News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by ineedasername on Saturday February 06, 2021 @04:18PM (#26050032)
News organizations have an obligation to report on what they believe to be true. This entails a judgement on whether or not something is disinformation.
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by LocalH on Saturday February 06, 2021 @05:25PM (#26050598)
> News organizations have an obligation to report on what they believe to be true.

They have an obligation to report facts and world events, regardless of what they believe to be true. At least in a US context, the infusion of opinion and bias into news that CNN jumpstarted is a cancer that I feel is directly responsible for the highly polarized state of the US.

Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by ineedasername on Sunday February 07, 2021 @11:51PM (#26060911)
It's not a fact if it isn't true. Disinformation and misinformation both often take the form of something stated factually. So there must necessarily be some judgment and evaluation of the truth value of everything they report. There is also the judgment involved in deciding what to report: there is an infinity of things that happen every day.

There is no avoiding the need for judgment in news reporting. Any process of judgement may be biased. An institution may itself have biases, and these will make there way in the judgments made there.

The idea that news organizations can simply and objectively report on facts and world events is functionally impossible. What you want are honest judgements made with an awareness of potential bias, knowing it can never be completely removed. As consumers of news, we should look for the organizations that seek to do that, and preferably read/view a variety of they present to us a more complete picture despite the differences in the judgements they make.

Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by AgentME on Saturday February 06, 2021 @06:07PM (#26050981)
I'm legitimately surprised someone could type this out but then make it about any news station other than Fox.
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by LocalH on Saturday February 06, 2021 @06:42PM (#26051237)
CNN first broadcast on June 1, 1980. Fox News Channel didn't exist until October 7, 1996. Many of the most pervasive problems with all cable news started with CNN. It's hard to fill 24 hours with pure news, so opinion got added to the mix, such that now primetime is all about the opinion. As a sibling comment stated, Fox just beat them at their own game in that sense.

It seems like public discourse is by and large worse off due to the way news media is structured. In the drive for viewers and ratings, the media has become extremely polarizing. People make it a badge of pride that they don't watch X or Y network. You expose that a bit as well when you assume that the words I wrote should only apply to Fox. All cable news media is problematic in this day and age.

Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by lmickh on Saturday February 06, 2021 @06:27PM (#26051136)
CNN and 24hr cable news has not been good for journalism. Opinion pundits responding to events before the facts can even be collected along with daily shows interweaving narratives pre-dates Fox News. Fox News played their game more blatantly ruthless than the others and beat them at their own game.
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by ineedasername on Sunday February 07, 2021 @11:54PM (#26060931)
It seems to me that CNN accidentally stumbled on to this problem, while when Fox News came along they cynically embraced it as a revenue generator. For CNN it began as a bug, Fox made it a feature.
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by dbcurtis on Saturday February 06, 2021 @06:50PM (#26051283)
I think your statement says more about what you are prepared to believe, than about any notion of absolute truth. MSNBC is often a mirror of Fox in equally (un)believable proportion.

When I was young, I got into short-wave listening. This was during the Viet Nam war. I used to listen to the English language news from Radio Moscow, then the news from Voice of America, just for the sheer, rollicking entertainment value of the ideological whiplash. I suggest a similar exercise using modern context -- it will sharpen your BS detector.

Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by dbcurtis on Saturday February 06, 2021 @06:42PM (#26051236)
> News organizations have an obligation to report on what they believe to be true.

Please..... harden and sharpen the edge of your critical thinking skills. News organizations are business entities first. The idea of "just the facts" news reporting idealism is a curiously mid-20th century American idea, and even then was only a facade.

Historically, news organizations have always had a point of view. And advertisers to please -- or at the very least maximize the audience that their advertisers could reach.

News organizations have an obligation to pay the rent and make payroll, just like any other business. Beyond that... I remain skeptical.

Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by pixl97 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @04:54PM (#26050347)
>News organizations have an obligation to report on what they believe to be true

Please state where this obligation is documented?

At least in the US (and yes, I realize this is a global site) the vast majority of news organizations have the obligation to make a profit. See "Manufacturing Consent".

Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by killjoywashere on Saturday February 06, 2021 @05:20PM (#26050550)
Their subscribers and advertisers can exert profit influence. And the law, via laws against libel and slander can be used to impose civil penalties (perhaps criminal as well).

