News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by jboog on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @09:23AM (#26077763)
Seems perfectly reasonable to go after someone for libel for literally committing libel.

The guy shamelessly lied and called the law firm a "scam".

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by dhosek on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @09:44AM (#26078043)
It's also worth noting that UK libel laws are considerably more liberal than the US libel laws. A statement that would be fine in the US could result in a life-shattering judgment in the UK.
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by willyt on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:37AM (#26078668)
But on the other hand we dont have punitive damages in civil law for anything. Generally, you can’t be sued for a randomly large amount of money like you can in the US. It has to be provable and direct costs of, in this case, lost business. This is probably why the judgement was for quite a small amount of money, considering how much a law firm turns over in a year. Disclaimer: I’m not a lawyer or your lawyer so there may be edge cases that I don’t know about.
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by buro9 on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:12AM (#26078348)
UK laws changed a while ago, and now you have to prove damages. I find it hard to believe that the damages proven could be attributed back to TrustPilot as I just don't believe that a significant % of people are checking TrustPilot before hiring a lawyer.
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by M2Ys4U on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:26AM (#26078515)
Here's what the judgment has to say about damages:

"Mr Bradshaw submitted that the gravity of the Defendant's libel is at least as serious as that in Monroe, and is comparable with that in Doyle. Accordingly, general damages award of £24,000 to £30,000 would be appropriate, subject to his concession that the claim was limited to £25,000.

In respect of special damages which were claimed at £300 per day, Mr Bradshaw submitted that on the basis of Ms Rhode's evidence there had been a significant reduction in enquires for a period of at least 6 weeks which would equate at £300 per day to a sum of £12,600.

In my judgment the claim for special damages is not made out. Ms Rhodes evidence is simply not directed to this point and no detailed financial or accounting evidence has been provided. Whilst I accept the Defendant has chosen not to appear and contest the figure the burden remains on the Claimant to prove its loss. I am however satisfied that reduction in the number of instructions was caused by the defamatory review and has caused the Claimant some financial loss. As Mr Justice Warby said in the case of Brett Wilson LLP v Persons unknown, responsible for the Operation and Publication of the website www.solicitorsfromhelluk.com [2015] EWHC 2628 [29] the loss of a single instruction can cost a firm tens of thousands of pounds (and in some instances more). In the circumstances I am satisfied that an award of general damages in the sum of £25,000 would adequately reflect the seriousness of the defamation, the financial loss which has occurred and the purpose of vindication."

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by pacaro on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:16AM (#26078405)
The defendant wasn't present, so the plaintiff's assertions about damages will presumably have been taken at face value. IANAL
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by evgen on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @12:13PM (#26079981)
If you read the actual case it turns out that the judge did not allow one of the two damages claims, so it was not just a case of whatever the plaintiff wanted they received.
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by cyberpunk on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @09:58AM (#26078193)
Do you mean more conservative?
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by wayneftw on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:11AM (#26078344)
Conservative would be less use of law and government, liberal would be more.
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by cyberpunk on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @11:53AM (#26079699)
Ah you mean liberal as in amount, not liberal as in more permissive. That was confusing, cheers.
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by quietbritishjim on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @12:23PM (#26080133)
> liberal would be more [use of law and government]

That is not what liberal means. In fact the confusing setence in your previous comment has basically the opposite meaning than you meant: more liberal libel laws would be less strict.

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by wayneftw on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @01:17PM (#26080768)
It wasn't my comment, but there is more than one meaning for the word liberal. [0] I was going with adjective 2. relating to or denoting a political and social philosophy that promotes individual rights, civil liberties, democracy, and free enterprise.

I took "more liberal" to mean "more left" as in the political spectrum of Left vs Right, Liberal vs Conservative because that's the only definition that really fits the context of the sentence...

Despite the fact that Liberalism has much more to do with Liberty than liberal use of government, Liberals today certainly want to use the government liberally to make new laws for solving any small discomfort.

[0] https://www.google.com/search?q=define+liberal

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by quietbritishjim on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @04:46PM (#26082761)
Maybe there's partly a cultural difference. Here in the UK, "liberal" mean would still greater freedom of speech even if you meant "liberal" in the political sense. Ironically that's probably one of the core tenants of political liberalism! By the way, the most liberal party here is in the centre politically, so it's very clear here that liberalness is not determined at all by left-rightness.

