Yet we still have chiropractors and homeopathy.
Not the case?
Further, many studies have found weak effects, no effects, and negative effects. When you see this kind of evidential pattern, it almost always means that the effect isn't real and we're just seeing experimental error. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chiropractic#Evidential_basis
That said, the placebo effect for something like chiropracty or massage can be very strong - and the placebo effect is real! Giving someone a saline shot creates a stronger effect than giving them a sugar pill; I don't know where chiropracty exists on that spectrum.
The article doesn't say it's locked, but I see no edit button.
I was trying to replace "Opinions differ as to the efficacy of chiropractic treatment" with "Opinions differ as to the ability of chiropractic treatment to produce an effect", because I have a grudge against overly complicated language.
Also, if you look to the top right corner of the page, there's a lock icon that shows the article is semi-protected. You can't edit it without logging in.
Edit: http://www.chirobase.org/05RB/CPSQ/02.html -- More information that looks like something I have read.
Edit2: http://www.chirobase.org/01General/controversy.html -- "NACM members publicly renounce the subluxation theory and other forms of chiropractic pseudomedicine." Interesting stuff. What I read: There is a portion of "chiropractic medicine" that is snake oil; how do I identify what is real? Are NACM members better informed?
Meanwhile, I had some back pain and started doing pilates and it evaporated, because now my core can actually hold my backbone up.
/plural of anecdote is not data
No one is debating that. What we're debating is whether chiropractic is medicine.
That said, most of its relieving effect is due to the placebo effect, and there is no evidence saying that it can do anything for you other than possibly reduce pain.
How did you get "most of its relieving effect is due to the placebo effect" from the article?
There is still debate on whether real or fake acupuncture is better. (Studies have come down on both sides of this issue.) However pretty much everyone who has tried to study the subject has found that both real and fake acupuncture have a definite impact on pain. Frequently both will outperform conventional medicine. For a random example see http://featuresblogs.chicagotribune.com/features_julieshealt....
From that I know that there is a readily measurable benefit to acupuncture, another readily measurable benefit to the placebo, and the difference between the two benefits is difficult to measure. Which leads me to conclude that most of the benefit from acupuncture is due to the placebo effect, and only (possibly) a little is because acupuncture itself is effective.
It might not be medicine, but it's not snake-oil either.
The optimal thing to do would be to keep adding more testing until the benefits of the latest delta drop to equal their costs. However, all the economic research on this topic that I've read suggests that while we need some testing we're way over the optimal point. Its the same sort of research that lets you publish papers on how the optimal copyright length is 14 years.
The same sort of ratchet effects are involved in both places too. The only people who care passionately about copyright lengths are those who have copyrights that are about to expire. The people who could have benefited from a work going out of copyright are often only dimly aware of it. Likewise when the FDA approves a drug that causes problems its obvious and there are a lot of people complaining, but when they don't approve a drug that could have helped someone - or when drug developers are scared off - people aren't as aware of it.
* Evaluations take a really long time. So it's hard to get the drugs into the hands of people.
* Development is now extremely expensive. That forces just about everyone except the largest drug mega-corporations out of the market.
* Drugs that would be a net benefit to the world sometimes never make it through the entire process because the ROI isn't good enough, or the associated side effects are deemed too harsh. (We would likely not have aspirin today if it hadn't been developed prior to the modern way of drug development... it has too many high-risk side effects)
--
On the plus side:
* The drugs you do get are generally far safer and better understood than they otherwise would be
* You can feel safe that each batch of the drug was made the same way, using the same process, and ends up having the same strength/effectiveness as every other batch of the same drug... even when made by a different company. (We take that for granted now... but it's actually a really big deal if you look at medication from a historical perspective.)
* We have far fewer snake-oil salesmen ripping people off for cures that are, at best, useless and at worst, cause the condition to get worse, or cause birth defects, or some other harm. If we do find the drug doing harm, it gets pulled off the market