I believe you will find 28USC4101 and 47USC588 of particular interest. Fun fact, you are actually accountable for infractions of law whether you know the law or not. Now, either 1) your question was borne out of genuine ignorance; I suspect this is exceedingly unlikely as it would tend to indicate you are incompetent (unless you care to dispute this point) or 2) you posed the question with malicious intent for the purpose of tearing down our common understanding of civil society. Which is it?

Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by pixl97 on Sunday February 07, 2021 @10:24AM (#26055603)
As to address your claim of 2, I do believe by observation that society is not as civil as you believe. I did not tear it down myself, but forces seeking profit have.

Liable and slander are notoriously hard to prove in US courts and use of weasel words commonly let bad actors off the hook in cases.

Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by throwawayboise on Saturday February 06, 2021 @05:28PM (#26050643)
So we have CNN "news" and Fox "news" reporting diametrically opposite things. Both cannot be true, yet both claim to report the truth. One, or more likely both, are false, and the truth is somewhere in the middle.
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by CuriousSkeptic on Saturday February 06, 2021 @06:11PM (#26051010)
I don’t think it’s even in the middle. News organization make money on fear and anger. So most of them seem to agree that you should be afraid of angry about something. Interpolating between news sources still leaves you at risk of fear and anger that in reality is entirely unwarranted.
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by prox on Saturday February 06, 2021 @05:41PM (#26050745)
Not necessarily in the middle, but skewed where it is advantageous to its backers. For instance, Russia Today seems to have decent reporting until it comes to smearing or undercutting the US, or promoting it’s interests.
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by trianglem on Sunday February 07, 2021 @01:59AM (#26053241)
I think it’s skewed asymmetrically and much closer to CNN’s version rather than Fox News’
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by briantakita on Saturday February 06, 2021 @04:30PM (#26050121)
In today's infotainment environment, the sanctioned judges of misinformation often perpetuate misinformation to stay in business. When multiple sides aside each other of perpetrating misinformation, regulating the market creates a favorable environment for entrenched market leaders, shutting out dissenting voices from the market.
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by refurb on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:05PM (#26051703)
Exactly. Like the Iraq War. Damn near every paper touted the “Saddam has WMD!”.

And they were wrong.

That’s why we need to allow dissent.

Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by _-david-_ on Saturday February 06, 2021 @11:54PM (#26052756)
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by refurb on Sunday February 07, 2021 @01:28AM (#26053126)
Not the ones that were the rationale for invading. Your article even says so "An initial glance at the WikiLeaks war logs doesn't reveal evidence of some massive WMD program by the Saddam Hussein regime -- the Bush administration's most (in)famous rationale for invading Iraq."
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by _-david-_ on Sunday February 07, 2021 @02:10PM (#26057273)
And? You said it was wrong that Saddam had WMD. That was incorrect.
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by konjin on Saturday February 06, 2021 @04:28PM (#26050098)
So say News Corp is lead by a racist, sexist, homophone it is their duty to be racist, sexist and homophobic?

The only people who think they can say everything they think and not be purged for it are people who don't think much at all.

Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by squidlogic on Saturday February 06, 2021 @04:42PM (#26050237)
Welcome to life in a free society. The alternative is a ministry of truth run by the same flawed humans who they portend to protect us against.
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by hpcjoe on Saturday February 06, 2021 @05:09PM (#26050472)
Minitrue, or reality czar. Same basic thing. Exclude (and cancel) those who disagree or do not conform.

This is a very dangerous time in the US.

Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by BuyMyBitcoins on Saturday February 06, 2021 @05:19PM (#26050547)
“HackerNews user makes baseless allegation that the ministry of truth is dangerous.”

(!) Learn how controlling misinformation is beneficial for society.

Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by hpcjoe on Saturday February 06, 2021 @05:28PM (#26050634)
Oh dear, I may be a candidate for a gulag^H^H^H^H^Hre-education camp. As seems to be a narrative trending in some circles.
Re:The war on disinformation is a war on dissent by dane-pgp on Saturday February 06, 2021 @04:44PM (#26050257)
> say News Corp is lead by a racist, sexist, homophone

You mean someone like Ray Zystzeciez?