A more realistic attack angle would be a large mining corporation recognizing a financial opportunity to undermine Bitcoin. If some organization could position themselves as a superior alternative to Bitcoin, crashing the Bitcoin network with periodic mining attacks could be worth the cost. Alternatively, if an entity could amass a large enough short position on Bitcoin, attacking the network to drive down the price might be attractive. We’d have to run the math on the scenarios, which is the point of projects like this.
> Even if they did currently, the endgame for Bitcoin as envisioned by Satoshi Nakamoto was for everyone on the planet to be mining Bitcoin at the same time.
The amount of wasted energy would be insane if everyone on the planet was mining Bitcoin.
Currently, it looks like we’re on a trajectory where large mining operations will centralize a lot of the eventually custom mining hardware. Individuals will have less and less incentive to mine Bitcoin as the reward decreases.
Governments can purchase large runs of ASICs while other mining will revert to GPU. Controlling 51% of the hash rate in this manner isn't as outlandish.
Further, you're not limited to double spend attacks. If you're the government with a decent advantage, you just treat your own chain as true and never accept blocks from other miners. The reward for mining will collapse, since even if you produce a valid block it'll not be on the longest chain once government miners catch up.
And once the reward for mining collapses you can probably even power down some of the ASICs.
There are counter measures, but combined with attacking the financial onramps and making possession criminal, it's hard for me to believe that BTC would survive an attack like this.
But of course, it's predicated on large governments agreeing it's worth seriously attacking. I don't know how likely that is.
They don't need the processors - they can simply change the laws.
Looking mostly at the US here. It is highly unlikely the government will sit by and watch trillions of US capital flowing into a Chinese-controlled infrastructure, undermining their reserve currency status.
Also worth mentioning that the US has leverage over the entire world’s banking system, that is how they enforce sanctions. Cutting the link between crypto and major currencies would qualify as an endgame.
It's the equivalent of shooting a bullet through your chest to shoot your enemy in the finger.
51% attacks don't make sense because you're hurting yourself 51% and hurting everyone else 49%.
And for this theoretical attack you'd probably need to sustain 90%+ hash power for a long time.
Your first hurdle will be producing enough ASICs to surpass current hashrate by nearly 10x. Solve that problem and you'll need a massive amount of energy and you'll have to set up huge mining facilities in various locations to prevent crippling local power grids.
This would take years to plan & execute. A lot of people would have to be involved. Good luck keeping it a secret. Network hash rate will continue to increase while you're building this infrastructure.
If by some miracle you've pulled this off, Bitcoin users will switch to a fork of Bitcoin that uses a different mining algorithm and your entire investment is now completely worthless.
If the attacker attempts to keep up the game of cat-and-mouse long enough they will eventually go bankrupt and will no longer be able to participate.
And this theoretical discussion completely dismisses the fact that it's nearly impossible to execute an attack like this at this stage in the game anyway.
The entire Bitcoin miner reward model is the defense for this attack.
Nation states have powerful computers... but nowhere near as powerful as the decentralized Bitcoin mining network combined.
Even if they did currently, the endgame for Bitcoin as envisioned by Satoshi Nakamoto was for everyone on the planet to be mining Bitcoin at the same time.
If a Nation State could ever become more powerful than every single private processor on the planet combined... I think it would be game over for a lot more than just Bitcoin.