It’s why we re not using smtp for chat. SMTP can’t be extended enough so replacements are built instead. Similarly if signal federated, eventually it would freeze and a few years later users would move to wherever they could get new features.
Federation is a good thing but only when the protocol is finished or if there is a forcing mechanism to allow updates to the protocol. ethereum/Bitcoin are good examples as they have flag days that force the value of currency to be in the balance to keep the protocol moving forward.
Im not sure "chat" needs this much constant "innovation" at the protocol level. Most of the issues with email are client UX more so than actual protocol limitations.
I think XMPP is a better comparison than SMTP. In its heyday, XMPP had several clients, some with different proprietary extensions, and all the core functionality basically worked across all the clients. Though it turns out some of the messengers I thought were XMPP were actually different protocols that XMPP could work with. Imagine that. People still use it too, though it's not as popular as it was in the 2000s.
Moxie, one of the original authors of the Signal protocol, said federation severely restricted flexibility and so they had to move on: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11668912
Agreeing on and keeping some spec up to date is a solved problem. Just ask any web standards committee.
Do any SMTP servers still allow organic routing? I was under the impression that all modern servers have extremely cumbersome auth/dkim and its hard to not be GMail and still send a real msg and have it arrive
Without federation, Signal is just another stepping stone in the long path of eventually abandoned instant messengers, all the way back from ICQ. We will get to an SMTP-like protocol, and email-like service, at some point. If not Signal, some other one.