Well, lawyers already went there: http://www.plotpatents.com/
"A Plot or Storyline Patent application seeks to patent the underlying novel and nonobvious storyline of a fictional story. Such protection is to be contrasted from the copyright protection of one of millions of possible expressions of an underlying storyline. The field of possible applications is broad, and may tentatively be split into an entertainment-advertisement dichotomy. The epitome of an entertainment application is an original, thought-provoking, often shockingly unique movie plot. Several potentially patentable features may have been found in the plots of, Memento, The Thirteenth Floor, Being John Malkovich, Butterfly Effect, The Game, Fight Club, The Matrix, Total Recall, The Truman Show, Minority Report, The Village, Groundhog Day, and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, to name a few. The epitome of an advertisement application is one of the many thoughtfully hilarious Super Bowl commercials."
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/11/04/movie_plotline_paten... http://www.groklaw.net/articlebasic.php?story=20051103183218... (this article's link to the published application is no longer accurate)
the ... proponent's website has its own legal reasoning: http://www.plotpatents.com/about_us.htm
USPTO publication numbers for a few of their applications 20050272013 20050282140 20050255437 20050244804
You can find those on google's patent search or the USPTO's Public Pair service: http://portal.uspto.gov/external/portal/pair
And beyond just being... questionable as a type of invention, the applications seem eager to see just how broad such claims might be:
1. A process of relaying a story having a timeline and a unique plot involving characters, comprising: indicating that a first character experiences dj vu to mask an actual event.
The problem is that as soon as you put the word "software" in front of the word "patent" during a discussion you can actually see eyes glaze over and brains shut off in the person you are talking to.
It's just easier for representatives to ignore this. That or they see the issue as niche, and therefore don't pay attention.
Yes, the same ridiculous rules that apply to software MUST apply to something more mainstream so that it gets noticed.
People have disputed the originality of movie ideas including Matrix [0] and Harry Potter [1].
[0] http://blogcritics.org/video/article/author-sues-matrix-writ...
[1] http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2010/02/18/entertainment/main...
So to clarify: Saying two different movies both of which has the "friend turns out to be bad" are copies is wrong; that's just not enough of a similarity to base a copyright case on. However, if you happen to find a way to patent it (which you probably could if there hasn't been prior art), you would be able to sue for patent infringement.
Doubtful. But, given that if diversity in movie plots benefits mankind (!) then offering an incentive to develop a new plot could be worth it. If the plot is entirely disclosed so that it can be used for free by anyone in a few years then is this not a benefit?
Say you've got a popular photo, you can transfer the litigious rights of it to a copyright troll and that troll will then sue everyone using it.
Kind of like what RIAA is doing.
mluiten might be referring to the fact that copyright only applies to "original works of authorship fixed in a tangible medium of expression." (See http://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-general.html)
That is, copyrights don't cover ideas, but creative works in some fixed form (e.g., a painting or a piece of software).
I'd like to introduce the concept of Movie Patents. I'd register a patent for the plot device of having the bad guy be the main character's best friend, with additional clauses for being his boss, advisor, or partner. I wouldn't ever make any movies. I'd just sit back and collect royalties from everybody who used my idea.
The reason behind this is that maybe then people who matter would actually notice how silly this concept is. It's so plainly obvious that it's a bad idea that regular people can finally understand what's going on. Eventually, people with the ability to make changes might actually find themselves forced to make changes.
Software, as big as it is, is just not that big. This issue can piss every single one of us off, and it won't make the NBC Nightly News. It can't piss off the people it needs to piss off in order to get it fixed, so chances are it will stay unfixed indefinitely.