Re:Stonehenge may have been built in Wales and then relocated
by throwawaylolx on Friday February 12, 2021 @06:59AM
(#26112727)
>radiocarbon dating puts the site a few hundred years older than Stonehenge
Is it really that reliable to make such precise statements?
Re:Stonehenge may have been built in Wales and then relocated
by sandworm101 on Friday February 12, 2021 @09:06AM
(#26113748)
>>Is it really that reliable to make such precise statements?
Carbon dating is never enough in itself. They are not saying that carbon dating proves that one thing happened before the other. They are saying that carbon dating does not disprove it, that the narrative they propose is not contradicted by carbon evidence. The fact that there are multi-century error bands means it can never be solid proof, but the fact that one error band is centered years later than the other does add weight to their proposed timeline. Carbon dating is a fuzzy telescope, but lack of perfect resolution doesn't mean it cannot produce useful evidence.
Re:Stonehenge may have been built in Wales and then relocated
by simonh on Friday February 12, 2021 @07:22AM
(#26112892)
Samples at the site were dated to around 3400 BC, which is 400 years earlier than the earliest samples from Stonehenge. Ive not seen the papers, but given standard techniques I expect there should be at least a couple of centuries gap between the error ranges.
Re:Stonehenge may have been built in Wales and then relocated
by yread on Friday February 12, 2021 @09:51AM
(#26114196)
They haven't used radiocarbon that much, it seems that OSL was more important
Re:Stonehenge may have been built in Wales and then relocated
by canjobear on Friday February 12, 2021 @10:33AM
(#26114735)
How do you radiocarbon-date a rock?
Re:Stonehenge may have been built in Wales and then relocated
by sandworm101 on Friday February 12, 2021 @11:05AM
(#26115100)
You date stuff associated with the rock. Digging tools found under the rock (eg worked antler). Remains of wood that was used to move the stone or line the pits. Remnants of possible associated cooking fires. If you find a deer skull or bit of leather under a large stone, it is safe to say that the two are related in time.
I'm not saying I believe them for sure, but yours is in no way a fair characterisation.