News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Autopilot on Cars for $999 by tjoff on Monday February 15, 2021 @05:24PM (#26148344)
> "with you also paying attention."

So no guarantees whatsoever then. Because you are always responsible and are always expected to recover from anything the autopilot might ever come up with.

Teslas do fail in deadly ways. Everyone that cares to look knows this. Yet Tesla is fine with it, even while knowing that humans can't reason about safety when the car drives perfectly the other 99% of times.

Re:Autopilot on Cars for $999 by jryle70 on Monday February 15, 2021 @05:48PM (#26148635)
> Because you are always responsible and are always expected to recover from anything the autopilot might ever come up with.

That's always been the case for any driving assistance systems that automakers offer, AFAIK. Do you object to the state of driving assistance in general or just how Tesla implements it?

Re:Autopilot on Cars for $999 by tjoff on Monday February 15, 2021 @06:16PM (#26148953)
Well driving assistance are mostly about assistance.

While Tesla allows for and gives the impression of it doing more than that, when it can't. You are expected to react within a split second at any time. Actually just driving the car is a way simpler task than supervising someone else that has unintuitive blind spots.

Something that google discovered early on and anyone that thinks about it realize. A car that mostly drives itself is way more dangerous than a car without any assistance at all.

Ask Uber.

Re:Autopilot on Cars for $999 by luplex on Monday February 15, 2021 @05:40PM (#26148542)
Tesla guarantees that an attentive driver can safely take control.

Comma does not.

Re:Autopilot on Cars for $999 by DesolationJones on Wednesday February 17, 2021 @04:40AM (#26164538)
They do guarantee that.

https://medium.com/@comma_ai/how-to-write-a-car-port-for-ope...

"No ADAS system currently on the market has safety guarantees on perception or planning algorithms.

So, what must be guaranteed is the ability of the driver to easily regain full control of the vehicle at any time. In openpilot, this is done through the satisfaction of the 2 main safety principles that a Level 2 driver assistance system must have:

1. The driver must always be capable to immediately re-take manual control of the vehicle, by stepping on either pedal or by pressing the cancel button;

2.The vehicle must not alter its trajectory too quickly for the driver to safely react. This means that while the system is engaged, the actuators are constrained to operate within reasonable limits."

Re:Autopilot on Cars for $999 by camjohnson26 on Monday February 15, 2021 @06:27PM (#26149052)
They don’t guarantee it they just provide a disclaimer. There’s plenty of driver monitoring solutions they could provide but don’t. Combine that with deeply unethical promises of full self driving coming just around the corner, feature complete by 2020, fully autonomous road trip by 2017, and you’re left with a dangerous product and customers that overestimate its abilities.
Re:Autopilot on Cars for $999 by luplex on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @09:02PM (#26161705)
I'm pretty sure the disclaimer does nothing. If they put out a product they need to expect people will use it, and they need to take actions to keep those people safe.

At least that's how I think it works in Germany.