I don't claim to know as much about the difference between Republicans and Democrats as Americans themselves, but I find it very surprising to think that Democrats would oppose freedom of speech particularly more strongly - I'd actually presume it to be the other way round (maybe based on my own conflation of "liberal" in the US sense and in the original political sense).

With all that said, the way the original commenter referred to liberal as simply meaning "more ... use of law" is pretty hard for me to take seriously. Is apartheid more liberal than racial equality because it requires more laws? Come on. It comes off as an attempt to slander (ironically!) liberalism by claiming any bad law is liberal because liberalism uses laws.

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by wayneftw on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @07:05PM (#26084251)
In the US, Democrats/left/liberals are well known for trying to control speech. [0] [1] [2] They are the party of greater government and using law more liberally to control more aspects of society.

Republicans/right/conservatives are the party of small government - hence the word conservative describing them. They favor free markets, which is to say: Don't make too many laws getting in the way of business!

The very meaning of the word Conservatism is "commitment to traditional values and ideas with opposition to change or innovation." [3] Less change = less laws. The conservative right weren't the ones behind the Civil Rights movement in the US - that was the liberal left, creating more laws controlling things like school segregation and so forth.

So, I think you can see that "more (vs less) use of law" is absolutely one of the overarching themes at play in our political scene. Even as a complete layman who actively avoids politics I wasn't able to avoid this knowledge. I think you can confirm it with a few quick searches to get a feel for what kinds of things people have said about either party [4] [5] [6].

[0] https://www.americancommitment.org/content/democrats-repeal-...

[1] https://reason.com/2019/08/12/every-democrat-in-the-senate-s...

[2] https://www1.nyc.gov/site/cchr/law/legal-guidances-gender-id...

[3] https://www.google.com/search?q=define+conservatism

[4] https://www.google.com/search?q=democrats+against+freedom+of...

[5] https://www.google.com/search?q=democrats+want+to+control+ev...

[6] https://www.google.com/search?q=republicans+want+to+control+...

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by quietbritishjim on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @03:47PM (#26094550)
Those first two sources are obviously biased to an almost comical degree. They're very much of the "those horrible Democrats want to take your freedom of speech" bent. Your third link has nothing to do with freedom of speech.

Yes, conservatives favour smaller government and fewer laws - actually that term means exactly that here in British politics too. But that doesn't mean any extra laws are necessarily liberal. Go back to my example of legislated racism to see that, which is clearly not liberal (in every sense of the word) despite requiring more laws and bigger government. Like the original comment I replied to, your comment and those sources come across a shallow attempt to insult Democrats by saying "look, this bad thing would require a law, and Democrats love laws, therefore they must want this bad thing!".

Maybe in this case my distance, as an outside observer, is actually helpful. I can see pretty clearly that Democrats wanting to limit freedom of speech is a rumour that doesn't reflect what Democrats actually want.

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by wayneftw on Friday February 12, 2021 @10:39AM (#26114823)
The first 2 links cited incontrovertible evidence, I don't see much comedy in that. The third link shows a law that controls speech, which is exactly how I labeled it in my first sentence.

You're arguing with me because I made a comment that stemmed from my own perception of politics. Now that I've clearly explained the reasoning for my comment, you're contorting yourself to prove that my perception is wrong. In the face of empirical evidence you've given nothing more than your opinion.

> I can see pretty clearly that Democrats wanting to limit freedom of speech is a rumour that doesn't reflect what Democrats actually want.

They want to control speech. I've shown a law, one among many that they've enacted, which proved my point. In response to that you applied some strawman argument about it not being "freedom of speech" when nobody ever said that.

I don't think you're arguing in good faith, so I'm going to end this here.

