We probably can’t destroy all life on earth either, because of the adaptations of microbes to the most inhospitable conditions. You’d have to remove the atmosphere and the oceans probably, or turn the earth into Venus.
Likewise when people remark on the fragility of earth when looking at a whole earth image - no, it is we who are fragile, particularly when, as tiny as we are, we could make the earth inhospitable to us.
Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006)
by bootlooped on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:40PM
(#26206073)
If somebody says they destroyed their car in an accident do you also point out that the car is fine and mostly in one piece, it's just totally unusable for human transportation?
Everybody knows what is meant when people say this.
The car crash disfigured the car into something people wouldn't really call it a car anymore. However, even if earth stops supporting human life (or, more likely, greatly reduce the number of places on earth that humans can live on), no one would argue it is still a planet.
Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006)
by bootlooped on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:16PM
(#26206397)
I think that assertion is disproven by thinking about what junkyards are full of: cars. It doesn't matter that they can't drive anymore, or even that they may be totally missing significant parts. People still generally think of them as cars.
Carlin had something to say about that.
Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006)
by paulryanrogers on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:05PM
(#26205727)
What do you hope to accomplish responding to a life-on-earth concern with an article exploring how to destroy the celestial body?
That people say "life on earth", and not "earth".
I'm a bit autistic when it comes to language.
I think the term is pedantic.
Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006)
by HelloMcFly on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:39PM
(#26206598)
This only thing this accomplishes is making you look like a jerk, with maybe a 10% chance of getting a chuckle out of the right person.
With the extreme environments that some animal species live in, I'm not even considered about destroying the life on Earth. It doesn't seem like an easy thing to pull off.
Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006)
by dennis_moore on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:39PM
(#26206066)
I'm not saying it isn't, but these organisms evolved over millions of years to adapt to these environments, whereas the extreme conditions caused by human activity are happening on a much shorter time scale, probably too short for organisms to be able to adapt.
It is pretty hard to imagine any particular set of conditions short of total planetary surface destruction that would make all extremophiles go extinct - and as long there is enough of them, they will start spreading again.
Any particular species, including humans that lives on Earth is unlikely to survive catastrophic changes - but life will come back and spread into the newly freed and opened niches, just as it did before multiple times.
Why did nobody tell the dinosaurs about the Lindy effect?
Maybe someone did, who's to say...
More specifically they mean human life. Almost nobody cares about an Earth incapable of supporting human life.
Are they? Some people I saw seem to be more considered about animals than humans.
Earth is 4.5B years old, and will likely continue to exist for quite some time. That's called the "Lindy effect" (old things will likely continue to exist).