Re:Umberto Eco: Ur-Fascism (1995) [pdf]
by jancsika on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @07:27PM
(#26160932)
> at least not in myself
I'm not worried about HN users' ability to assess their own internal beliefs.
I am worried about HN users beginning and ending their self-reflection at a mere assessment of whether they think their intentions are good/benign/etc.
To go old school with your broken clock example-- if everyone's unset VCR eternally reads "12:00", you probably want to know whether the current time is exactly 12:00 when you try to convince a neighbor you programmed yours. (Well, theirs would blink, but you get the idea.)
It's a bigger deal when a benign belief intersects with the beliefs of neo-fascists or other asshole ideologies.
That may or may not require one to do anything in particular in response, depending on the context. But to not realize the intersections with asshole ideologies, or-- worse-- to actively resist caring (not saying you are, but that seems a growing pattern on social media)-- seems at best like electing to be a willing troglodyte in a complex world.
I'm not worried about HN users' ability to assess their own internal beliefs.
I am worried about HN users beginning and ending their self-reflection at a mere assessment of whether they think their intentions are good/benign/etc.
To go old school with your broken clock example-- if everyone's unset VCR eternally reads "12:00", you probably want to know whether the current time is exactly 12:00 when you try to convince a neighbor you programmed yours. (Well, theirs would blink, but you get the idea.)
It's a bigger deal when a benign belief intersects with the beliefs of neo-fascists or other asshole ideologies.
That may or may not require one to do anything in particular in response, depending on the context. But to not realize the intersections with asshole ideologies, or-- worse-- to actively resist caring (not saying you are, but that seems a growing pattern on social media)-- seems at best like electing to be a willing troglodyte in a complex world.
Edit: clarification