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by jokethrowaway on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @01:34PM (#26080976)
While that's true (and I agree with your definition in the context, which is not political), the root of the misunderstanding is modern liberalism stealing the word from what is now known as classical liberalism
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by quietbritishjim on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @04:56PM (#26082883)
Even if I interpret it in a polical way, I would still take "more liberal" to mean "supports greater freedom of speech"; that's consistent with what you call classical liberalism. I hadn't heard of this "modern liberalism" until now, which seems to be an American term. But looking at the Wikipedia article [1] it doesn't seem to involve much discussion either way about freedom of speech, except to do with donations by corporations (it seems a stretch to connect that with willingness to legislate about libel). If anything, the other parts of that article still have a strong enough similarity to classical liberal principles that I would expect an American "modern" liberal to still be in favour of free speech.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modern_liberalism_in_the_Unite...

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by CydeWeys on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @11:03AM (#26079053)
There is some nuance there though as that could be mere hyperbole/figure of speech, rather than a specific allegation of unethical business practices. What hurt him more is that he didn't show up to defend himself.

Musk successfully used the hyperbole defense against the much more serious potential libel "pedo", though admittedly that was in US court.

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by oh_sigh on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @04:13PM (#26082446)
First of all, the judgement was because the guy never showed up for court. He might have won if he did.

More importantly, he called it a scam, and it isn't clear that that is a lie. He alleges that he paid for work, but they just rephrased the documents he gave them. Why wouldn't that be a scam?

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by IshKebab on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @11:04AM (#26079071)
Sure if it isn't a scam. But the article also said:

> In the review, Mr Waymouth alleged: "I paid upfront for a legal assessment of my case.

> "But what I got was just the information I sent them, reworded and sent back to me."

Which sounds pretty scammy to me.

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by jboog on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @07:16PM (#26084335)
Because certainly no one would ever lie or exaggerate on the internet!
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by henryaj on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @09:25AM (#26077786)
What lies did he tell?
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by BoorishBears on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @09:36AM (#26077945)
> He then left a review accusing the firm of being "another scam solicitor", according to court documents.

> The firm took legal action, stating that this was untrue and defamatory.

Seeing as he pulled the old "give me back my money and I'll delete that" it sure sounds like the typical leave a bad review for leverage strategy, his mistake was straight up lying.

-

I got in a dispute with an apartment management over my deposit and left a review with dozens upon dozens of well documented missteps they had taken during my tenancy complete with pictures. I didn't lie and I didn't embellish...

20 minutes later I got a call that my deposit was being refunded in full and asking if I could kindly take down my review.

I hadn't lied in it so I never took it down, but I did condense it, removed the pictures and mentioned they had returned my deposit finally.

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by mikro2nd on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:02AM (#26078249)
If I read correctly, he also didn't pitch up at court to defend his position, so the judgement went to the law firm.
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by Nasrudith on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @09:46AM (#26078066)
That is considered a lie in the UK? In the US that would be considered an obvious equivalent of "shitty and only out for themselves". Everyone already knows lawyers are master of screwing you over with contracts legally.
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by jboog on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:42AM (#26078742)
That's because it is usually perfectly legal to lie about someone in the US and just call it "hyperbole" or something. Our libel laws are incredibly permissive in the US.

See Elon Musk calling a guy a "pedo" repeatedly with zero evidence, because he pissed him off online. Although there were other issues in that case.

The UK has way more strict libel laws than the US. If you lie about someone it's a LOT easier to get a civil judgment against you. Hency why a ton of magazines/newspapers have been successfully sued over libel whereas in the US this almost never happens.

Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by leephillips on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:47AM (#26078809)
No, it would not. A “scam” is a scheme to defraud, it’s an allegation of illegality.
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by isoskeles on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @10:58AM (#26078983)
I get annoyed when I read people claim a business is a “scam” when their real problem is something clearer like the products are too expensive. Can we reserve the word “scam” for actual scams, or am I really expected to divine the true meaning of these troglodytes’ reviews? I just ignore them.
Re:Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustP... by BoorishBears on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @11:49AM (#26079630)
Scam is the go to word to try falsely throw a company under the bus without needing to go into specifics, I also ignore those reviews.

If a business really wrongs someone, people tend to be willing to go into detail about how they were wronged. Especially since it sucks and if you're willing to write a review, you're probably also willing to make it one that informs others specifically what went wrong so they can avoid it.