News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop defacing quotes with brackets by zeroimpl on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @06:26PM (#26083922)
Whenever I see “go home and bite [his] pillow”, I’ve always assumed the person spoke quickly and/or skipped a word, which the editor thought should be added. It never occurred to me before now that the editor actually replaced a word!
Re:Stop defacing quotes with brackets by ddingus on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @07:14PM (#26084320)
Right? Prior to this discussion, my thought was similar, typo, or something benign.

Replacing a word breaks the syntax and brings ambiguity to some use cases involving brackets and quotes that did not have it before.

As I mentioned elsewhere, a similar thing happened with the one space vs. two spaces to end a sentence.

In that last sentence, there is now ambiguity after "vs. " where there was not before. Right now I am on desktop, but if I were to input that sentence on my Android, "two" would be auto-capitalized, even though I am mid sentence.

I see this headed a similar direction.

Cases where the actual verbatim expression may be made more clear with something added in brackets will now overlap with cases where someone wants to replace a word in a quote...

Sigh :(

Re:Stop defacing quotes with brackets by titzer on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @07:06PM (#26084263)
Me too, which lowers my opinion of the speaker!