are a 'socially cooperative species', and we're good at it. Leave us alone to cooperate and don't invoke some government authority.

Isn't "some government authority" exactly how we as a species go about "socially cooperating" on a larger scale?

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by collinexander on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:14AM (#26214531)
Thanks for the reply, it helped me understand where you are coming from.

For purposes of discussing bitcoin, it is a global good, and environmental concerns are a global concern. If there is a global market for bitcoin, then taxing bitcoin mining (or other such measures) in one country would just incentivize miners to move to another country. So any such action as you describe would need to be coordinated on a global level among several or all nations.

> There's an underground market on taking out hits on someone else, that doesn't mean that "society" has decided that murder is good.

Not sure if it is fair to compare bitcoin production to murder. I agree that we need some sort of action for climate change, but I am not sure regulating bitcoin is the answer. We'd have to apply the same subject "utility" measuring stick to _any_ activity that consumes electricity and regulate that. Like others have suggested, maybe taxing certain types of energy usage directly according to their climate change impact would be more effective and would apply evenly to all goods / services without deciding on behalf of individuals what is useful and what is not.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whimsicalism on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:22AM (#26214622)
> So any such action as you describe would need to be coordinated on a global level among several or all nations.

I was not the original person you were discussing with, so I don't think a tax specifically on bitcoin mining would be the best idea, but yes global problems require global scale coordination often.

> Not sure if it is fair to compare bitcoin production to murder.

My point is merely that the fact that a market exists for something is not sufficient to show that "society" has decided it is useful IMO.

> Like others have suggested, maybe taxing certain types of energy usage directly according to their climate change impact

Yeah, I was the one who commented that, so I definitely agree