Both Yelp/Google have an issue with their data freshness on business. I'm constantly updating open/close times, (and even whether a business exists) on Yelp. And business (particular taxicabs) have long ago figured out how to Game Googles Small Business directory to get in fake listings.
It will be interesting to see what they do with their database.
A have a friend who used to verify these listing changes for Yelp -- but it's all been outsourced to Indian now. Who knows if that will effect quality.
1. Many of these businesses are small restaurants, bars, etc. Notorious for going out of business.
2. The ones who don't go out of business can easily switch to other discount coupon providers.
Personally I've somehow ended up with way too many discount coupon providers sending email to my inbox. I suspect I'm not alone. Presumably I'm also not alone in the other behavior I see in myself - of those providers (Groupon, Living Social, Gilt Group, Bloomspot, Yelp deals, ... there might be more... I could care less), I am least likely to open Groupon emails.
However, one also has to look at what kind of business you can compare Groupon with. My guess it is taking over part of coupon and other marketing companies.
What kind of valuations do those kind of "old school" companies have? I take the market is rather segmented. That is what kind of cash flow were they producing, what is their price to sales ratio and EPS?
Off the top of my head, I'd say the top 10-15% of restaurants would have no interest in trying Groupon because it cheapens their brand. Then account for chains who don't really need Groupon's reach to offer such promotions (or rather will find it more cost effective to do something like this themselves).
As for the rest of the restaurants, once the novelty of groupon wears off, how often will they come back to give the general public 50% (actually close to 75% off, because Groupon takes half the cut) off meals ?
The Groupon Now idea is a bit more interesting but I think it's something that's going to be best captured by a less physical method of scaling (i.e. not emplying 4000 sales people)
Disclaimer: I'm currently working for a startup in the restaurant space though it does not have any element(s) of a daily deals/groupon clone.
The type of businesses that do benefit the most are those that will operate anyway but have excess capacity to use (eg. beds and breakfasts).
Dining out simply isn't pleasurable when the waiting staff treat you like a 'coupon customer'.
EDIT: OK, maybe not, only estimate I was able to find: http://en.allexperts.com/q/Running-Restaurant-2285/Ideal-res...
Isn't that in itself a reason to be skeptical about whether they can actually scale? The whole point around most internet businesses is that they can scale for very little cost. For Groupon to scale they need huge capital input (to hire staff) but then importantly that expense needs to be maintained to keep the treadmill going.
I haven't seen any particular mention of amount of businesses retained as repeat customers, either.
Future products? Maybe they'll sell lucky moose.
I have a neighbor who owns a "Moe's" franchise -- many of his customers refuse to do business without a discount.
They could probably expand at a slower rate and keep a profit; or they could spend what would otherwise be a profit to expand at a faster rate. At the moment they seem to be going for option 2 which may be a debatable choice but also very normal for a company in the high-growth phase. Amazon is the classic example for this.
If you're calling bubble and confused about how they're running at a loss don't miss this line:
"Participating Merchants: 56,781 in the first quarter of 2011, up from 212 in the second quarter of 2009"
That database of 56,781 merchants is GOLD.
The way their sale staff works is to create direct relationships, phone contact etc - that is not a cheap proposition.
In terms of growth potential there are 10x as many restaurants in the USA as Groupon's entire universe of merchants today.
If they continue to capture the consumer mind that they're the best in the world to answer those two questions, their valuation and growth potential is insane.
Refs:
http://answers.ask.com/Food_and_Drinks/Restaurants/how_many_...
http://www.geekosystem.com/groupon-im-hungry-im-bored/