News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Banned in Boston by burkaman on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:51PM (#26129512)
Genuine question, not intended as an attack: does anybody find these regional stereotypes to be actually meaningful in real life? In my experience they are sort of like geographically-themed horoscopes, and I didn't think anybody really took them seriously. I've met a lot of different people from a lot of different places, I've lived in a few different regions, and I can't really think of a less useful predictor of personality than where you grew up.
Re:Banned in Boston by YankeeDoodel on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:00PM (#26129546)
This is a throwaway so I don't mind saying...yes.

I've lived in a lot of different areas in the US. People in the NE and PNW are more guarded and reticent. People in the Southwest/Midwest are more friendly and talkative. Wearing a cross or being the right color makes a big difference in some places.

These are not categorical statements about everyone in a region, but my life experience says that some US stereotypes have some basis in reality. Local communities have different behavioral norms, and that's fine. We can pretend that they don't exist, but we can also acknowledge them to try and help bridge cultural gaps.

Personally, I wish that people were more accepting of Northeast personalities. But the world wouldn't work if everyone was the same.

Re:Banned in Boston by colechristensen on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:06PM (#26129578)
There are lots of jokes about norwegian-americans in lutheran churches which are spot on. likewise for passive aggressive minnesotans.

And everyone i’ve ever known from wisconsin would at least be considered a mild alcoholic anywhere else.

Stereotypes are what they are, first order approximations.

Re:Banned in Boston by runeb on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:28PM (#26129686)
As a Norwegian living in America I'd love to hear some of these. Got a link?
Re:Banned in Boston by samstave on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:42PM (#26129747)
As a great grandson of Norwegian immigrants - (They were some of the first Norwegians to Ballard Seattle (where the king and queen of norway still? visit) - My great grandfather owned the first bakery there.

The sense of humor is my cup of tea: puns.

Dead-pan-really-good-puns. My Norwegian and Swedish friends are as punny as me.

Do you like puns?

Give me a topic for a pun-off

(as you can see from my last name "stave" '*staava*' (I don't know how to phonetically spell it - but based on stave churches...)

---

I used to think I was indecisive... but now I'm just not sure.

Re:Banned in Boston by selimthegrim on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:25AM (#26129923)
I believe there was an entire episode of Almost Live! where Bill Nye went around Ballard as a cop arresting people for not conforming to Norwegian stereotypes
Re:Banned in Boston by thehappypm on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:25AM (#26129924)
Slightly meaningful at best.

Most people’s experience of a region are hugely tourist. Like folks who visit NYC and see Times Square, then draw conclusions about your average New Yorker. Likewise folks who visit Hollywood and make a conclusion about California.

Re:Banned in Boston by cgriswald on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:31AM (#26130398)
I don’t agree. Your examples are both extremely touristy and stereotyped heavily in media... largely produced in those locations.

The regional stereotypes I’m familiar with are... stereotypes. They’re true. They just might not be true about any particular individual who lives there. And they’re true because these are largely learned behaviors.

Are they useful? Well, in aggregate they might give you some patience and understanding if you’re going to that region and have to interact with the people. Lots of behaviors you might consider rude might actually be friendly or at least polite there. And while you may not be able to assume an individual from a place matches the stereotype, it’s a pretty safe bet if they match the stereotype they’ve got a connection to the place.

Re:Banned in Boston by aidenn0 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:31PM (#26129700)
When it is polite to say hello to someone (and how one does so), is culturally relative. It's not really personality, it's learned behavior.
Re:Banned in Boston by acomjean on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:02AM (#26129836)
I grew up in the suburbs around Boston. My mom was an immigrant and my dad Irish/Armenian. America is pretty diverse and you find various pockets of friendliness in most cities.

There are some “general regional tendencies” I’ve found but they’re overblown, if a little fun.

In my experience Armenians in the Boston area are very friendly or hostile. But they’re my relatives..and it might just be me. In general Id say people Around Boston are less “outgoing” than the people in NY were I lived for a little while. Though in NY I always felt they were more honest with you. Less friendly than Alabama were one of our offices were. (Bless their hearts). And a co-worker from Minnesota “Minnesota nice” notes that while theyre friendly on the outside not so with personal info. (They’ll give you directions anywhere except to their house ) And in MInnesota when they’re hunting for agates, be afraid.

http://minnesotaconnected.com/events/agate-day-festival-brin...

Re:Banned in Boston by thehappypm on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:25AM (#26129930)
Ancedata
Re:Banned in Boston by stephenhuey on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:15AM (#26129886)
Have you been to Boston? People often told me they knew I wasn’t from around there because I smiled so much.
Re:Banned in Boston by burkaman on Sunday February 14, 2021 @06:27PM (#26137305)
Yes, I live a mile outside of Boston and I grew up here. I don't think I've ever met anyone from here that really fits the stereotype. My local friends don't smile any less than my Californian friends.

> People often told me they knew I wasn’t from around there because I smiled so much.

I've always understood jokes like this to be a sort of ironic "it's funny because that's what people say about us even though it's not really true". I am now realizing I might be alone in this.