News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by smcl on Saturday February 13, 2021 @01:51PM (#26125686)
Another example - Kyle Rittenhouse - is out on bail and he travelled from another state with a gun then killed 2 people in Kenosha. He's not yet been tried (or found guilty, but ... come on) but I think we all know he's not going to serve anything like 68 years in prison.
Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by jeswin on Saturday February 13, 2021 @02:53PM (#26126192)
Not American, but the Wikipedia entry on the incident suggests that the two aren't in any way comparable.

At the same time, sentencing a 15-year old kid (who hasn't even committed murder) to life in prison and not reconsidering it so far into the 21st century - that's cruel and unusual punishment. Boggles my mind.

Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by smcl on Saturday February 13, 2021 @04:52PM (#26127323)
I'm not sure why people are having a hard time with this one. But let's try it this way - switch the positions of the 17 year old white kid and the 15 year old black kid. Do you believe the outcomes would be the same? Do you think the black kid would get bailed after killing two people and then have (in addition to support among various gun rights groups) numerous people on HN hand-wringing and explaining that technically killing someone is actually not a crime in every circumstance? No, we'd see pics of the black kid presented as menacing, everyone would talk about him as a "young man" instead of "a little boy", any and all indiscretions he'd committed would be dug out and published everywhere and ultimately used against him.

Of course we're dealing with hypotheticals so people will play dumb and either pretend I'm being absurd or just say they'd treat both the same because that's the easy way out. But I think deep down we all know the truth.

Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by ciupicri on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:07PM (#26126316)
There's a difference between a bail and being declared not guilty. Anyway he was supposedly defending himself, while Ligon was robbing and assaulting people, so the cases are different.
Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by dionidium on Saturday February 13, 2021 @01:53PM (#26125708)
These aren’t even remotely similar cases and mentioning the Rittenhouse case here is an unnecessary and unhelpful distraction.
Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by smcl on Saturday February 13, 2021 @01:54PM (#26125717)
Why? We are discussing that one kid got 68 years for not killing someone, and another kid is probably not going to get anything close to that for killing two. Now, I know there are more things involved in crime and sentencing than whether someone killed anyone but it should be crystal clear that these are very worthy of comparison.

On the other hand you are right in one respect - they're not remotely similar in that one boy was white and the other black. I know we're not going to "solve" racism in the comments section of HN but I think it's important to confront the fact that race is an overwhelming factor in how these cases play out.

Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by marvin on Saturday February 13, 2021 @02:40PM (#26126098)
The question in the Rittenhouse case isn’t what sentence people get for murder. It’s whether he committed murder at all, or killed in self-defense after having the horrible (and probably ethically unsound) judgement to travel armed to an obviously violent event. It’s not an example of what’s being discussed.

There’s more than enough cases that legitimately make the case for racial sentencing discrimination. Quoting this ridiculously politicized case will only harm the cause by providing ammunition to the other side.

I mean, I personally think that 68 years in prison for almost anything is a horribly abusive practice. Acceptable for some few instances of violent crime. But since I also believe that killing in self-defense can sometimes be justified with no punishment, it’s not a very good point to use for discussing.

Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by 40four on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:39PM (#26126633)
This is way off topic, but I’m very curious to the outcome of the Rittenhouse trial. There is no doubt he killed those people. There are multiple videos of it. Whether or not the court finds it falls under ‘reasonable’ self defense according to Wisconsin law will be interesting.

They will have to decide that he A) He used only the force necessary to prevent or terminate interference with his person. And B) He reasonably believed that such force was necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm to himself.

Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by marvin on Saturday February 13, 2021 @06:33PM (#26128091)
My guess at this point would be that he gets convicted for having violated firearms laws, but not for murder. It's an interesting case, but the political climate surrounding it spans much more than just the shooting, and is (seen with international eyes and an attempt at staying impartial) completely bonkers.

He shouldn't have been there in the first place, and there shouldn't have been any incentive for anyone else to be either. The fact that there was a remotely plausible rationale for a vigilante policing force in the first place is just insane. That the police didn't roll up and say "go home, this is our job" is ridiculous. Then, of course, pouring fuel on the fire, the whole situation attracts a lot of people who want to commit violence - maybe including Rittenhouse himself. None of this should happen in a first-world country, and it's not something that will be solved with a murder trial. Regardless of its outcome.

There seem to be deep and persistent currents in American society that form the basis for events like these, and every honest assessment and candid dialouge attempting to fix them is a good thing. It might be off topic to a degree, but people getting life sentences willy-nilly is definitely part of the same web of causal relationships.

Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by smcl on Saturday February 13, 2021 @04:44PM (#26127252)
I don't think it is offtopic or if it is then my mention of Rittenhouse in the first place was. I am very curious too. I have a pretty bad feeling that he will get off extremely lightly and that as a result the US will see renewed unrest. Given the original topic that kicked off this thread, the unrest will be entirely justified.
Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by sdenton4 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:01PM (#26127383)
Dude kills two people while wearing a certain color hat matching other people he's spending a lot of time with...

Most of the time under those circumstances, the question of self defense isn't going to enter into the following discussion.

Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by dionidium on Saturday February 13, 2021 @06:27PM (#26128048)
Why would you invent a detail about an event that was captured on video and so easily refuted? He was wearing a white hat.
Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by smcl on Saturday February 13, 2021 @06:57PM (#26128272)
It sounds like the "color of hat" is a metaphor here
Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by dionidium on Saturday February 13, 2021 @09:07PM (#26129030)
It very clearly was not, but I hope I can at least rest my case on what a pointless distraction this subthread was destined to be.
Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by smcl on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:51AM (#26130698)
You seemed pretty keen to take part in the more pointless parts - like talking about the colour of someone’s hat - so I’m not sure you get to play that card.
Re:The nation’s oldest juvenile lifer, Joe Ligon, left priso... by giantg2 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:16PM (#26126392)
Just because a person is killed does not mean that a crime has been committed. There are lawful reasons, such as self defense, defense of a third person, etc.